Rotorua’s reform plan collapses after councillors reject both options

Rotorua Lakes Council meets to discuss its Head Start local government reform options. Photo / Mathew Nash
Rotorua Lakes Council meets to discuss its Head Start local government reform options. Photo / Mathew Nash

Rotorua Lakes Council has failed to reach an agreement on how it wants to approach local government reforms.

It voted today against submitting a voluntary reform Head Start application alongside Tauranga City Council, and against taking the Government’s alternative Backstop reform process.

What was initially scheduled to be a largely procedural meeting today turned into anything but following the events of the past week.

The meeting was initially meant as a final chance to ratify what appeared a done-deal to join a Bay of Plenty-wide Head Start proposal featuring a western authority covering Tauranga and Western Bay of Plenty, an eastern authority for Kawerau, Whakatāne and Ōpōtiki, and a central authority for Rotorua.

But councillors were forced back to the drawing board after the proposal fell apart this week when Whakatāne, Ōpōtiki and Kawerau submitted their own Eastern Bay proposal, independent of the region’s other councils.

 Rotorua Lakes Council debates its approach to local government reform. Chief executive Andrew Moraes, Deputy Mayor Sandra Kai Fong and  democracy and governance advisor Robert Griffith. Photo / Mathew Nash
Rotorua Lakes Council debates its approach to local government reform. Chief executive Andrew Moraes, Deputy Mayor Sandra Kai Fong and democracy and governance advisor Robert Griffith. Photo / Mathew Nash

Then Western Bay councillors voted against an amalgamation with Tauranga City on Thursday. Tauranga voted to press ahead with its plan without Western Bay’s support.

But Head Start proposals require at least two councils to proceed - and the deadline for applications is Sunday.

A new motion was tabled in Rotorua today that would have seen the council partner with Tauranga to submit a proposal creating two unitary authorities, one for Rotorua and one covering Tauranga and Western Bay of Plenty, despite Western Bay’s opposition.

Head Start proposals can include unwilling partners where the submitting councils have a larger combined population.

Alternatively, councillors were asked to support entering Backstop, the Government-led mandatory reform process.

In the end, they voted for neither.

A motion supporting Backstop was lost 6-5. A motion to proceed with the revised Head Start proposal met the same fate.

Councillor Merepeka Raukawa-Tait voted against both motions.

Council chief executive Andrew Moraes said the result was that he was “not authorised” to submit a Head Start proposal.

Mayor Tania Tapsell had urged councillors to back Head Start, saying it was Rotorua’s best opportunity to shape its own future rather than leave the decision to central government.

“Head Start is now. Backstop will be Government-led,” she said.

“Head Start at least gives us an opportunity to make our decision and avoid a wider regional authority.”

As debate continued, Tapsell acknowledged the difficult position councillors had been placed in after the collapse of the original proposal.

“It has been incredibly hard, and there are heavy hearts,” she said.

“Please trust me on this one. I have had many conversations with ministers, and I do strongly believe Head Start is the best opportunity for Rotorua.”

 Rotorua Lakes Council debates its approach to local government reform. Councillors Merepeka Raukawa-Tait, Ben Sandford, and Robert Lee.  Photo / Mathew Nash 07 August 2026
Rotorua Lakes Council debates its approach to local government reform. Councillors Merepeka Raukawa-Tait, Ben Sandford, and Robert Lee. Photo / Mathew Nash 07 August 2026

Councillor Trevor Maxwell supported the Head Start proposal, arguing Rotorua risked surrendering its influence if it chose not to participate.

“If we are not at the table we won’t have a say. This is the only viable option available to us,” he said.

“We need to consider what is best for Rotorua.”

Opponents, however, argued the council should not force Western Bay of Plenty into a proposal after its councillors had explicitly rejected amalgamation.

Councillor Karen Barker said attempting to achieve the same outcome through another pathway was “disingenuous”.

“They were elected by their community as are we,” she said.

“To manoeuvre them into this does not sound collaborative and is not an act of good faith.

“We have unwilling partners. It will put a strain on any relationships ... I cannot support what is in front of us.”

 Rotorua Lakes Council debates its approach to local government reform. Councillors Trevor Maxwell, Don Paterson and Karen Barker. Photo / Mathew Nash 07 August 2026
Rotorua Lakes Council debates its approach to local government reform. Councillors Trevor Maxwell, Don Paterson and Karen Barker. Photo / Mathew Nash 07 August 2026

Raukawa-Tait said maintaining trust between councils was paramount.

“Relationships are key to everything,” she said.

“Once trust has been eroded it is very hard to come back from that.”

She later described the reform process as flawed, saying councillors were being asked to make a significant decision without enough detail.

“We don’t know the detail. We are asking our community to trust the process and the Government.”

Councillor Robert Lee also criticised the pace of reform, saying councillors should not abandon their principles because circumstances had changed.

“Principles are not what we dispose of when inconvenient. They are what we stick to,” he said.

“Let’s not be bullied into this sham of a process.”

Following the failed votes, Tapsell said Local Government Minister Simon Watts had indicated the Government could allow an extension of up to one month for a Head Start proposal and moved that the council reconvene next week to consider its options.

Tauranga Mayor Mahe Drysdale could not be reached for comment this evening.

Western Bay of Plenty Mayor James Denyer had not been fully briefed on the outcome of Rotorua’s meeting, but said it would be interesting to see what happened next.

“Whatever happens, we will try to do the best for our communities.”

All three mayors had supported pursuing the three-way unitary model through Head Start.

This week’s events came after Rotorua’s initial three-way merger talks with Taupō and South Waikato collapsed after Taupō withdrew, opting for Backstop. South Waikato later shifted focus to a possible Waikato River catchment proposal with Waipā and Waikato councils.

The deadline for Head Start proposals is this Sunday.

Mathew Nash is a Local Democracy Reporting journalist based at the Rotorua Daily Post. He has previously written for SunLive, been a regular contributor to RNZ and was a football reporter in the UK for eight years.

- LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.