Auckland second harbour crossing: Meola Reef study to cost taxpayers, ratepayers $1m

Auckland ratepayers and taxpayers will split the $1 million bill for investigating whether Meola Reef in Pt Chevalier is the right spot for the city’s next harbour crossing.
After two and a half years in Government, National has unveiled plans for a multibillion-dollar business case to examine options for a second crossing and launched a global hunt for an infrastructure expert to lead the project and report directly to ministers.
Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown has long advocated for a route across Meola Reef, and welcomed the study.
“It’s better to pay for half a study we have a say in, than a free study we have no say in that costs a really big fortune later on,” Brown told the Herald.
“I’m more focused on quick fixes, that’s something we can do quickly and cheaply with a bit of paint this year. We will have fixed up roads all over Auckland well before this study even gets done.”
Transport Minister Chris Bishop and Prime Minister Christopher Luxon jointly announced the next steps for the crossing today.
Bishop confirmed Cabinet had agreed an independent detailed business case was necessary, despite NZTA having completed an investment case in May and endorsing a tunnel as its preferred option.
“Despite the great progress that has been made, more information and work is required before Cabinet can select a preferred option.”
That investment case has already cost taxpayers $100 million.
A tunnel is also the favoured option for some construction experts.
“There are benefits and costs to each of the two options that the board looked at,” Bishop said.
“Tunnels are obviously complicated and expensive, but to be honest, in the environment we’re dealing with in Auckland, so are bridges.”
Brown disagrees a tunnel is the best option.
He has long advocated for the crossing to be built as a bridge over Meola Reef, a partially submerged rocky lava flow extending into the water from Point Chevalier, arguing this would be cheaper and more logical than other routes being considered by NZTA.
Bishop and Luxon both laughed as they announced the Meola Reef study, saying it was part of the Auckland City deal and a “sign of good faith”.
They said the $500,000 taxpayers will stump up for the Meola Reef study was worth it.
“We’re talking about the most expensive infrastructure project New Zealand will have ever undertaken, a massive infrastructure project that already impacts 170,000 vehicle movements today and up to $4 billion of GDP, that is a massive investment,” Luxon said.
“That is to really make sure that we have done due diligence properly, that everyone’s aligned.
“We need to partner with Auckland Council, we also need to do everything we can to reach out to the other, to the opposition parties as well, because I want as much bipartisanship on this.”

While Brown welcomed the study, Auckland Council has not confirmed it will fund its share. It will only go ahead if the council agrees to pay half.
“There’s a lot to consider here and we’re not going to be rushed into any decisions,” Brown said.
“At this stage, it’s just an invitation to contribute to the study, but the regional deal endorsed by the governing body committed council and central government to work closely on the Waitematā Harbour project.”
Brown said: “It’s great that the Government is listening to my concerns about this project, as well as issues raised by a range of Auckland community and business groups.”
“The best quote is one of mine that [Auckland Minister] Simon Watts used – ‘projects don’t go wrong, they start wrong’, and this one is quite complicated.
“This is a good example of the regional deal – working together on big projects. We don’t want the harbour crossing to become another extravagant failure like Auckland Light Rail.”
The promise of bipartisanship also extends to opposition parties.
“Multiple parliaments and potentially multiple governments will be involved so we will engage meaningfully with the opposition,” Bishop said, in acknowledgment this would be a lengthy process.
He confirmed he met with Labour’s Tangi Utikere and the Greens to brief them on the plans before the announcement.
Immediately after the announcement, Labour leader Chris Hipkins said: “This appears to be an announcement about an announcement about a study about a study so that sometime in the future they can make a decision about making a decision.”
But he said Labour would not stop the process now that it has started, including the Meola Reef study.
“The work that they commissioned today, we will continue. We will see that through to its conclusion, and then we’ll take it from there.”
Infrastructure New Zealand said the Government’s approach is a “responsible” one.
“There are still balls in the air,” chief executive Nick Leggett said.
“They’ve investigated options to a detailed level, that’s smart and should save angst and money later on by reducing the need for scope changes mid-project. Scope changes are what blows out billions in these projects.”
Until now the $5.4 billion City Rail Link was the country’s biggest infrastructure project.
A new crossing will steal the title – and cost taxpayers billions and billions of dollars.
There are mixed views on the appointment of an independent ‘Senior Responsible Officer’ – the person who will lead the business case and answer directly to the ministers of Finance, Transport, Auckland and cabinet.
That removes the project from NZTA’s responsibilities.
“We would need reassurance on ministers directing this project,” Leggett said.
“This sends warning signs to me as ministers should set direction, sign off the money and monitor progress. Having them direct proceedings is what has got us into problems with infrastructure projects to date. Think i-Rex, Auckland Light Rail, Let’s Get Wellington Moving.
“Hundreds of millions of dollars of public money wasted due to too much politics. NZTA builds mega-projects. They have the capability and they should be enabled to build more with this project. Politicians are ultimately responsible, but they are not project managers of complex infrastructure with many billions of dollars at stake.”
The business case will also look at how the crossing will be paid for, including user pay options like tolling.
“[The business case] will allow us to do further work required on funding and financing, and delivery model options. It will also allow us to consider the Auckland transport network more broadly including NZTA’s Auckland Motorway Plan, any time-of-use charging scheme, and the 30-year Auckland Integrated Transport Plan to be developed as part of the Auckland Transport governance reforms,” Bishop said.

North Shore councillor Richard Hills, while not supportive of the Meola option, welcomed a “thorough and potentially more open process”.
“It’s a process that could cost tens of billions of dollars, so it must be done right,” Hills told the Herald.
“A new crossing will bring network resilience to supplement the ageing bridge but future plans need to have a strong public transport priority, to build on the runaway success of northern busway which has already extended the life of the bridge, reduced congestion and emissions.
“Walking and cycling should be investigated too, as is popular on other famous harbour crossings around the world. Crossing from the Shore each day, the bridge is often the least congested part of the network so it’s also crucial to know how any future crossing lands in and around our communities and show the positive or negative impacts that may have.”
One further option will also be looked at.
“We have had an approach from the private sector involving an alternative approach, (which) basically involves an innovative construction methodology to upgrade the existing bridge rather than building a new one,” Bishop said.
“The Government doesn’t have a monopoly on good ideas, and if it works, then we should properly consider it.”
But the long wait for a crossing continues - the business case is expected back sometime next year.
Katie Bradford is a Senior Correspondent at the Herald. She has been a broadcast journalist for over 20 years and was based in the press gallery for 10 years. She specialises in politics, business and Auckland issues.