Book bombshell: Woodward defends decision to withhold Trump's virus comments

Hillel Italie
Author Bob Woodward at Trump Tower in New York. Photo / AP file
Author Bob Woodward at Trump Tower in New York. Photo / AP file

Bob Woodward, facing widespread criticism for only now revealing US President Donald Trump's early concerns about the severity of the coronavirus, told AP today that he needed time to be sure that Trump's private comments from February were accurate.

In Woodward's upcoming book on Trump, Rage, the President is quoted saying the virus was highly contagious and "deadly stuff" at a time he was publicly dismissing it as no worse than the flu. Woodward, the celebrated Washington Post journalist and best-selling author, spoke with Trump more than a dozen times for his book.

"He tells me this, and I'm thinking, 'Wow, that's interesting, but is it true?' Trump says things that don't check out, right?" Woodward told AP during a telephone interview.

Using a famous phrase from the Watergate era, when Woodward's reporting for the Post helped lead to President Richard Nixon's resignation, Woodward said his mission was to determine, "What did he know and when did he know it?"

Trump names three sitting senators among 20 possible supreme court picks https://t.co/R21B5bP9DD

— The Guardian (@guardian) September 9, 2020

On Twitter and elsewhere online, commentators accused Woodward of valuing book sales over public health.

"Nearly 200,000 Americans have died because neither Donald Trump nor Bob Woodward wanted to risk anything substantial to keep the country informed," wrote Esquire's Charles Pierce.

The issue of daily journalists presenting newsworthy information in books isn't new.

The competition for attention is intense, and headlines help boost sales and guest shots for interviews.

Reporter Michael Schmidt of the New York Times recently attracted attention for his book, Donald Trump vs The United States, by reporting new details on an unannounced visit by Trump to Walter Reed military hospital in November 2019.

If Woodward had said “He’s playing it down! He told me.” The news cycle would be identical to today’s. Trump would claim he didn’t want to panic anyone. We’d be aghast. His supporters wouldn’t care. And his Gov’t policy would remain unchanged (and inadequate).

— Scott Gilmore (@Scott_Gilmore) September 9, 2020

Schmidt reported that Vice-President Mike Pence was put on alert that he might have to briefly assume the powers of the presidency if the president had to undergo a procedure that required anesthesia.

Pence later said he didn't recall being put on standby for the Reed visit, which the White House has said was part of the President's routine annual physical. But Schmidt's book renewed speculation about Trump's health.

Political figures with book deals also have been chastised for holding back timely material.

Former national security adviser John Bolton, whose scathing memoir The Room Where It Happened came out in June, declined discussing Trump's actions towards Ukraine while the impeachment hearings were being held earlier this year.

Donald Trump is staring down a potential surprise Nobel Prize - receiving a nomination on the same day tapes have been released revealing the U.S. President downplayed COVID-19. @AmeliaAdams9 #9News pic.twitter.com/Iq659GBYNC

— 9News Australia (@9NewsAUS) September 9, 2020

Woodward's book, which comes out next week, draws from 18 conversations with Trump between December and July.

During his AP interview, Woodward said Trump called him "out of the blue" in early February to "unburden himself" about the virus, which then had few cases in the US.

But Woodward said that only in May was he satisfied that Trump's comments were based on reliable information and that by then the virus had spread nationwide.

"If I had done the story at that time about what he knew in February, that's not telling us anything we didn't know," Woodward said.

portrait of Trump painted by Atlantic article and Woodward book over the last week:

he called US soldiers “suckers” for having gotten killed in WW1 (117,000 died)

he played the American people for suckers by deliberately downplaying threat of coronavirus (190,000 dead so far)

— John Harwood (@JohnJHarwood) September 9, 2020

At that point, he said, the issue was no longer one of public health but of politics. His priority became getting the story out before the election in November.

"That was the demarcation line for me," he said. "Had I decided that my book was coming out on Christmas, the end of this year, that would have been unthinkable."

Asked why he didn't share Trump's February remarks for a fellow Post reporter to pursue, Woodward said he had developed "some pretty important sources" on his own.

"Could I have brought others in? Could they have done things I couldn't do?" he asked. "I was on the trail, and I was (still) on the trail when it (the virus) exploded."

- AP