Listener

Conversations that count: Is it time your ageing parents stopped driving?

New Zealand Listener
Conversations that count: Is it time your ageing parents stopped driving?
Driving often equates to independence, so giving it up can feel like losing freedom and admitting you’re no longer able to do things you once took for granted. Photo / Getty Images

Online only

You’re growing fearful about an older relative’s ability to keep driving. Maybe it’s because they’re confused on a route they know well or perhaps they’ve already had a car accident. So, how do you talk with them about whether it’s time to hand over the car keys?

In Part II of the listener.co.nz series ‘Conversations that count’, Age Concern’s Karen Billings-Jensen and Jackie MacIntrye share their ideas for discussing the issue so that everyone is heard and understood.

Do you think it’s time to hand over the car keys and stop driving?

  • What it should sound like: “I’m concerned about your safety on the road.”
  • What it can sound like: “You’re a danger to yourself and others. It’s time to give up your freedom and independence because you’re no longer capable.”
  • Why it’s hard: Driving often equates to independence, so giving it up can feel like losing freedom and admitting you’re no longer able to do things you once took for granted.

How do you know when it’s time to have this conversation?

According to Waka Kotahi the NZ Transport Agency, it’s time to talk about safe driving if you notice your loved one doing any of the following:

  • Driving too slowly.
  • Confusion when stopping or changing lanes.
  • Becoming lost on a route that would not previously have confused them.
  • Ignoring traffic lights and signs – confusing the colour or order of the lights or failing to notice traffic lights, Stop signs or Give Way signs.
  • Not being able to make sound judgments about what’s happening on the road.

The NZTA also points out the skills needed for safe driving include good vision in front and out of the corners of the eyes, quick reactions – to be able to brake or turn to avoid crashes, good co-ordination between eyes, hands and legs, the ability to make decisions quickly and the ability to make judgments about what’s happening on the road.

If you’re concerned about any of the above, then it’s time for the talk.

Surely any problems will be picked up when Mum or Dad renews their driver’s licence?

You’re required to renew your licence at 75 and 80, then every two years after. That involves getting a medical certificate from a doctor that says you’re well enough to drive. An on-road safety test happens only if a doctor feels it’s necessary.

So, how best to start this conversation?

Karen Billings-Jensen, Chief Executive of Age Concern New Zealand: “It’s about trying to find a natural window of opportunity and acknowledging that this can be an extremely emotive issue. For a lot of people approaching 75, when they’re first required to get a medical certificate to ensure fitness to drive, it can cause huge anxiety and might be the first time they’ve ever had to envisage life without a car. It’s a good time to start thinking and talking about what that might look like.

“Once again, if they’ve got friends or family in a similar position and the topic comes up in conversation, it’s good to take the opportunity to ask if they’ve ever thought what they would do. I think the worst thing you can do is sit someone down and say, ‘We need to have this conversation and we’re having it right now.’”

Jackie MacIntrye, community support co-ordinator, Age Concern Nelson-Tasman: “We run Life Without a Car workshops and Staying Safe: Refresher Courses for Older Drivers, with support from the NZTA. Taking part in one of these is a good opportunity to look at what skills a person has, perhaps discuss alternative modes of transport, and plant the seeds of what the future might look like without a car.”

But what if they won’t listen and you’re extremely worried they are a danger to themselves and other people?

JM: “There are people who have been advised they should no longer be driving but may continue to do so. We sometimes get family members telling us their concerns. One idea is to let the local medical practice know of your concerns or see if there’s a community constable who can come around and have a chat.”

NZTA notes if there’s a condition likely to affect a driver’s ability, it must be disclosed to their insurance company and it’s then up to the company to decide whether or not to continue insuring them. The spectre of an expensive car accident, where they might not be covered, might be enough to make some drivers hand over their keys.

KBJ: “There’s also something to be said for looking at the positives about no longer driving. The Life Without a Car booklet points out how much it costs to run a car and when you add up things like registration, car insurance, petrol, warrant of fitness checks and paying for repairs, it can equal thousands of dollars each year. That’s a lot if you just want to go to the shops once a week.”

What are the alternatives to driving?

JM: “It is a mindset shift, and it does take a while, but often people are surprised at the options that do exist. However, that can be dependent on where you live, and it can be more difficult in rural areas. So, can they car-share and get a ride with a couple of friends to do the shopping and run other errands at the same time? Is it cheaper to sell the car and use the money that would have been spent on it to pay for Ubers or taxis? Are there local service or church groups that help with driving to the shops or medical appointments? If they can use public transport, the SuperGold Card has some real advantages.”

To read about how to talk about wills and managing finances, go here.

To read about how to talk about moving out of the family home, go here.