Listener
Opinion

Duncan Garner: I’ve seen enough, ban e-scooters before someone you know dies

Duncan Garner
Opinion by
Duncan Garner is an award-winning journalist and broadcaster who now hosts the Editor in Chief live podcast.
Duncan Garner: E-scooters are flying death traps, no protective clothing required and no lessons in how to use and ride them. Photo / MediaWorks
Duncan Garner: E-scooters are flying death traps, no protective clothing required and no lessons in how to use and ride them. Photo / MediaWorks

Online only

George is 15 and damn lucky to be alive.

He’s banged up all right; in hospital, licking his many wounds, including four broken bones. I know George, he’s my son’s friend. It’ll be a crappy summer for George.

He grabbed a scooter a few days back and next thing he remembers is waking up in hospital. Waking up was a bonus. He was told he was hit by a car at 2am and went through the windscreen. Or he may have hit the car. Same result. I’ve seen his injuries. Ouch. He’s lost so much skin.

Months earlier, another young fella I know got some pretty bad injuries after riding a scooter with two others. Three on one machine – that’s madness. But the fact is, many people don’t respect the rules.

That’s particularly true of our teens. So why don’t we do what some schools in Noosa and on the Gold Coast have done: ban the bloody things? Or introduce an age restriction? People have died in scooter accidents, and many of us will know someone who’s been injured.

I think it’s imperative that schools get together with local councils and call time on teens using these machines. Hop on one as an inexperienced rider, phone in one hand and concentration poor, and it’s a lethal combination.

But the attitude seems to be: nothing to see here. Why? In an overprotective world where we over-road cone, over-parent, stay out of the sun, wear a hat, where we say no to bullrush but yes to high-vis, we take the fun out of everything including not putting your heads underwater on trips to the beach. Yes, some schools won’t allow students to duck under the water, and restrict swimming to waist high. There are numerous school policies banning students from doing things. Surely schools can get together with councils and based on risk predictions and data, introduce tougher rules to make things safer?

There is so much inconsistency. On the one hand, the kids are wrapped in cotton wool. On the other, they’re allowed to jump on an e-scooter with a speed limit of, well, anything that doesn’t create a hazard. Helmets seem to be optional. I’d go so far as to say scooters are flying death traps, no protective clothing required and no lessons in how to use them.

Where’s the health and safety plan for that? There’s a cavalier attitude to something that carries a fair amount of risk.

ACC’s drowning in the fallout. The total cost of e-scooter-related ACC claims from 1 January 2019 to the end of 2024 was $50 million. Every year, hundreds hospitalised.

It’s time to do something.

There would be accusations of nanny state-ism, but is it over-reach or simply best practice, trying to keep your kids safe? As parents, that’s our job.

Schools, parents and board of trustees can work together in the face of a genuine risk that sits on two wheels in front of teenagers every day. This isn’t a make-believe threat looming on the horizon. It’s here. What are we waiting for? Another accident?