Duncan Garner: This weekend could be the most significant of Christopher Luxon’s political career


Once again, Christopher Luxon made the bleeding obvious look far too difficult.
All the Prime Minister had to say this week was that, from an international law perspective, the US/Israel attack on Iran appears unlawful. He could then have added that Iran has sponsored some of the world’s worst terrorism during the past 30 years, leading many to view military action as justified, necessary and overdue.
He could have held both positions. He would have been right. Instead, he made a total hash of it.
Once again, Luxon proved critics right when they say he struggles to answer straightforward questions under pressure. He was unprepared for obvious questions – questions he should have faced from his own team in his own office.
Who allowed him to take that word salad to a press conference? Does he have senior staff? Who’s running the shop? This guy needs help, and fast. Never before has a prime minister’s office looked so underdone and undercooked. They’re sending their man into a gunfight armed with a plastic fork.
At the same time, it appears we’ve crawled up the backside of Donald Trump and the US. For what? We’ll get nowhere, and Trump won’t even know we’re there.
Away from his fumbles over Iran, it seems Luxon can’t catch a break. A Taxpayers’ Union-Curia Poll released yesterday must have sent shockwaves through National’s MPs. The party has plummeted to just 28 – only a few points above its 2020 election defeat. MPs are no doubt increasingly realising Luxon may not get them there.
They’re probably hoping he spends the weekend thinking about the future and comes to the same conclusion. They want Luxon to stand down rather than face a messy scrap to remove him. This weekend is now really significant for the future of the National Party and how it approaches this year’s election.
Luxon simply hasn’t been good enough or popular enough. Like it or not, this is, after all, a popularity contest, and they have time now to make something happen.
It worked for Labour when it brought in Jacinda Ardern in 2017. National now has an opportunity, but only if Luxon reads the room properly. He can return with a speech stating he is standing down for the good of the party, and the handover will then be bloodless and smooth.
Who will be the new leader? Chris Bishop? Erica Stanford? But there’s one issue here: how will Winston Peters react? He values loyalty and Luxon and Peters have been a stable force. Will Peters walk away or will Bishop offer a couple of bottles of decent whisky and talk him around? Anything is possible. Bishop is hugely personable and gets on well with Peters. And remember, it’s in the coalition’s interest to stay together, without upsetting any economic recovery.
That, of course, is now threatened by the situation in the Middle East. Geopolitics is complicated: wars, threats, regional power struggles and nuclear brinkmanship. But when bombs are falling on Iran, when reports emerge of civilians being hit, when peace and international law are on the line, that is precisely the moment a leader needs to stand up and be clear.
Instead, what we got from the Beehive was a fumbling non-position masquerading as policy. First, Luxon said New Zealand supported “any actions” that stop Iran getting a nuclear weapon or sponsoring terrorism. Then – and credit to him for putting his hand up – he apologised for that phrasing, admitting he “misspoke”. Because no responsible nation backs “any actions” indiscriminately.
Even after the back-pedalling, his core message hasn’t changed: We acknowledge the strikes. We understand why others undertook them. We condemn Iran’s regime.
Iran is run by brutal authoritarians who show little respect for their own people. Executions, repression, the crushing of dissent. These are well documented. But that is not a legal justification to invade a foreign and independent state.
He could have said both. He would have been right.
But on the other questions, were the US and Israeli strikes lawful? Were they justified? Did they breach international law? Luxon wouldn’t say. Instead, he said that’s up to the United States and Israel to explain, because New Zealand isn’t privy to the intelligence they used.
He wouldn’t say whether indiscriminate bombing – whether of military targets or a girls’ school – was wrong. He said it was up to others to tell us whether it was legal.
Meanwhile, leaders across the globe are calling for caution and restraint. Many have explicitly raised questions about military strikes in the absence of an imminent threat. Even close allies have trodden carefully. Leaders in Australia and Canada have publicly stressed that any military action must comply with international law and have avoided endorsing the legality of unilateral strikes without clear justification. They’ve acknowledged the complexity but haven’t ducked the legal frame.
Meanwhile, our PM won’t say whether he believes an attack on a sovereign nation, without UN backing or imminent threat, is lawful. Yes, the US holds the cards when it comes to trade and influence. but that doesn’t mean we take no position for fear of upsetting someone somewhere.
This is the broader problem with this government. Too often, they are afraid to commit to a position. Instead, they default to the least offensive option.
Take a stance. Have a policy. Stand for something, Prime Minister. Because having no position is like putting your hands in the air and saying, “I can’t face this. Leave me alone.”
That’s not leadership. That’s dancing on the head of a pin.
New Zealand has a proud history of upholding international law, from our nuclear-free policy to principled stances on Iraq and commitment to UN norms. Yet this government has chosen to sit on the fence.
That matters for New Zealand’s standing in the world. If you don’t stand up for international law when it’s inconvenient, you don’t get to call yourself a defender of it when it suits you.
It signals a government that runs from the tough questions, won’t stand up for the rule of law when powerful nations are involved, and is more comfortable shrugging than naming right from wrong.
Luxon let himself and his country down this week. We got the Prime Minister at his worst – and his opponents are waiting. This time, they’re likely to be from within his own party.