Listener
Opinion

Duncan Garner: Christopher Luxon continues to sound like he’s managing risk, not leading a country

Opinion by
New Zealand Listener
Duncan Garner: "A meek National party looks scared of its own shadow." Photo / Tony Nyberg
Duncan Garner: "A meek National party looks scared of its own shadow." Photo / Tony Nyberg

This election should be a cakewalk for National.

Two years into the first term, it should be rubber-stamping a victory as the largest party in Parliament and leader of the first tripartite coalition government. But not this time. Not under leader Christopher Luxon and not under these economic conditions.

Two polls into 2026 and we’ve got largely the same result as last year: Labour has bigger numbers than National, but National sneaks back in with Act and an increasingly popular NZ First. Earlier in the electoral cycle, National could dismiss the polls – “there’s a long way to go until the next election” – but not anymore. Polls start to matter in election year and there are only so many of them before the big day. Make no mistake, they become ever more influential.

After its 2023 election drubbing, Labour should be a mess, licking wounds and changing the leader who failed to win that last election, but the party is more than a serious option. It’s also barely visible. It has done this deliberately, because it’s working. The biggest news is that Chris Hipkins has not just got a girlfriend and a haircut, but he’s lost some weight. Now, he’s getting married. Again. Easy headlines, happy news ... soft publicity. Labour keeps its nose ahead.

Maybe we all have short memories. Yet, in the two major polls already out this year, Labour outpolls National. It is not inspiring anyone yet somehow, but National still can’t put them away.

Where’s the urgency? The mongrel? The fight? The bit that says, “I’m the Prime Minister, this is what I’m doing to make your lives easier, and those guys had their chance and could barely dress themselves each morning?”

Voters like strong leadership; they want commonsense solutions, not waffle, and they want it straight, no spin, no lies, and something we can all fact check. Luxon’s repeated claims about getting on top of spending and his line that growth is returning continue to ring hollow. He, and National, will be judged by voters when their wallet feels it.

I don’t believe Luxon isn’t trying, but he simply struggles to connect and be on the same page as ordinary Kiwis. He’s wealthy and he’s sorted, but many voters aren’t as fortunate. They’re hurting. Mortgages still bite. Groceries still sting. Power bills still make people swear. This is textbook change-of-government territory.

Sure, Luxon keeps pointing to an “economic recovery”. Fine. On paper, yes, inflation easing, but worryingly back over the 3% mark, and interest rates are stabilising. But here’s what Luxon is being punished for – we don’t feel it. If nothing changes for us when we sit down to pay all the bills, then Luxon is just noise in the distance.

The reality is no one votes on spreadsheets. They vote on vibes. And the vibe out there is anxious.

A meek National looks scared of its own shadow

Right now, Labour is surviving by doing almost nothing and National is failing by doing too little or the same old stuff. Then there’s Winston Peters, who simply will not die (I mean that metaphorically). Every time he opens his mouth, National bleeds support. Angry conservatives. Protest voters. People who don’t like Labour, but don’t quite trust Luxon, either. Peters doesn’t need to win; he just needs to siphon. From everyone. And it’s working. The net result is National voters are walking away to Winston – the polls are clear on that.

If the recovery shows up in wallets before election day, Luxon will get a lift. If it doesn’t, he’s in trouble. National simply hasn’t done enough on cost-of-living measures and will be viewed as squandering its time in charge. Too afraid to offend anyone, so it does nothing.

The big, expensive policies like NZ Super remain, welfare costs have soared as unemployment has risen, fast track has taken two years to see the first projects emerge and the Resource Management Act changes might be groundbreaking, but will ordinary Kiwis care when they need to get a second job just to pay the power bills?

And the irony of National’s meek and mild approach is that it has coalition parties that were and are more than willing to go harder. Why did National blink? Inexperience from Luxon and Finance Minister Nicola Willis, who raised expectations but never sought to follow it through?

They can’t keep blaming the previous Labour government. To be fair, yes, they might have inherited “a mess”, but surely National knew that and had some other ideas – a bit of imagination, a bit of mongrel – to sort it out? We’re still years away from a surplus and the government continues to borrow half a billion a week to keep the lights on.

Its policy offerings on electricity reforms and rates caps are so weak that it may have done less damage if it had rolled out nothing. These policies highlight how ineffective the Government has become. I doubt anyone remembers the electricity reforms and the rates-cap details. Besides, they’re so far into the future that there is a good chance none of it will happen.

If you raise expectations, you have to deliver

It’s never felt like National is actually angry on behalf of voters. Instead, we get corporate calm and carefully scripted lines. Luxon sounds like he’s managing risk, not leading a country. You don’t win by being the nicest guy in the room. You win by sounding like you’ll fight for people who are sick of being squeezed. Remember the squeezed middle? Many of us do, because we’re still there.

But Luxon is not that champion, is he? Where’s the fire? Where’s the conviction? Where are the results? Which brings us to the real problem. National raised expectations it hasn’t been able to keep. Voters really despise that, as they did when the Jacinda Ardern’s Labour government failed to deliver.

Despite the hard work of Erica Stanford and Chris Bishop in leading tangible change, National has appeared too scared to stand for anything. It’s clear voters don’t reward timid, they walk away from it. They reward leaders who look like they actually mean it.

This election is there for the taking. But if National keeps playing it safe, keeps hoping Labour will simply collapse, keeps underestimating Winston Peters, then don’t be shocked if election night is a lot tighter than it should have been.