Second Waitematā Harbour crossing: NZ First leader is against latest Government plan

Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown has welcomed the study into Meola Reef, having long advocated for it as his preferred site for a second Waitematā Harbour crossing. Image / Mayor's office
The most galling part of that was the $50m spent on consultants for Labour's plan to put an almost $1 billion cycling bridge over the harbour. Video / Ryan Bridge TODAY

New Zealand First leader Winston Peters is clarifying claims his party did not support the latest business case investigating a second Auckland harbour crossing, confirming it endorsed the final decision but pushed for changes in Cabinet.

Peters told Ryan Bridge TODAY funding a new study into a second crossing was a “gross, shocking waste of money”.

The Government and Auckland Council have agreed to split a $1 million feasibility study into a second harbour crossing over Meola Reef, marking a formal consideration of Mayor Wayne Brown’s long-preferred bridge route.

Asked whether he agreed to the case when it was presented to Cabinet, Peters responded: “No, we said, ‘Look, this is not the way to go about it’. But if you don’t win, you don’t win.”

Elaborating on his comments following the interview, Peters said NZ First supported “the establishment of a senior expert to lead the exercise for Cabinet” but did not specifically task that person with leading a business case into Meola Reef.

Peters said he proposed the following changes:

  • Make the information held by New Zealand Transport Agency Waka Kotahi and Auckland Council available to infrastructure builders through an open tender process on the Government Electronic Tendering System;
  • Under disclosure agreements, let infrastructure builders assess all available information and address where and how is the most cost-effective solution to moving people across the harbour while spreading demand;
  • Enable those infrastructure firms to put forward and compete for tender, with the Government and Auckland Council selecting the best solution.
Winston Peters says NZ First is opposed to a $1m study into a second Waitematā Harbour crossing via Meola Reef. Photo / Sylvie Whinray
Winston Peters says NZ First is opposed to a $1m study into a second Waitematā Harbour crossing via Meola Reef. Photo / Sylvie Whinray

NZ First remained concerned that the crossing debate risks pitting the Meola Reef option against a crossing adjacent to the existing bridge, Peters said.

“We say build a bridge and get over it.”

Yesterday’s announcement was described as a Cabinet decision, meaning all members would have supported the business case proposal. Cabinet collective responsibility requires members not to publicly disagree with decisions made by Cabinet.

Coalition parties have the ability to invoke an agree to disagree clause, however, this has not been referenced by NZ First following yesterday’s announcement.

Peters said he rejected this idea “completely”, saying the project should instead be put out to tender, with those tendering doing the exploratory work, as was happening at Marsden Point.

“Let them do all the work, let them make all the payments and let them do all the cost” – though he was open to partly subsidising that work.

He pointed to money “wasted” on Auckland light rail, the Skypath over the Harbour Bridge, the over-budget Pūhoi-Warkworth motorway, and Transmission Gully which “went broke in 2018 and when it was finished you had five different lots of tar seal and the tar seal had to be fixed up before the first car went on it”.

He said that $100m had already been spent consulting on a second harbour crossing.

“In any other country there would be people going to prison for that.”

Peters denied, when asked, that he was calling for Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Transport Minister Chris Bishop to be jailed, but said there was a “massive lack of accountability”.

Later, Bishop confirmed that Cabinet had collectively agreed to the study “a couple of weeks ago”.

“Mr Peters is entitled to his view, obviously, but Cabinet’s made this decision.

“It’s the right thing to do, and we’ll be going ahead with it. And whoever’s in the hot seat in a year or so’s time – whether it’s me or whether it’s another transport minister – will have to advance this process.”

Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown welcomed the study while criticising the millions already spent, arguing we should “have a look at something sensible without getting too worried about worrywarts”.

Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown has welcomed the study into Meola Reef, having long advocated for it as his preferred site for a second Waitematā Harbour crossing. Image / Mayor's office
Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown has welcomed the study into Meola Reef, having long advocated for it as his preferred site for a second Waitematā Harbour crossing. Image / Mayor's office

Brown reiterated his belief that Auckland Council should lead decision-making on the crossing and was open to Peters’ suggestion of putting the project out for tender if it helped reduce costs and fast-track construction.

“I think it’s kind of better than what we’re doing, [which] is just tipping money into local consultants and getting nothing back.”

Richard Templer, chief executive of Engineering New Zealand, told Ryan Bridge TODAY it’s crucial that officials ensure whatever decision they advance is “very well-informed” and backed by Parliament and Aucklanders, arguing the country can’t afford to get it wrong.

“We don’t want decisions flip-flopping, because we know that has cost the country billions of dollars.”

The business case, announced by Luxon and Bishop yesterday, will investigate whether the natural lava flow at Point Chevalier offers a viable, lower-cost alternative to the multibillion-dollar tunnel options previously favoured by central government.

An independent expert will lead the project, reporting directly to ministers to resolve long-standing disputes over the crossing’s final design and funding.

Templer said the Meola Reef option’s viability would depend on the stability of the basalt rock and what lies underneath the lava flow.

“If you’re looking at a bridge, you need to know that the foundations the bridge will sit on are going to be able to take the weight of the bridge and the weight of the traffic.

“If you’re looking at a tunnel, you need to know what is under the water, whether it is going to be easy to tunnel through, whether it is going to be hard to tunnel through, and whether or not it’ll be able to take the load of all the water and seabed when you create a void underneath that.”

Sign up to The Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.