Analysis

All Blacks v Springboks: Flaws exposed as Dave Rennie’s side fall to 43-28 loss in Baltimore – Gregor Paul

Gregor Paul
Analysis by
Rugby analyst and feature writer
All Blacks halfback Cam Roigard makes a break in the fourth test against the Springboks in Baltimore. Photo / Photosport
All Blacks halfback Cam Roigard makes a break in the fourth test against the Springboks in Baltimore. Photo / Photosport

Gregor Paul in Baltimore

The series has gone, the All Blacks have suffered three defeats in a row and a sense has developed that having been tracking close to the Springboks at Ellis Park, the All Blacks have slipped a length behind the Boks.

Baltimore was not a happy place. It was sobering and perhaps psychologically triggering, given how dominant the Boks looked by the end of a match which they won 43-28.

For the second week in a row, the All Blacks were beaten by a better team – one that had too much power, too much rugby intelligence and too much creativity.

But this time they were well beaten – made to look tired, lacking in physicality and energy against a team that seem to have limitless potential.

In a series that was painted as power versus pace, the Boks ended up winning both titles and playing like they were just as comfortable to pass and catch as they were to kick and maul.

The winning margin may have slightly flattered the Boks, but only just. When it came down to it, there was daylight between the two teams.

There wasn’t any facet of the game in which the All Blacks looked better and this whole idea that the Boks could be run off their feet turned out to be a fallacy.

They looked fit, strong, quick and full of running – something that couldn’t be said about the All Blacks, who were dead on their feet in the final 10 minutes.

All Blacks halfback Cam Roigard makes a break in the fourth test against the Springboks in Baltimore. Photo / Photosport
All Blacks halfback Cam Roigard makes a break in the fourth test against the Springboks in Baltimore. Photo / Photosport

No question it was a long tour for the All Blacks, one that will ultimately grow them and become a focal point for them as they develop from here, and one that they use as a reference point to determine all the things they need to improve.

And that won’t be hard for them to work out. The same old problems plagued the All Blacks throughout the game.

The scrum battle was closer, less obviously a big win for the Boks, but it was still a victory for them and is still a weapon for them – either in its ability to win a few critical penalties, or to be a destructive launchpad.

The All Blacks, again, had periods where they couldn’t cleanly catch or retrieve the high ball and it meant there were long periods in both halves where South Africa held possession and were able to play at their pace and control the game.

It set them up to make multiple entries into the All Blacks 22, and to then come in waves, pounding away at the All Blacks in that “will this ever stop?” way of theirs.

The All Blacks defended defiantly and for the fourth week in succession they gave everything. Ethan Blackadder was immense, Richie Mo’unga was calm and fluid and Peter Lakai had another game in which he looked like an All Blacks great in the making, but none of it was enough.

The All Blacks couldn’t find a way to put enough pressure on the Springboks, not even after they scored their second try on the back of 32 phases that were as brilliant as they were relentless.

The Boks kept hammering them, but the ball runners, as per the ethos of “back in game, go again”, kept coming and the handling was clean, the retention perfect and the cleaners didn’t miss a bit.

The Springboks scrum goes to work against the All Blacks in Baltimore. Photo / Photosport
The Springboks scrum goes to work against the All Blacks in Baltimore. Photo / Photosport

As passages of play go, it was both stunning but potentially massively influential as it forced the Springboks forwards to work their little green socks to defend their line in temperatures that were close to 85 degrees Fahrenheit, or 27C in a proper measurement system that is not unfathomable.

And forcing the bigger Boks forwards to run and tackle was the central plank of the All Blacks’ game plan.

This whole series has been built on the narrative that if the game is allowed to flow, go from end-to-end in a battle of aerobic capacity, then the All Blacks will prevail.

It’s a narrative that has got under Springboks coach Rassie Erasmus’ skin as he’s possibly feared that it’s true. But he’s hidden that fact behind insinuations that the All Blacks are trying to win a culture war and depower scrums and other collision elements that give rugby its essence.

That the series has been framed as a battle for rugby’s soul has created all the drama and tension – and the critical, underappreciated metric to follow in the first half was not so much the sense of ebb and flow when the ball was in play, but the number and length of stoppages.

It’s the breathers by stealth that play against the All Blacks – the frustration of having South Africans gasping a little for air, only to be able to get the oxygen debt under control via a heavily choreographed scrum reset or “hamstring strain” in need of an urgent rub.

But having been forced to stand around for an inordinate amount of time after the first quarter, while the referees explained that they had lost comms with the command centre and had to seek permission from both teams to carry on with radio silence, the All Blacks couldn’t get the flow they wanted.

Not that it made any difference. The truth about this series is that the Boks are better, just as fit and just as capable with the ball.

All Blacks 28 (Codie Taylor, Will Jordan, Ethan Blackadder, Beauden Barrett tries; Damian McKenzie 4 cons)

Springboks 43 (Damian de Allende, Morne van den Berg, Malcolm Marx, Pieter-Steph du Toit, Kurt-Lee Arendse, Cameron Hanekom tries; Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu 2 cons, pen, van den Berg con, Manie Libbok 2 cons)

HT: 14-17

Gregor Paul is one of New Zealand’s most respected rugby writers and columnists. He has won multiple awards for journalism and written several books about sport.

Listen to Elliott Smith’s live commentary on Newstalk ZB Sport and iHeartRadio, or join the Alternative Commentary Collective on iHeartRadio and Radio Hauraki.