Analysis

All Blacks depth chart: The biggest selection questions for Bledisloe Cup series

Cameron McMillan
Analysis by
Cameron McMillan is Deputy Head of Sport for NZME. He has been a sports journalist for 20 years and was on duty in 2011, when the All Blacks put things right.
All Blacks veterans Rieko Ioane (from left), Scott Barrett and Codie Taylor. Photos / Photosport
Sport Headlines | Liam Lawson avoids a high-speed crash with Lewis Hamilton and Tasman beat Bay of Plenty in round nine of rugby's NPC | Friday, September 25, 2026

As the All Blacks prepare for a two-test Bledisloe series without new captain Ardie Savea, Cameron McMillan looks at a possible starting side for the first test while also trying to sort out the possible three back-ups for each position.

The latest All Blacks injury update listed 10 players with about 24 months of cumulative recovery time.

Ardie Savea, Luke Jacobson and Caleb Clarke may well be done for the test season but there is good news for coach Dave Rennie with Scott Barrett, Quinn Tupaea, Anton Segner, Leicester Fainga’anuku and Cortez Ratima all set to return in the coming weeks.

As the revolving doors continue, with 48 players having appeared for the All Blacks across 11 games so far this year, it leaves Rennie with plenty of options across each position.

Let’s examine the first-choice XV.

15. Damian McKenzie

Status: Good for now but open to other options.

Rennie seems sure that McKenzie is his fullback, having started every test so far in the No 15 jersey (he played just one test at fullback last year). Has moving Will Jordan to wing paid dividends? He’s scored tries but Jordan could probably do that if he was playing prop. What McKenzie brings is a much stronger kicking game.

Back-up options: Will Jordan, Beauden Barrett, Ruben Love.

14. Will Jordan

Status: Locked in for long term.

Like McKenzie, Jordan has started every test in this position after playing 10 tests at fullback last year and seven in 2024. Rennie clearly sees him as a wing. He made 45 carries in the test series against South Africa but also gave up 24 turnovers. Fehi Fineanganofo started two tour games on the right wing but no one was going to take Jordan’s spot in the test series.

Back-up option: Leroy Carter, Fehi Fineanganofo, Rieko Ioane.

Will Jordan scores in Baltimore. Photo / SmartFrame
Will Jordan scores in Baltimore. Photo / SmartFrame

13. Rieko Ioane

Status: The only man standing?

With Quinn Tupaea expected back from an MCL injury in one to two weeks, he may be in doubt for the first Bledisloe. With Billy Proctor (four to six weeks) and Anton Lienert-Brown (four to six weeks) out, the midfield stocks are getting thin. That leaves Ioane, who looked strong off the bench in Baltimore. Why not give him a shot at his home ground?

Back-up options: Quinn Tupaea, Emoni Narawa, Leicester Fainga’anuku

Rieko Ioane celebrates a try against the Lions. Photo / Photosport
Rieko Ioane celebrates a try against the Lions. Photo / Photosport

12. Jordie Barrett

Status: Locked in for long-term

First name on the team sheet. But say he got injured against the Wallabies, who is the next Uber off the app? Lienert-Brown is out for next four to six weeks, would Timoci Tavatavanawai get a start or would Rennie go with the dual first five-eighths of Love and Mo’unga? David Havili is still playing for Tasman but leaves for Japan after the NPC season. Dallas McLeod played one test in 2023 but is also heading offshore after the NPC to join the Exeter Chiefs. Could Daniel Rona be the back-up back-up to fellow ‘Nakian Jordie Barrett right now?

Back-up options: Timoci Tavatavanawai, Richie Mo’unga, Daniel Rona.

11. Leroy Carter

Status: Chops and changes

Neither Carter, Josh Moorby or Emoni Narawa made the most of the vacant No 11 jersey in South Africa left when Caleb Clarke went down with a ruptured shoulder tendon. Clarke is out for the rest of the year so the contest will continue. Both Carter and Moorby had defensive lapses in South Africa but showed impressive attacking skills.

Back-up options: Moorby, Emoni Narawa, Fehi Fineanganofo

10. Ruben Love

Status: The pick ... for now.

Rennie made the bold call to start Love in the first test against France and it proved to be the right call. He’s impressed for the most part, but maybe dropped off in the last few tests. Richie Mo’unga is back in contention but didn’t exactly put the pressure on with the All Blacks being handed a heavy defeat in Baltimore. In saying that, if Love has one bad performance, the Mo’unga drums will start banging. The next question is where does Beauden Barrett sit in the depth chart?

Back-up options: Mo’unga, Josh Jacomb, Beauden Barrett

All Blacks No 10 Ruben Love during the test against France. Photo / Photosport
All Blacks No 10 Ruben Love during the test against France. Photo / Photosport

9. Cam Roigard

Status: Locked in

Similar to the Aaron Smith era, there seems to be a decent drop-off to the next option. The answer is that Roigard plays the full 80 for the time being. Cortez Ratima is due back in the next week or two. Will be interesting if he slots back on to the bench against the Wallabies.

Back-up options: Cortez Ratima,Kyle Preston,Noah Hotham.

8. Peter Lakai

Status: Keeping the seat warm

No Ardie Savea for what could be the rest of the season, it’s a chance to give either Lakai or Wallace Sititi a decent run in the test side. Sititi and Semisi Ta’eiloa played at No 8 in tour games in South Africa but Lakai got the start in Baltimore.

Back-up options: Wallace Sititi, Semisi Ta’eiloa, Christian Lio-Willie.

7. Anton Segner

Status: How’s the ankle?

With Luke Jacobson out for four to five months that means the All Blacks are without their first-choice No 7 and No 8 for the rest of the season. Segner is coming off an ankle-joint inflammation and should be fit in one to two weeks. Would it be a risk to start him against the Wallabies? It’s probably between him and Ethan Blackadder, who have differing styles, with the Crusaders loosie more of a Jacobson clone. DuPlessis Kirifi has been forgotten about after a strong Super Rugby Pacific campaign, while Lucas Casey is the next young hopeful openside. The likely option after Blackadder or Segner would be to move Lakai to No 7 and play Sititi at No 8.

Back-up options: Ethan Blackadder, DuPlessis Kirifi, Lucas Casey.

All Blacks Anton Segner during the tour match against the Bulls. Photo / SmartFrame
All Blacks Anton Segner during the tour match against the Bulls. Photo / SmartFrame

6. Simon Parker/Tupou Vaa’i

Status: It’s complicated

This really comes down to where to play Vaa’i. If Scott Barrett is fit and ready to go at test level then maybe that question is answered, with Barrett and Holland as the locks options. But if Barrett is not ready for test level just yet then maybe Vaa’i is better suited at lock, with Parker getting the start. Just to complicate it, Barrett has also played on the side of the scrum before.

Back-up options: Sititi, Scott Barrett, Shannon Frizell

5. Fabian Holland

Status: Plenty of options

The All Blacks have played 11 games this year and used four different locks in seven starting combinations, which will become eight if Scott Barrett is fit to face the Wallabies next month. Holland has the higher upside.

Back-up options: Josh Lord, Sam Darry, Patrick Tuipulotu

Fabian Holland in action against the Springboks. Photo / Photosport
Fabian Holland in action against the Springboks. Photo / Photosport

4. Scott Barrett

Status: If fit, get him in there right away

Was clearly missed in the Springboks series. The All Blacks were lacking one more hard-working, experienced leader who could have commanded the lineout. Hasn’t played a game since last November. If he’s not ready then maybe try Josh Lord and Holland again – the combination from the Ellis Park win.

Back-up options: Josh Lord, Sam Darry, Jamie Hannah

3. Tyrel Lomax

Status: Let’s see him against a different scrum

Lomax started the first three tests against South Africa and despite being part of a struggling scrum, remained Rennie’s first choice. With Tamaiti Williams still out, it’s between Lomax and Fletcher Newell for the Bledisloe Cup series.

Back-up options: Fletcher Newell, Pasilio Tosi, Saula Ma’u

2. Codie Taylor

Status: Needs a big series

Not sure what to make of Taylor’s place in the side one year out from the World Cup. He was dropped for the third test, with Asafo Aumua taking his place, but then captained the side in Baltimore. It’s unlikely, if fit, that Scott Barrett would want to captain the side again, so Taylor is the top choice again. World Rugby’s new obsession with the brake foot didn’t help his tour but the All Blacks had scrum and lineout issues throughout the test series. One option is to turn him into Keven Mealamu 2.0 and let Asafo Aumua and Samisoni Taukei’aho fight it out for the long-term starting role.

Back-up options: Asafo Aumua, Samisoni Taukei’aho, George Bell

1. Ethan de Groot

Status: Let’s see him against a different scrum

Has been the regular loosehead starter for the last two years but same as Lomax in terms of a scrum that clearly came off second-best against the Boks. De Groot missed part of the Springboks series due to a concussion, with George Bower starting in the second and third tests.

Back-up options: George Bower,Xavier Numia, Ofa Tu’ungafasi

Cameron McMillan has been a sports journalist since 2003 and is NZME’s Deputy Head of Sport.