All Blacks: Wales defeat puts Dave Rennie’s team rotation under scrutiny


Being the team responsible for the end of 73 years of historic rugby dominance might seem punishment enough, but Sunday morning’s match brought a big lesson for Dave Rennie and his co-coaches – and for those who thought the All Blacks’ 10-man rotation of their team to play the supposedly weak Welsh was appropriate.
Hindsight? No, before the All Blacks’ northern tour I maintained Rennie needed to play his top team consistently after the Springbok series to build combinations and rhythm – both conspicuously lacking against Wales. Not only was the Nations Championship at stake but the All Blacks had already built depth using almost 50 players in South Africa, prompting this: “There’s a need now to lock in his top 23 to build teamwork and combinations that minimise errors and maximise performance.”
Rennie was unrepentant, saying the side selected was good enough to win, had plenty of chances, but weren’t clinical enough in the face of Wales’ fierce defence: “So, no, I have no regrets about the side we picked. As I talked about previously, there’s really good competition with places, there’s not a lot between certain positions.”
Really? Was that the correct focus right now? Surely the time to rotate was the second Bledisloe Cup test against the Wallabies after the beating handed out in the first test and when the cup could not be lost. Only four changes were made to the starting team then – three for injuries.
The World Cup is not far away – and while Rennie is missing a handful of injured top teamers, there’s no substitute for playing together, especially given the All Blacks’ high-octane, high-risk attacking style. The 1996 All Blacks made history in winning a series in South Africa for the first time – playing 10 tests in 12 weeks that year with the starting pack unchanged in all 10; four backs also started all 10 tests.
This result was Rennie’s first big blooper as All Blacks coach, a loss which may damage the careers of a few of those in “certain positions”. Like first five-eighths, where the jury is out about Richie Mo’unga and whether his ineffectiveness was down to rust or whether the brow of a certain hill has been crested. Back in August, I asked why the All Blacks needed Mo’unga? Satisfactory answer (other than injury cover) still required.
There’s an argument Mo’unga had to play for assessment/game-time purposes. There’s another that Damian McKenzie, with his superior speed and sharpness, would have made more of the couple of half-breaks Mo’unga fashioned in the second half, semi-puncturing a defence the All Blacks struggled to find creative ways past.

The following first-teamers could have played (though Jordie Barrett was rested as a precaution after a head knock): Codie Taylor, Ethan de Groot, Fabian Holland, Tupou Vaa’i, Cam Roigard, McKenzie and Barrett. The tight five are particularly relevant as the All Blacks were beaten at the breakdowns; the halfbacks, Mo’unga and Cortez Ratima, were alarmingly outplayed by Tomos Williams and Sam Costelow. The other concern was the penetration of the back three as the All Blacks battered away at the Welsh line, only to be held up three times in a performance light on variation and creativity.
There can’t be enough praise for the Welsh defence – it undoubtedly won the game, along with their attacking intent. On that score, Fehi Fineanganofo was shown up by Louis Rees-Zammit for pace and invention. Josh Moorby had little influence on events and Beauden Barrett, in a nervy display, made a bad decision early in the second half which led to the winning try.
There’s no question the All Blacks are missing wounded wings Will Jordan, Caleb Clarke and even Leroy Carter and there’s a feeling they have never quite replaced Mark Telea. Leicester Fainga’anuku did for a time but his hybrid role means being on the bench; he managed little in the face of Wales’ desperate defence. Jury’s out there too.
Rennie’s decision at first five-eighths is difficult. Ruben Love is out for the time being and is still a work in progress. If he goes with Mo’unga, he needs to play him all the time (same with Love). If McKenzie, he needs to solve the fullback issue. Beauden Barrett did well there against Australia after being a forlorn, out-of-sorts figure in Super Rugby, but he was hesitant against Wales and seems a risk at 15, particularly in the likely World Cup quarter-final against the Springboks.
There’s another dimension to this whole rotation business. The days when the mighty All Blacks could rotate a whole team and still win – as they did in 2005 – have gone the way of the transistor radio, fondue sets and floppy disks. It’s the kind of thing that prompts other countries to label Kiwis arrogant in a rugby context. Pre-match coverage in New Zealand was unanimous in the view that Wales were no chance of beating the All Blacks. The TAB had the hosts paying $13 for the win.
The cold, hard truth is that Sunday morning’s test might have ended some careers. Rennie’s own is not in danger but a flawed win against Wales hastened Scott Robertson’s departure after leaking four tries; the All Blacks shipped five with some soft defence this time. It’s time Rennie’s “trajectory” involved consistent fielding of his top team.
Paul Lewis writes about rugby, cricket, league, football, yachting, golf, the Olympics and Commonwealth Games.