Opinion

Why America is undergoing regime change, engineered from within by the country’s president – E.J. Dionne jnr

Opinion by
E. J. Dionne jnr
E. J. Dionne Jr is a contributing Opinion writer for the New York Times and the author of Why Americans Hate Politics, Our Divided Political Heart, Why the Right Went Wrong and, most recently, 100% Democracy, with Miles Rapoport.
Protesters, observers and neighbourhood residents face federal agents during an operation in Minneapolis, on January 13. Photo / David Guttenfelder, The New York Times
Protesters, observers and neighbourhood residents face federal agents during an operation in Minneapolis, on January 13. Photo / David Guttenfelder, The New York Times

THE FACTS

  • Donald Trump threatened tariffs on allies over Greenland, then retreated after market fallout.
  • Trump’s actions, including pardoning January 6 insurrectionists, highlight his “radical constitutionalism” approach.
  • Recent events, including federal agent shootings, raise concerns about regime change and constitutional erosion.

Whatever hope there was that 2026 might be less jarring than the previous year is gone. This month, something snapped in the United States.

On their own, this month’s domestic headline events would be shocking enough:

  • The killing of Renee Good by an Ice agent in Minneapolis and the Trump Administration’s subsequent cover-up;
  • Yet more of President Donald Trump’s corrupt pardons;
  • The Justice Department’s criminal investigations of Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell, Governor Tim Walz of Minnesota and the state’s Attorney-General, Keith Ellison, Mayor Jacob Frey of Minneapolis, and a group of senators and House members who simply reminded members of our armed forces to follow the law when they are issued illegal orders.

All this was before Trump announced that he would impose tariffs by presidential fiat on some of America’s closest allies if they didn’t surrender to his hunger for Greenland.

He eventually retreated from both tariff and invasion threats after his beloved stock market fell sharply.

But unilaterally undermining the alliance that has kept the US safe for more than three-quarters of a century was strategic lunacy and showed how much wreckage one man can leave behind when he’s allowed to cast aside all constraints on his appetites.

Lest anyone miss the strongman theme, Trump chose to say on social media that he hoped Attorney-General Pam Bondi was “looking at” the former special prosecutor Jack Smith. That happened to be the day Smith appeared before a House committee and methodically explained why he had indicted Trump for causing the January 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol.

Then last weekend federal agents in Minneapolis shot and killed 37-year-old Alex Pretti, an intensive care nurse whom local police identified as American citizen with no criminal record, prompting Frey to declare that “a great American city is being invaded by its own federal Government”.

Collectively, those actions have brought into the open what has been lurking just beneath the surface of US politics and can no longer be brushed aside.

US President Donald Trump in the Oval Office on January 7. Photo / Doug Mills, The New York Times
US President Donald Trump in the Oval Office on January 7. Photo / Doug Mills, The New York Times

Trump is actively seeking regime change – not in Venezuela, where a dictatorship remains in power despite the apprehension of Nicolas Maduro, but in the United States.

It’s tempting to look at the Trump Administration primarily as a psychodrama rooted in the US President’s delicate ego and his obsession with doing whatever it takes to distract attention from topics he finds uncongenial. See: the Epstein files, about which the Administration is also skirting the law.

But what is happening to the country is about more than Trump’s extreme neediness.

His neediness is transforming our institutions.

From the first day of his second term, Trump and his lieutenants have been systematic in undermining laws, rules, and understandings that undergird a free, democratic and constitutional republic.

Theorists of the new Maga right made their goals clear with books such as Regime Change, which calls for a new American “Caesar” and their embrace of a “radical constitutionalism”.

That last phrase is from a 2022 essay by Russell Vought, now the President’s director of the Office of Management and Budget, in which he urged Trump’s sympathisers “to cast ourselves as dissidents of the current regime and to put on our shoulders the full weight of envisioning, articulating and defending what a Radical Constitutionalism requires in the late hour that our country finds itself in, and then do it”.

They’re doing it.

Trump’s early signals

One of Trump’s first acts in office received far less scrutiny than it deserved: his executive order effectively overturning a law banning TikTok.

As Charlie Savage of the New York Times later reported, Bondi told tech companies they were free to violate the statute because – well, because Trump said so. As Savage noted, this could be seen as Trump’s “starkest power grab”. TikTok has announced a deal with a group that included several investors with ties to Trump.

Another day one move, Trump’s blanket pardon for the January 6 insurrectionists, did arouse substantial outrage. But the sharpest criticism came from Democrats and other Trump critics, with Republicans in large numbers hiding behind the fact that a president has unlimited constitutional power to issue pardons or ducking the question entirely.

The signal Trump sent from the start – that he could set aside laws he didn’t like and that those who engaged in criminality on his behalf would receive clemency – spoke to the seriousness of his embrace of “radical constitutionalism” which, as he has made obvious, is no constitutionalism at all.

Letting these early abuses of power slip by opened the way for the routinisation of step-by-step regime change.

The country got accustomed to:

  • The mass firings of government workers;
  • The Administration’s ignoring, obstructing or getting around court orders, often with the backing of a Supreme Court that had already granted him broad immunity;
  • Its shopping for prosecutors willing to file baseless charges against political enemies, the gutting the Department of Justice, and the use of the FBI to find dirt on political opponents;
  • Its use of executive power to target universities and law firms;
  • Trump’s appointment of election deniers to high-level positions, raising fears of federal interference in the fair administration of this year’s Midterm elections;
  • And the blatant use of presidential power for personal enrichment or to help friends and donors.

Since many of Americans’ liberties are still in place and US institutions continue to function in familiar ways, fear of regime change might once have seemed extreme, unduly academic or abstract.

The events of the past three weeks have brought home that, on the contrary, these worries are chillingly realistic and concrete.

A statue commemorating Hans Egede, the Danish missionary who founded Nuuk in 1728, stands on a hill overlooking the town in Greenland, on January 13. Photo / Ivor Prickett, The New York Times
A statue commemorating Hans Egede, the Danish missionary who founded Nuuk in 1728, stands on a hill overlooking the town in Greenland, on January 13. Photo / Ivor Prickett, The New York Times

Outrage and pushback

The killing of Good by an Ice agent – operating as part of a de facto personal police force for the US President – has shocked and dismayed a significant American majority, and Pretti’s shooting death prompted new outrage.

Even Republicans who have been loath to criticise Trump questioned the obviously phony investigation into Powell for fear of its impact on the economy.

The prosecutorial threats against Walz, Ellison, Frey and the members of Congress who warned service members against obeying illegal orders can be seen only as ploys to use government power to chill dissent.

It may, however, be the Greenland madness that finally forces a reckoning with what happens when Congress – yes, that means its Republican majority – sits by and allows a chief executive to run roughshod over any legal limits to his desires, any sense of stewardship towards institutions built over decades to keep the US secure, and any responsibility to other nations that long stood with America in defence of democracy itself.

Trump’s practice of radical constitutionalism is radically dangerous.

He eventually backed down, but not before causing enormous damage.

The observation by Canada Prime Minister Mark Carney about the world order in his remarkable address at Davos last week is also true of the US constitutional order: “We are in the midst of a rupture, not a transition”.

Recognising that the nature of the US regime is the central question in its politics will not make other issues go away.

But failing to confront what’s at stake would be a generational failure. The danger now is not alarmism but complacency.

This article originally appeared in the New York Times.

Written by: E. J. Dionne jnr, the author of Why Americans Hate Politics, Our Divided Political Heart, Why the Right Went Wrong and, most recently, 100% Democracy, with Miles Rapoport.

Photographs by: David Guttenfelder, Doug Mills, Ivor Prickett

©2025 NEW YORK TIMES