Ridley Scott’s dull take on a post-apocalyptic thriller


The Dog Stars, directed by Ridley Scott, is in cinemas now.
The Dog Stars is Ridley Scott’s adaptation of Peter Heller’s 2012 post-apocalyptic novel of the same name. So one might reasonably expect a Blade Runner-esque dystopia, scary alien-like creatures that feast on innocent humans, or a bleak view of our likely future in the aftermath of a world-destroying virus.
But with none of the veteran director’s trademark touches, this movie feels like it could have been made by anyone. And despite a moderately propulsive story, The Dog Stars is devoid of dramatic thrills. That’s despite the efforts of a cast including hot young things Jacob Elordi and Margaret Qualley, as well as Josh Brolin and Guy Pearce.
Elordi plays widowed mechanic and Cessna pilot Hig, living in a fortified airfield in the Colorado wilderness fortress with Brolin’s Bangley, a grumpy survivalist.
Picking up an intermittent radio signal from “Grand Junction”, naturally the young guy wants to explore further afield to see if life is better out there. But the old guy says it’s safer just to stay where they are, barricaded against the “Reapers” – desperate, marauding human survivors who murder and pillage.
When Hig’s inevitable exploration brings him to Qualley (The Substance) and her suspicious dad (Pearce), assumptions are tested as all characters learn lessons about trust and community.
With heart throb Elordi in the lead, Heller’s story has all the hallmarks of young adult story adaptations like Tomorrow, When the War Began and The 5th Wave, except that the bloody violence depicted in the film is definitely not for younger viewers. But the bigger issue is that Heller’s novel is purposefully quiet and reflective, which doesn’t translate easily to film. What we get instead is prosaic explanation of purpose, and painfully thin characterisation.
Brolin reportedly tried to leave the production after one day on set, due to artistic differences. He stayed, and delivers his familiar gruff old-timer role, a performance choice no doubt made because he seems to have had no directorial guidance from Scott.
This was the director’s MO in recent films such as House of Gucci and Gladiator 2, which employed top-tier stars – Denzel Washington, Lady Gaga, Paul Mescal – who were apparently left to their own initiative with uneven results.
The Dog Stars marks the prolific 88-year-old director’s 30th feature, but one of his least memorable.
Rating out of five: ★★½