NZ20 cricket: Greats demand release of Deloitte report

NZ Herald
The Northern Brave celebrate winning the men's 2026 Super Smash grand final. Photo / Photosport
Staff believe CEO Scott Weenink was 'pushed out' over T20 private series decision, a leaked internal staff survey reveals. Shayne Currie joins Herald NOW. Video / Ryan Bridge TODAY

Some of the biggest names in New Zealand cricket have demanded answers from the sport’s national organising body about the impact of the proposed NZ20 competition.

A legal letter sent to the New Zealand Cricket (NZC) board and chief executive Geoff Allott, signed by many of the country’s greatest players, calls for the release of the Deloitte Report into proposals for future structures of the game.

The letter also calls for the release of the NZC management’s recommendations on the issue.

The letter says: “NZC has publicly promoted NZ20 as its preferred model for the future of domestic T20 cricket and indicated that the competition would involve external investment and the sale of interests in participating teams. The board has publicly stated that NZ20 was selected as NZC’s preferred option following consideration of alternative models. However, members have not been provided with the report that informed that decision.”

The letter goes on to claim: “The limited information available raises legitimate questions as to whether the structuring and implementation of NZ20 is consistent with [NZC’s] constitution.”

The signatories call for clarity on NZC’s dealings with “third-party investors and corporate entities that sit outside NZC’s constitutional framework”.

All signatories to the letter are life members or honorary members of NZC.

The letter is signed by Glenn Turner, Jeremy Coney, Stephen Boock, Ewen Chatfield, Dayle Hadlee, Sir Richard Hadlee, Stuart Heal, Lesley Murdoch, Richard Collinge and Justin Vaughan.

“We wish to emphasise that we support initiatives designed to strengthen New Zealand cricket and secure its long-term future,” the letter says. “Our concern is not with reform itself, but with ensuring that any reform occurs transparently, lawfully, and in accordance with the constitution.

“Accordingly, we request that NZC implements a fair and transparent dispute procedure.”

The Deloitte report – which is understood to have cost $500,000 – was initiated by former NZC chief executive Scott Weenink and tasked consultancy firm Deloitte with assessing the options for the future of domestic Twenty20 cricket.

Deloitte looked at four options, with the findings presented to NZC’s board to inform its decision on the future of the game. The options were:

  • An NZC-run team in the Big Bash League;
  • A privately funded franchise competition within New Zealand;
  • A revamped version of the existing Super Smash;
  • Retaining the status quo.

It is understood that only two of the options were seriously considered: the Big Bash League or the private franchise league – known as NZ20.

Sources have told the Herald that NZ20 was the preferred option of the New Zealand Cricket Players Association and the six major associations – Auckland, Northern Districts, Central Districts, Wellington, Canterbury and Otago.

In March, the board decided to back NZ20, which saw one of its members, former Black Cap Dion Nash, resign as a result.

In September, bowling great Hadlee and Murdoch, a former NZC president, both wrote letters criticising the organisation. They claimed they had been promised access to the full Deloitte report after they provided information for the writing of it.

NZC has been contacted for a response.