Anna Fifield: What happened to our “independent” foreign policy?

The sinking of the Rainbow Warrior in 1985 is etched in my brain as one of the seminal events of my life as a young New Zealander.
I was 9 at the time, but I remember it – and the shock waves it sent through our country – so vividly.
The enduring nature of our nuclear-free resolve, practically imprinted into our DNA now, was underlined recently when Prime Minister Christopher Luxon quickly shut down Defence Minister Chris Penk’s suggestion that we might have a “conversation” about our nuclear-free status.
When I was growing up in the 1980s, I had a sense of New Zealand as a brave little country that stood up for what was right and could say uncomfortable things to our friends, even when it brought significant consequences.
A little country whose leader could demolish his American debating opponent with the immortal line: “I can smell the uranium on [your breath] as you lean towards me!” For my generation, that was a catchphrase for our willingness to take on the big guy.
I’ve been thinking about this moment quite a lot recently as I’ve wondered what happened to our “independent” foreign policy – and what it would take to get it back again.
Politicians of all stripes like to go on about our independent foreign policy, although every country – even Belarus – would say it has an independent foreign policy.
But it feels like we are a long way from a time when we could tell our security ally that we wouldn’t budge on our principles and were prepared to rupture our cornerstone alliance for them.
Now, we are being squeezed on two fronts, making it all the more dangerous to navigate, and all the more difficult to be genuinely independent.
Our economic dependence on China, which buys more from New Zealand than the United States and Australia combined, shapes what our leaders feel able to say on issues that matter to us, whether on human rights or military activities in our backyard.
Of course, I don’t think New Zealand politicians should be railing publicly and angrily at Beijing, but we could be doing more, respectfully and politely behind the scenes.
That has started to change over the past year or so, but alas, we are still a long way from having an independent foreign policy.
That’s because we now seem more concerned that we might be similarly squeezed by the US and its erratic President. There is basis to that fear: Trump has just announced a 50% tariff on Canada, apparently in relation to alleged discrimination of American cars, alcohol and dairy. He also threatened to impose a full trade embargo on Spain in response to its refusal to allow the US to use its bases to strike Iran.
But our pro-American government has not acted in our national interest: it has not condemned the blatant violation of international law, over Iran, or the subsequent flouting of the laws of the sea that are so vital to faraway island nations like ours.
Having an independent foreign policy was never a policy of neutrality.
It’s about being able to make individual decisions based on what we consider right on each occasion.
How do we get back to a position where we can be independent in our decision-making?
Bolstering our economic resilience would be a good start. We need to diversify our markets and the products we sell. Less milk powder, more GPS-connected cow collars.
Raw logs are not the future; aerospace is. We can occupy valuable niches and enjoy the freedom that comes with being needed. Then we would have much more latitude to operate according to our values.
We have mana in the world. We are still known as the plucky little country with a strong, principled spine. We shouldn’t need to be so anxious.