Listener
Reviews

Weekend wine guide: What is wine quality?

Michael Cooper has 45 wine books and several literary awards to his credit. In the 2004 New Year Honours, Michael was appointed an Officer of the New Zealand Order of Merit.
Rare red: One of just 600 bottles of 1945 Domaine de la Romanée-Conti. Photo / Getty Images
Rare red: One of just 600 bottles of 1945 Domaine de la Romanée-Conti. Photo / Getty Images

When you buy a bottle of wine, you can pay $8 for an everyday-drinking brand or compete with those happy to pay more – a single bottle of 1945 Domaine de la Romanée-Conti was sold by Sotheby’s in 2018 for US$558,000 (then NZ$858,000). But how do you decide a wine is high quality? Quality is hard to define, according to Steve Charters, a professor of wine marketing at the Burgundy School of Business in Dijon, France. “The nature of wine quality is slippery … While ‘quality’ is widely adopted as a concept applicable to wine, it is much less frequently explained.” Wine critics and judges focus on aspect they think reveal quality, reports Charters. These factors include “complexity, intensity of flavour, harmony, finesse, balance, length, personality or distinctiveness, and purity.” But what about consumers? How does an average drinker assess the quality of a wine? Charters conducted in-depth discussions with 105 wine drinkers in Australia, pondering the criteria by which general drinkers measure wine quality. “The first was pleasure, and it is important to note that this was clearly the most important single dimension to the informants in the study; all of them, when asked what wine quality entailed, used words like ‘pleasure’, ‘enjoyment’ or ‘fun’.”

My quality ratings, based on fragrance, flavour depth, complexity, harmony and other desirable characteristics, are based on a five-star system. Three stars indicate good, above-average quality, four stars excellent quality, and five stars outstanding quality. I avoid the popular, US-based, 100-point scoring system, because it implies a degree of precision in the sensory analysis of wine that is unrealistic. Robert Hodgson, a retired US statistician and hobbyist winemaker, studied the accuracy of the 100-point scale by arranging for individual judges at the California State Fair wine competition to blind taste and rate the same wine several times. Their scores were highly inconsistent. Only about 10% of the panellists could consistently rate the same wine within the range of plus or minus two points; for example, 87-91 out of 100. A wine awarded 91 points out of 100 by a judge at the first tasting would frequently later be rated as a 95 or 87.

Wine of the week

Loop Road Central Otago Pinot Noir 2023

Certified organic, this generous red was estate-grown at Bendigo. Bright ruby, it is mouthfilling, savoury and supple, with very satisfying depth of cherry, plum and spice flavours, and plenty of drink-young appeal. (From Quartz Reef.) (14% alc/vol) $30-$35