Listener
Opinion

An effective drug and alcohol treatment programme is being misrepresented and underfunded

Opinion by
Roger Brooking
Transformational: Research shows alcohol and other drug treatment courts are more effective at preventing reoffending than prison-based treatments. Photo / AdobeStock
Transformational: Research shows alcohol and other drug treatment courts are more effective at preventing reoffending than prison-based treatments. Photo / AdobeStock

Politicians of all persuasions tout their credentials for being tough on crime, including the current coalition government. It has brought back three strikes, boot camps, cracked down on gangs, and committed to increasing police numbers and prison capacity. In 2024, the prison population passed 10,000 and in mid-November, 2025 surged to nearly 11,000. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon described this as a “good thing”.

If governments really want to be tough on crime, instead of locking more people up, they should invest in interventions that reduce reoffending. In other words, we should address the drivers of crime. The drivers are socio-economic: poverty, dropping out of school, unemployment, cultural alienation, family dysfunction, child neglect and abuse and poor mental health, often exacerbated by alcohol and drugs. Dealing with these is truly tough – borne out by the sorry statistics describing the prevalence of every one of these problems in New Zealand.

There is one intervention that does work: alcohol and other drug treatment courts (AODTC). New Zealand has three, in central Auckland, Waitākere and Hamilton. Only high-risk, high-needs offenders with addictions are eligible, and they must face up to three years in prison. If they agree to participate, and if they graduate at the end of an 18-month programme, they’re sentenced to supervision and avoid going to prison.

This is not an easy option. The AODTC involves mandatory drug testing two or three times a week, intensive drug treatment (usually residential), anger management and parenting courses, job training and up to 180 hours of voluntary community work. The magic ingredients that make this effective include regular appearances before a trained judge, who monitors the offender’s progress every step of the way. Drug court judges offer lots of encouragement, but if offenders misbehave or return positive drug tests, they may spend a few days in prison.

In December, a conference was held in Auckland on the future of drug courts. Graduates were invited to speak; all had struggled with serious addictions and all had been to prison. Many said serving time, doing nothing all day, was a far easier option; participating in the AODTC was the toughest thing they had ever done. For those who succeed, the results are transformational.

An evaluation from 2019 found the AODTC reduced graduates’ reoffending by 86%.

Roger Brooking

The conference heard that almost half of people complete the programme. Those who do are 50% less likely to reoffend within a year than comparable high-risk offenders in the district court. An evaluation from 2019 found the AODTC reduced graduates’ reoffending by 86%, but the Ministry of Justice told cabinet it needed “further refinement ... for it to deliver better outcomes”. That’s ridiculous.

Let’s compare the AODTC with addiction treatment in prison. Corrections annual reports for the past five years show its drug treatment programmes consistently reduce reoffending by less than 5%. In other words, the AODTC is at least 10 times more effective than prison-based treatment.

Let’s compare costs. In 2020, a release by then minister Andrew Little, based on the 2019 evaluation, stated “the AODT court model is expensive to operate”. So no additional funding has since been allocated. Each drug court costs about $3.3 million a year. Yet in 2024, Corrections was given $376 million to rehabilitate offenders. It spends this on programmes that make almost no difference.

The conclusion is obvious: politicians should stop pretending to be tough on crime. Instead, they should get really tough and allocate taxpayer funding to an intervention that actually reduces crime – and which, according to participants, is much tougher than prison.

Roger Brooking is a Wellington alcohol and drug counsellor specialising in the justice sector.