Listener
Opinion

Anna Fifield: As the EU widens its circle, would NZ look to join?

Anna Fifield
Opinion by
Anna Fifield was a foreign correspondent for 20 years. She now writes on foreign affairs for the Listener and her Between Giants newsletter, and hosts RNZ/Newsroom's The Detail.
Best of friends: Europe’s Ursula von der Leyen and Canadian PM Mark Carney. Photo / Getty Images
Best of friends: Europe’s Ursula von der Leyen and Canadian PM Mark Carney. Photo / Getty Images

Many people – including European diplomats and Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney – seemed surprised last month when European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said she was opening the door for Canada to be the first “associate member” of the EU.

Canada is, after all, an entire ocean away from Europe.

Perhaps, then, it was even more surprising when the European Parliament president, Roberta Metsola, swiftly suggested Australia and New Zealand could eventually follow. We are not an ocean but an entire hemisphere away.

The idea seems half-baked. There’s currently no such category of membership, and creating one in the 27-member bloc, which has the bureaucratic metabolism of a geriatric sloth, will require a treaty change that will not be easy. It’s also unclear what benefits and responsibilities associate membership would confer.

But the very suggestion underscores how alliances are rapidly changing in the hurly-burly of 2026. It was only in January that Carney stood before the World Economic Forum in Davos and declared the world order to be in a state of “rupture” and urged “middle powers” to work together.

Since then, we’ve seen Donald Trump in the US pick fights with allies – Carney recently said he seriously wondered whether Trump would take military action against Canada – Canada! – and kowtow to strongmen like China’s Xi Jinping and Kim Jong Un of North Korea.

Trump was, of course, incensed by the idea of a closer EU-Canada relationship, but Carney said he was not interested in great power rivalry. “We are pursuing resilience so that no one can control our open markets, impair our sovereignty, threaten our territorial integrity, or undermine our freedoms, our democracies, our rule of law,” he said.

A closer relationship would involve moving beyond their existing free trade agreement and their security and defence partnership to create an “alliance for the future,” von der Leyen said. This could mean closer co-operation on science and universities, for example.

Although it’s unclear whether this will actually happen, the idea of New Zealand joining is intriguing.

“There are countries with which we want to deepen our relationship,” Metsola said, citing New Zealand and Australia. Singapore and Japan have also been mentioned. “In such times of uncertainty, having friends matters.”

Matthias Matthijs, an expert on European political economy at the Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies in Washington, said there were synergies. “Neither Canada, nor Australia, nor New Zealand could join the EU under the current treaties, but it is clear they share most of Europe’s strategic interests and political values,” he said.

Our government hasn’t responded – no doubt worried Trump might notice if we were interested. And we already have a free-trade agreement with the EU, signed in 2023, and close co-operation on a number of other areas.

Perhaps we should be asking ourselves a different question. Instead of focusing on the undefined “associate member” label, we could view this moment as an opportunity to bolster our connection to Europe and stop treating it primarily as a trade relationship.

Because, as the global ripples caused by the Strait of Hormuz energy crisis have shown, geography is becoming less relevant. Values – such as upholding international law – and interests increasingly bind countries together.

As Carney correctly spotted at the beginning of the year, mid-sized nations (and small ones, too) need more relationships and stronger ones to avoid depending too heavily on any one. In the age of Trump and shifting geopolitical plates, that looks like a good diplomatic insurance policy.

It may seem like a long shot for New Zealand right now. A year ago, it would have seemed a fanciful idea for Canada, too.