Analysis

Rugby Summit explained: What’s behind the growing dispute between NZR and the provinces

Gregor Paul
Analysis by
Rugby analyst and feature writer
Northland's Joshua Goodhue receives the ball from a line out during an NPC clash with Otago. Photo / Photosport
Northland's Joshua Goodhue receives the ball from a line out during an NPC clash with Otago. Photo / Photosport

The best rugby story of the year has not been the resurrection of the old school international tour, but the drama and intrigue delivered by the NPC.

To see Northland reach the final, a province with comparatively limited means and resources, is perhaps the single most compelling piece of evidence that the competition now has an embedded equity that ensures a fair, nationwide distribution of talent and that all 14 provinces can hold realistic ambition about winning a title.

The majority view within the provinces appears to be that it is the $1.1 million salary cap which is regulating the player market, but that is only partially – if at all – responsible for driving talent distribution.

The more significant mechanism is the direct contracting model that allows players to sign with any Super Rugby club and yet play for any province – a change introduced a decade ago.

The previous system came with geographic restrictions about where individuals had to play their provincial rugby to be eligible for specific Super Rugby teams and it clustered talent in the urban centres and effectively created a two-tier NPC that was consistently dominated by Auckland, Waikato, Wellington, Canterbury and Otago.

And this is why the rise and rise of Northland could hardly have been more timely. It serves as a kind of cautionary tale as to why the provinces are fearful about being dragged back to a world they felt they had left behind.

Following the so-called “Rugby Summit” earlier this month in which New Zealand Rugby sought stakeholder feedback about various possible changes to elite men’s competitions, the proposal to merge the urban provincial centres with their respective Super Rugby clubs appears to be almost a fait accompli.

This is going back to a system that was deemed to have failed, but NZR’s executive and board are thought to like the proposal because it will clarify that high-performance development is the responsibility of the Super Rugby clubs.

It may also lead to a centralisation and reduction of management, administrative, executive, and governance functions and therefore be useful in the national body’s quest to find $20m of annual cost savings.

Northland's Heremaia Murray celebrates after scoring a try in the NPC semi-final against Otago. Photo / Photosport
Northland's Heremaia Murray celebrates after scoring a try in the NPC semi-final against Otago. Photo / Photosport

But there is concern among the provincial unions that the proposal will cluster talent in the urban centres, scepticism about NZR’s motivation and fears that it is a precursor to more radical change to the NPC.

This is why all 14 unions have signed a letter that was sent to NZR last week asking for it to press pause on its plans and to provide a detailed case to support the rationale for amalgamation.

Once again, it seems that the game is at an impasse where the national body wants to go in one direction and its provincial union membership, another.

Are provincial unions right to be concerned about the future direction of the NPC?

To some extent the concerns are valid. The amalgamation proposal has come around after being a one-line recommendation in the Men’s Pathways and Competitions Project [MPAC], that was completed earlier last year.

It said: “Amalgamate each of New Zealand’s five Super Rugby clubs with the provincial unions in which they are based, thereby removing duplication, creating simplicity and clarity of responsibility and accountability, and resolving destructive tensions that exist currently.”

The logic seems sound, but the unions say they still haven’t seen any business case to support the change and nor have they been presented with any details about how amalgamated entities would work in practice.

But really, what the letter the unions have written is illustrating, is their historic distrust of NZR.

It signals that they carry unfounded fears that the NPC is going to be radically altered in format and that there are rational fears about losing their high-performance status within the ecosystem. One won’t happen, the other will.

It also alludes to the probability that some provinces are trying to buy time to promote their alternative idea of blowing up Super Rugby and turning the NPC into a fully professional eight-10 team competition.

Blues players celebrate a Super Rugby win over the Reds. Photo / Photosport
Blues players celebrate a Super Rugby win over the Reds. Photo / Photosport

That the unions are wary about NZR’s motives and intentions is understandable. It was only three years ago that former NZR chief executive Mark Robinson said: “Regardless of the Silver Lake injection of capital into the game, the model we’ve got at the moment is not fit for purpose.”

Since then, much of the dialogue between NZR and the provinces has been about the former reducing its funding, with $1.8m budget cuts landing in 2024 and 2025.

Now, NZR has revealed that it has a $20m black hole in its accounts and is believed to be talking generally about all areas of the game accepting a 5%-7% funding cut.

However, unions feel that the NPC is not an obvious contributor to that debt – the competition has been collectively profitable in nine of the past 10 years – and yet it feels like its head, to some degree, is on the chopping block when there are more obvious places to look for cost savings.

It is also now working well as a competition that engages with its respective communities.

Figures released after the round-robin revealed that there had been a 57% rise in attendance compared with 2025 and that the co-exclusive broadcast deal between Sky and TVNZ saw the broadcast audience jump into the low millions, with digital engagement almost doubling.

Harry Wilson of the Reds during the Super Round clash in Christchurch. Photo / Photosport
Harry Wilson of the Reds during the Super Round clash in Christchurch. Photo / Photosport

This building angst and perceived sense of persecution that the unions clearly feel is, though, a little misplaced and devoid of self-awareness. It’s even a little paranoid.

In 2015, NZR funding accounted for 27% of provincial unions’ revenue, whereas now, it makes up 42%. Also, much of the financial pain NZR is feeling relates to the equity deal done with US fund manager Silver Lake – an agreement that has failed to deliver the promised spike in income and has saddled the game with annual interest payments of $10.5m.

The unions, who shared a $38m windfall, not only voted unanimously in favour of the deal, they also, despite being warned by the Players’ Association – which had taken out an injunction at the High Court to stop it going ahead – not to agree to taking an additional $62m of Silver Lake funding in 2023 as it would likely lead to NZR having to cut annual distributions.

Every stakeholder is complicit in creating the financial pain the game is now experiencing, and the unions are not being specifically or unfairly targeted.

Nor, as the Herald understands it, does NZR have any intention to radically change the NPC.

It wants to trim costs where it can, while retaining the engagement the NPC is generating, and therefore it is almost certain to stay as a 14-team competition, but with less centralised funding.

What does amalgamation entail?

In essence, amalgamation in the urban centres means putting the Super Rugby club at the apex of the region – in charge of high-performance from talent identification to player development programmes to career pathways.

The provincial unions would remain in the NPC, but the administration, management, governance and high-performance functions would all come under the Super Rugby club.

This would provide clearer pathways for elite players and stronger and more consistent development programmes.

It would also cut costs by removing duplication – but NZR has provided no detail on how exactly it envisages combined entities operating.

Partly, that detail has not been provided because it doesn’t exist. That can be worked out in time – and each region left to agree on the specifics of how it merges functions and how it operates rather than a unified model being imposed.

The immediate mission is to establish the macro framework which will confirm a three-tier structure that assigns the NPC as a community competition and Super Rugby as the elite, professional gateway to the All Blacks.

Hawke's Bay first five-eighths Harry Godfrey clears the ball in the unsuccessful Ranfurly Shield challenge against Counties Manukau in Pukekohe. Photo / Photosport.
Hawke's Bay first five-eighths Harry Godfrey clears the ball in the unsuccessful Ranfurly Shield challenge against Counties Manukau in Pukekohe. Photo / Photosport.

Each tier will have a clear identity and purpose and corresponding funding streams and resource structures.

The unions say this is a return to a system that had to be broken up a decade ago because it made the urban provinces all powerful – and they fear it will spark an inequitable distribution of talent again.

But the salary cap and direct contracting model serve as protective measures against that happening, and the union’s real concern may be that they simply don’t like the idea of Super Rugby clubs having full responsibility for high-performance programmes.

And this also hints at the other major problem – that there are thought to be deeply rooted personality clashes between key provincial and key Super Rugby club personnel, and therefore no unanimity as to which individuals should be appointed to run amalgamated entities.

There are too many low-trust relationships between union and Super Rugby executive personnel for NZR to expect that mergers could happen without rancour and objection.

Is the professionalisation and creation of an eight-10 team NPC a realistic possibility?

Most sources that the Herald has talked to are a hard no on ditching the Australians, blowing up Super Rugby and creating a fully professional, smaller NPC.

They all say it would be detrimental to the All Blacks’ high-performance ability on the global stage, and that there are not enough players, commercial sponsors or broadcast value to make a domestic competition viable.

However, this idea was tabled at the “Rugby Summit” and therefore must have supporters somewhere within the provincial network.

Again, the issue here is that if there are unions with a desire to run professional teams in a professional domestic competition, it alludes to ego and ambition being a likely barrier to harmonious and functional relationships with Super Rugby clubs.

What happens now?

Nothing changes in regard to the timeline NZR set down in its “Rugby Summit Pre-Read” document.

NZR chief executive Steve Lancaster and chairman David Kirk are believed to be hosting a call with the unions ahead of the next board meeting on October 23 – to answer questions raised in the letter.

But the plan remains for a preferred option to be identified and approved by the NZR board at its final meeting of the year on December 9.