As US shutdown nears end, Trump and Republicans still confront soaring health costs

The longest government shutdown in United States history is coming to an end, but the central issue that caused it — the staggering cost of healthcare — isn’t going away anytime soon.
It will continue to bedevil US President Donald Trump, especially as the Midterm elections draw closer.
The burden is now on Trump and Republicans to bring down costs or risk peril in the those elections, after a splinter group of Democrats agreed to end the shutdown by dropping their party’s demand to extend certain health insurance subsidies.
Despite repeated promises to offer an alternative to Obamacare, Trump has nothing much to show on the issue, beyond a vague plan to send money directly to policyholders.
“We want a healthcare system where we pay the money to the people instead of the insurance companies,” he told reporters in the Oval Office on Tuesday.
“We’re going to be working on that very hard over the next short period of time.”
Trump’s statement highlights the pressure on Republicans to articulate their own vision to improve the affordability of healthcare now that the subsidies that millions of people rely on to pay for coverage are set to expire by the end of the year.
Like Trump, Republicans in Congress who have spent years attacking Obamacare have not offered up a serious alternative, since their failed effort to repeal the law in 2017.
The White House declined to provide more details of Trump’s latest idea. But the proposal assumes that giving patients a bigger role in purchasing their care will lead to lower costs and better health outcomes.
The evidence that such an approach could significantly lower costs is not strong.
Most health spending goes to very sick people who don’t have much choice in the care they receive.
Research suggests that financial incentives and information about prices can shape behaviour for patients seeking elective care. But that kind of spending is a small share of the country’s health care bill.
Millions of Americans who will lose access to subsidies when the current formula expires are looking at a jump in premiums, in some cases hundreds of dollars a month or more.
The Congressional Budget Office estimates that two million Americans will lose insurance altogether next year as the prices rise.
Trump seems to be arguing that the subsidy money should not be used to help people buy insurance but rather be offered to the same people in special accounts.
Extending the extra subsidies would be expensive, costing US$23 billion ($40.6b) next year and nearly US$350b over the next decade, according to the budget office estimate.
Even without them, most consumers can still get some help paying their insurance premiums through tax credits established under Obamacare.
The Affordable Care Act, which became law in 2010, has been attacked since its inception for failing to constrain health costs, which are higher in the US than in other rich democracies.
But its expansion of health coverage to tens of millions of Americans who would otherwise lack coverage has made the law popular.
Democrats expanded funding for people who buy their insurance during the pandemic, leading to a surge in new insurance sign-ups. It is these added subsidies that are on the line now.
Democrats have embraced healthcare costs as a central issue this year, mindful of Trump’s first term when he tried — and failed — to repeal and replace Obamacare.

It was an early and messy defeat for him.
Republicans in Congress, who had rallied around the cause for nearly a decade, were unable to agree on a substitute. Democrats ran campaigns focused on the legislative debacle and took back the House the next year.
During his campaign last year, Trump barely talked about health reform. When asked about Obamacare during the presidential debate, he said he would be open to adjusting it “if we can come up with a plan that’s going to cost our people, our population, less money and be better healthcare”.
When pressed on whether he had a specific proposal in mind, Trump said he had “concepts of a plan”.
Democrats forced the Government shutdown over healthcare costs, insisting that Republicans extend extra subsidies that help people pay insurance premiums and that Republicans reverse the recent cuts they made to Medicaid.
Republicans have said such an extension does not belong on a spending measure, and some have argued that Congress should let the subsidies expire.
The handful of Democratic senators who agreed over the weekend to end the shutdown extracted a promise from Republican leadership for at least a symbolic vote on extending the subsidies next month.
The effort has succeeded in thrusting the challenges Americans face in paying for healthcare into the political spotlight at a time when Trump would prefer to focus on other things.
For the most part, Trump’s policy efforts on healthcare have tended to focus on ancillary issues, such as improving the transparency of healthcare prices, reducing the supply of illegal fentanyl, and requiring drug companies to offer discounts to patients who buy prescription drugs with their own money.
His Health Secretary, Robert F. Kennedy, jnr, has had little to say about how to improve the affordability of insurance coverage, and instead often focuses his attention on topics like vaccines or encouraging a healthier diet.
Republicans in Congress have floated some ideas. Their major tax and domestic policy Bill cut nearly US$1 trillion from Medicaid — about half by scaling back Obamacare’s expansion of coverage to the working poor.
Some lawmakers continue to talk about Obamacare replacement approaches, though the issue has lost prominence in recent years. This week, senators Rick Scott of Florida and Bill Cassidy of Louisiana expressed enthusiasm in proposals similar to Trump’s idea.
Trump supported the healthcare cuts passed this northern summer, but he frequently downplayed the scale of the changes, inaccurately saying they were narrowly aimed at eliminating fraud.
Trump’s newly articulated proposal shares a consumerist bent with those policies, by replacing insurance subsidies with cash payments to individuals.
It appears to echo a recent proposal made by Cassidy, who suggested taking the expiring subsidy money and giving it to consumers in the form of a “pre-funded flexible savings account”, which can only be used to pay medical bills.
Cassidy’s plan would account for about US$350b in spending over the next decade, not “trillions and trillions” of dollars that Trump has spoken about.
This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
Written by: Margot Sanger-Katz and Shawn McCreesh
Photographs by: Jovelle Tamayo, Doug Mills
©2025 THE NEW YORK TIMES