All Blacks: Dave Rennie’s selection headache with five No 10s after Richie Mo’unga return

Dave Rennie has five number 10s to choose from during the All Blacks tour of South Africa. Photo / Photosport
Sport Headlines | Thursday, August 13, 2026. NBA team the Los Angeles Lakers has been sold for more than $21b. Video / NZ Herald

Richie Mo’unga’s return to the All Blacks has been confirmed, with the first five-eighths taking the injured Billy Proctor’s place on New Zealand’s tour of South Africa.

The addition means that coach Dave Rennie now has five No 10s to choose from and, with the first test against the Springboks fast approaching, here’s a look at how each compare.

Ruben Love

Matches: 9 / Points: 60

The Hurricanes playmaker has been Rennie’s first-choice first five-eighths since taking charge and has been consistent with his goalkicking, slotting 15 of his shots at goal during the Nations Championship.

The 25-year-old continued his strong form off the tee against the Sharks, converting seven of the team’s eight tries against the provincial side.

Ruben Love cemented his status as the All Blacks' starting playmaker under Dave Rennie. Photo / Photosport
Ruben Love cemented his status as the All Blacks' starting playmaker under Dave Rennie. Photo / Photosport

Love was the most in-form of all No 10 options going into the tour of South Africa, scoring 138 points as he helped lead the Hurricanes to their first Super Rugby title in a decade.

But his ability to score tries might be one of the few things lacking in his game.

He scored just three with the Hurricanes in Super Rugby Pacific last season, which is the same number he has put up for the All Blacks in his nine games with them.

Richie Mo’unga

Matches: 57 / Points: 466

Richie Mo’unga returned from three years away in Japan on August 1 to line up for Canterbury in the NPC.

In his two games back in New Zealand, the 32-year-old came off the bench to score a match-winning try against Auckland, and then started at No 10 as Canterbury won the Ranfurly Shield from Otago.

Richie Mo'unga last played for the All Blacks in their 2023 Rugby World Cup final loss to the Springboks. Photo / Photosport
Richie Mo'unga last played for the All Blacks in their 2023 Rugby World Cup final loss to the Springboks. Photo / Photosport

New Zealand Rugby rules prevented him from joining up with the initial squad in South Africa because he had not committed to a two-year contract, forcing him to play for Canterbury.

Rennie has made it clear he’s keen to have Mo’unga as part of his squad heading into the Rugby World Cup, making it no surprise he was called up at the first opportunity.

He also has plenty of experience against the Springboks, including in his last test for the All Blacks, the 2023 World Cup final where he slotted two penalties, but was unable to convert a Beauden Barrett try.

Beauden Barrett

Matches: 146 / Points: 840

One of the All Blacks’ most experienced players has only made one appearance during Dave Rennie’s tenure so far, with a 68-minute stint against the Stormers where he converted three tries.

Beauden Barrett has played just once for the All Blacks since Dave Rennie took over as coach. Photo / Photosport
Beauden Barrett has played just once for the All Blacks since Dave Rennie took over as coach. Photo / Photosport

His 2026 Super Rugby Pacific campaign with the Blues didn’t live up to his usual expectations, scoring 81 points from one try, 32 conversions and four penalties.

The 35-year-old was a key part of the team which won the 2015 World Cup and has been used at fullback and first five-eighth throughout his career.

Having made his test debut in 2012, next year’s Rugby World Cup in Australia could be the last time fans see Barrett pull on the black jersey.

Damian McKenzie

Matches: 78 / Points: 390

Like Ruben Love, McKenzie appears to be an important player for Rennie, having started at fullback for the three Nations Championship tests and against the Sharks.

Damian McKenzie has mostly worn the No 15 jersey under Dave Rennie. Photo / Photosport
Damian McKenzie has mostly worn the No 15 jersey under Dave Rennie. Photo / Photosport

Fans might have felt concerned during the Durban fixture that McKenzie could face a long stint on the sidelines after coming off before halftime with an ankle injury, but Rennie and assistant coach Jason Ryan were both confident he’d be suiting up for the side again soon.

The 31-year-old’s 2026 Super Rugby Pacific campaign finished with a huge defeat to the Hurricanes in the grand final, but had a solid season otherwise, scoring 135 points overall, including five tries.

McKenzie has been the best tryscorer out of the No 10s available to Rennie, crossing over for one against Ireland and one against the Sharks.

Josh Jacomb

Matches: 1 / Points: 2

The 25-year-old finally stepped foot on to the field with the All Blacks in their 38-21 victory over the Stormers in Cape Town.

Josh Jacomb scored two point in his only match for the All Blacks so far. Photo / Photosport
Josh Jacomb scored two point in his only match for the All Blacks so far. Photo / Photosport

In his 12-minute cameo, Jacomb was able to convert a Leroy Carter try, but failed to do the same for the five-pointers from Moorby and Aumua.

Born in Auckland, he made his provincial debut for Taranaki in 2021 and then made his first appearance for the Chiefs in 2024, but will play for the Highlanders from 2027.

His performances in the NPC have been stellar and he was the competition’s second-highest points scorer in 2025 and scored a total of 68 points during the 2026 Super Rugby Pacific season.