Toolkit supports transgender and non-binary participants in community sport – Alice Soper


In July last year, Minister for Sport and Recreation Mark Mitchell made the controversial decision to remove the guidance for the inclusion of transgender people in community sport from Sport New Zealand Ihi Aotearoa’s website.
The origin of this guidance was a response to growing requests for support from the sporting community. As a result, principles were established for and by sports administrators from around the country, following an extensive consultation process.
However, with the change in Government and the signing of coalition agreements, politics overrode this consensus. This led to the deletion of the guidance.
The guidance may have been removed, but the need that led to its creation didn’t go anywhere. Sports organisations were told by Mitchell at the time that they “themselves are best placed to know how to run their code in a safe and fair way”. One sports organisation was listening carefully to this edict and decided to step up to fill the vacuum, assembling a toolkit to support community sports to run in a safe and fair way for everyone.
That sporting organisation was Women in Sport Aotearoa (Wispa). Which, alongside InsideOUT Kōaro and the Clare Foundation, has launched a comprehensive toolkit for the inclusion of transgender and non-binary participants in community sport. The organisations’ motivation is stated clearly at the top of this guidance: “Wispa believes that it is everyone’s job, as collective guardians of the sports system, to make sure that no one is left behind.”
Their inclusive approach starts with four simple questions. First, they ask sports to reflect on the inherent unfairness that they have accepted as part of their chosen code. Then they ask them to check the research to determine whether transgender participants breach those parameters or if the situation is related to gender at all. For example, discrepancies in skill level or technical ability, variance in height or weight or issues related to bias already exist across sport, regardless of who is playing.
Finally, they ask sports to reflect on what grounds safety is being assessed.
By working through these questions, it becomes apparent how much unfairness is routinely tolerated across participation in sport. The initial guidance introduced for safety back when trans women could still play rugby in England, set the weight and height requirements at a level that would have flagged most cis women in the forward pack as a danger. It was only the assignment of their gender at birth that removed any concern that their size gave an unfair advantage over teammates.
The skill gap has long been an issue in women’s sports, with first-timers regularly competing against internationals. When Super Rugby Aupiki offered all athletes the opportunity to go fulltime this season, we saw the skill level rise across the competition.
Those players not selected for the Black Ferns and Black Ferns XV sides will now be released back into their provinces for the Farah Palmer Cup, coming into the competition off a professional pre-season to play against those weekend warriors from the local club scene. Their technical ability will be higher, not because of their gender but because of their circumstance.
This is what the research tells us and it’s reflected in the guidance Wispa has put together. That work shows there is currently too much emphasis on biomedical factors, while social factors remain sidelined in policymaking.
I know from my own experience as an athlete what difference the access to a nutritionist, trainers, physios, facilities and even a full-length competition did for my abilities. It put me ahead of my peers when I returned to Wellington, but no one thought to regulate me out of the game.
Wispa’s toolkit offers a thorough and practical approach to participation – a clear-headed look at the landscape and how to support the grassroots of our games. It weeds out the politics of the day to allow all of us to play on.
Sports columnist Alice Soper is a former provincial rugby player and current club coach, she has a particular interest in telling stories of the emerging world of women’s sports.