Leah McFall Middle Ground: When did it become embarrassing to read a book in public?

I’m reading a book about the decline of reading, and it’s giving me the trots.
The irony is that hardly anyone will read it, so let me summarise. Reading rates are falling off a cliff, especially among the young. This is leading to a reverse Enlightenment – a darkening of human culture. I don’t have to tell you the smartphone is a leading reason why. I don’t have to tell you democracy is doomed without literacy. We’re already experiencing social decline and institutional fall – it’s everywhere we look, the fraying of the ties that bind us. Personally, I believe our descent into the abyss truly began when Kim Hill quit Saturdays, but you’ll have your own milestones.
I bought it after a recent, chilling experience with another book. It happened during an Air New Zealand flight from Auckland to Wellington – a horror scenario all by itself, especially as thick evening fog had blanketed the capital and the plane was bucking and shuddering. In smooth, well-rounded vowels, a flight attendant announced the pilot would give our landing a crack but as he could barely see the runway, there were no guarantees. The wheels descended and so did we, before the plane banked sharply upward. We were heading back to Auckland and by way of apology, the drinks trolley would be coming around again.
I didn’t mind – this gave me an extra hour to read. I had a thick paperback in my handbag and dug it out. But as I licked my finger and turned a page, I felt other passengers eyeing me, as if I were strange. They had screens of all sizes – compact, lightweight, many with headphones – but nothing as impractical as a book. Why clunk around with such a thing? Was I seeking their attention, with my singular behaviour? Marking myself out as flamboyantly individual, even though I wear no-brand sneakers and live in Karori?
By the time we were over New Plymouth I was having a personality crisis. When did it become embarrassing to read a book in public?
But then, when did I last take a book to a cafe, park bench or bar and read it while waiting for friends? People in Paris do this. It used to be insouciant, cool, even sexy. It was normal. Now, it’s up yourself.
I’m not saying people who read are cleverer than people who don’t. I’ve always read books, but it hasn’t entirely paid off; Pluto, in my opinion, is still a planet. But books of all types have given me empathy. Context. They’ve taught me how to collect and sift ideas and compare perspectives. Books have been frustrating – I’ve thrown plenty across the room. They’ve also kept me hopeful and helped figure out the values I want to live by. They’re the love of my life.
Telling people to read more is not a strategy that works – trust me, I have teenagers. But we need to normalise reading books in public, as if it’s still central to our lives. I don’t want to live in an era in which the majority don’t bother, never allowing themselves the time to connect their thoughts and never experiencing stillness. It would be less free and more conformist but, mostly, as boring as hell.
In radical defiance, I dare you to read in public. It must be identifiably a book, as an e-reader appears as just another screen. Doing it will prove it’s still possible to stop time, control experience and commit to your future self. Your example will be soothing to everyone else, made frenetic by their phones.
Imagine a flight with books in every row. “Good evening, everyone,” the pilot will say. “As you can tell, we’re experiencing considerable turbulence. Conditions are hostile. I know you’re feeling doomed at present, but we’re going to land this thing in the end.”