All Blacks: Richie Mo’unga’s arrival pressures Ruben Love’s playmaking progress

All Blacks coach Dave Rennie said Ruben Love was excited by the arrival of Richie Mo'unga to the All Blacks camp. Photo / Photosport
Liam Napier and Elliott Smith discuss Richie Mo’unga’s comeback and the All Blacks team to play the Bulls.

Richie Mo’unga’s arrival in South Africa creates a delicate dynamic for the All Blacks to manage. Not solely for this tour but, progressively, through to next year’s World Cup.

Through his transparent, level-headed approach, though, Dave Rennie appears well placed to navigate this potentially sensitive juncture.

title="https://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/rugby/all-blacks/all-blacks-v-sharks-player-ratings-dave-rennies-weapons-that-should-worry-the-springboks-opinion/premium/AFA5F6LYFVA7DJU5CGY5T7EYGE/">Ruben Love’s emergence as the first-choice All Blacks playmaker is one of the success stories of the test season.

After watching Love commit to first-five and help guide the Hurricanes to their first Super Rugby title in a decade, Rennie threw him the keys and backed him to seize the All Blacks’ reins.

In his four starts for the All Blacks this year, Love has repaid that faith to confirm he is the long-term future at No 10.

Love’s evolution as the backline director remains in its infancy but his instinctive vision, inherent confidence, pace, decision-making, exceptional goal-kicking, aerial ability and defence have all been evident.

Love will retain the first-five mantle to start the first test against the Springboks at Ellis Park next week, once the All Blacks complete the Bulls match in Pretoria on Sunday morning (NZT). That much is guaranteed.

Beyond that, though, Mo’unga’s belated boarding pass, after receiving NZ Rugby board approval to join the South African tour to replace injured Hurricanes centre Billy Proctor, elevates pressure on Love to perform each week.

Rennie is astute enough to know there are two ways ripping the Band-Aid off could play out. He could let Mo’unga become the unsettling elephant in the room or confront it head on.

Mo’unga’s presence will inevitably shake up the playmaking pecking order and compromise game time for others on this tour – Love, Beauden Barrett, Damian McKenzie and Josh Jacomb.

The All Blacks is, however, an elite professional environment. Competition is part of the gig across all positions. The more world-class talent, the better.

How Rennie communicates and manages this situation dictates whether he will retain buy-in from the players he’s instilled confidence in thus far this season. And by prioritising explaining Mo’unga’s selection rationale to his playmakers, Rennie should ensure he will not destabilise unified team culture for one player.

“I met with all four 10s yesterday morning before I’d spoken to Richie,” Rennie explained after naming his team to play the Bulls.

“I wanted them to understand my job as head coach is to pick the best players available. Razor was involved in bringing Richie home and he mentioned to Ruben about it.

“Yesterday Ruben was saying how good it will be to have him in as a chance to learn. At the moment it’s been Ruben’s jersey, he’s going well and we’re happy with that. It will be good competition but all four 10s are really supportive of the decision.”

The battle between Love and Mo’unga will be fascinating in the coming weeks and months.

History suggests Mo’unga will need time to find his feet and regain his best form after spending the past three seasons in Japan, which, while improving as a domestic competition, remains a long way from the test arena.

Love doesn’t boast Mo’unga’s experience but he will grow with time in the saddle.

Rennie, in an ideal world, wanted Mo’unga in the All Blacks squad from the outset of his tenure. But having committed to an 18-month homecoming rather than two years, NZ Rugby maintained its steadfast stance that Mo’unga must first play a full provincial season before becoming eligible for the All Blacks.

Love’s performance curve has since shifted selection perceptions to pencil his presence in the coveted pivot role.

The question now is for how long.

Mo’unga’s initial challenge is that, to this point under Rennie, the All Blacks are yet to select first-five cover on the bench, with McKenzie satisfying that need from fullback.

 Left to right: Josh Jacomb, Beauden Barrett, Richie Mo'unga, Damian McKenzie, Ruben Love. Photos / Photosport
Left to right: Josh Jacomb, Beauden Barrett, Richie Mo'unga, Damian McKenzie, Ruben Love. Photos / Photosport

“We felt Richie coming in and immersing himself, getting his head around the structures and details, would be really beneficial,” Rennie said. “He’s a player who is good enough to apply pressure for selection at some stage.

“The thinking is it wouldn’t be in the first test but he might get game time against the Lions [the tour match between the first and second Springboks tests] to start pushing a claim then.

“I’m not sure when he’ll play test footy for us but coming in now, spending time in the environment will accelerate that opportunity.

“We’re really happy with how Ruben has been going, with Damian, who we’re predominantly using at 15, Beauden and even Josh who gets a chance to start at the weekend [against the Bulls]. It’s about creating depth in those positions. Richie brings a lot of experience but he’s going to have to earn the right.”

Rennie’s messaging is on point.

Mo’unga’s arrival after the three South African provincial matches, and Love’s form, dictates the young prodigy will retain the responsibility to run the All Blacks cutter.

Rennie appears unlikely to risk stunting Love’s confidence and development by rushing Mo’unga into the test team but everything must be earned through performances.

The wider playmaking picture is set to become complicated, too, as Mo’unga sparks an imminent squeeze.

The All Blacks are expected to send up to eight players home from South Africa before venturing to Baltimore for their fourth, money-making test against the Springboks.

Jacomb, after savouring the once-in-a-lifetime experience that this South African tour entails, could be among that contingent.

For the remainder of their campaign, in the two Bledisloe Cup fixtures and four Nations Championship tests in the UK in November, the All Blacks will then question whether they have room for Love, Mo’unga, McKenzie and Barrett in the same congested squad.

Rennie has dealt with Mo’unga’s call-up in the right manner. His honest internal communication cultivates respect but the difficult conversations are just beginning as the All Blacks playmaking puzzle ever evolves.

Liam Napier is a Senior Sports Journalist and Rugby Correspondent for the New Zealand Herald. He is a co-host of the Rugby Direct podcast.

Listen to Elliott Smith’s live commentary on Newstalk ZB Sport and iHeartRadio, or join the Alternative Commentary Collective on iHeartRadio and Radio Hauraki.