How the Springboks will respond to first-test defeat – Gregor Paul


By Gregor Paul in Johannesburg
No one need be in any doubt that the Springboks will come back harder in Cape Town after losing at Ellis Park.
They will carry the ball with more venom, drive into the tackles with more explosive energy and smack black shirts with a kind of rabid intensity.
It is the way the Boks have responded for more than a century. They lose, they hurt, they get angry and they double down on the physicality.
It’s maybe the Calvinist mindset and work ethic driving that response – a conviction that the method was right in the defeat, but not the execution.
New Zealand didn’t break at Ellis Park when they were smashed with the proverbial hammer, but the Boks will convince themselves that if they just swing it harder in Cape Town, there will be splintered bits of All Blacks all over the place.
And maybe they are right. Maybe the All Blacks rode their luck in the first test, winning a scrum penalty in the 55th minute that turned the momentum of the game, but one that could, just as easily, have gone the other way and sunk them.
The smash-them-until-they-break plan was working for the Boks and they were just one decision away from destroying the All Blacks physically.
It was gladiatorial for a period, the crowd baying for more scrums as if the Boks were lions, the All Blacks slaves and the odds of the latter getting out of the Colosseum alive were decidedly low.
That’s the abiding memory the Boks will have of the game – and it is one that will persuade them to go again, to come at the All Blacks with all of the same weaponry.
But it wasn’t luck that changed the game. The All Blacks didn’t piggyback their way to glory on good fortune. It was the depth of their character, the unity and smartness of their leadership, their ability to problem-solve and their precision to convert the little moments into points.

It was also their ability to pass and catch, to run into space, to ask different questions of the defence and use different means to implement their plan. In short, it was their ability to play a bit of rugby that got them home.
Even that laundry list of qualities doesn’t get to the heart of what really won the All Blacks the test.
There was something intangible about their quality – a hard-to-pinpoint essence that could be labelled an esprit de corps,and whatever it was, they had enough of it to absorb the onslaught they faced and be the physically dominant team in the final quarter.
The nature of the win was important because it has not only set the All Blacks up well in the series, but it’s also proven they have the physical, mental, tactical and technical capacity to beat any team – including the defending World Cup champions – in a one-off fixture.
That was not the case last year. Under the old regime, the All Blacks were not a great bet to win a one-off test against South Africa. They didn’t have the resilience – the ability to recalibrate and find a way to stay strong in the toughest moments.
They didn’t have 80 test-class minutes in them, but under the new regime, it’s possible to cast forward and see the All Blacks beating the Springboks in a World Cup quarter-final, or the French in a semi, or England, Ireland, Scotland or Argentina at any stage of the tournament.
That’s a huge turnaround and maybe the biggest positive to take out of the 33-16 win. The All Blacks are now genuine World Cup contenders – something they weren’t 12 months ago.
In the context of the series, what the nature of the victory has done is put enormous pressure on the Boks to broaden their tactical scope from the strict confinement of scrummaging for penalties, box-kicking and mauling.
That menu was not enough to win at Ellis Park and if they do indeed double down on the physicality in Cape Town, there is a definitive sense the All Blacks will be able to handle it second time around, depower it and once again ask the question whether the Boks have anything else to offer other than set-piece grunt and the magnificent Jasper Weise.

That’s maybe a leap to assume the All Blacks have found the means to depower the Springboks but they have this esprit de corps now, the confidence in their leadership and belief in themselves now they have done it once.
But more critically, with 80 minutes of exposure under their belts to South Africa’s scrummaging, this All Blacks team should be able to reconfigure, adapt and cope with what is coming.
This is the essence of good All Blacks teams – they review well, innovate and elevate their training to come out ready and better – and if South Africa retain their mindset of trying to win the game on muscle alone, the result will look much the same in test two as it did in test one.
If South Africa are to win this second test, then they will have to play more rugby than they did in Johannesburg, and that’s the big question mark hanging over them now: do they have the skillsets, athletes and mindset to run more, to counter-attack and to offload?
Or more simply, they have to show they can play a little bit of rugby.
Gregor Paul is one of New Zealand’s most respected rugby writers and columnists. He has won multiple awards for journalism and written several books about sport.
Listen to Elliott Smith’s live commentary on Newstalk ZB Sport and iHeartRadio, or join the Alternative Commentary Collective on iHeartRadio and Radio Hauraki.