Will we get 50-year mortgages? – Darcy Ungaro

THE FACTS
- Donald Trump proposes a 50-year mortgage to address housing affordability.
- Extending mortgage terms lowers payments but increases total interest paid over time.
- Longer terms may not fix affordability, as they can drive up house prices by increasing borrowing capacity.
In the US, Donald Trump is talking about home loans with a 50-year term. Will New Zealand follow suit?
It’s taking longer for people to buy their first home in economies throughout the Western world. What to do? Right on cue, the Trump administration proposes a 50‑year mortgage as a fix.
Would a 50-year mortgage cure housing affordability, or is it just a way of locking the next generation into debt for life?
Here in New Zealand, the age of the average first‑home buyer is 36, so it’s likely they’ll still be paying off a 30‑year mortgage anyway when they start getting NZ Super.
Extending mortgage terms from 30 to 50 years lowers payments, but is it really a solution to long-term affordability? Longer loan terms help those struggling with cashflow, but over time, the lender gets more interest.
Let’s look at what’s likely to happen.
Once upon a time, you could easily get a mortgage with a deposit of as little as 5%. These days, you need closer to 20%. If you do manage to buy a home, your next challenge is making sure you can afford it through your family life, as your income goes up and down.
On a $1 million mortgage, moving from a 30- to a 50-year loan term would cut your payments by about 17%. That’s helpful for a young family starting out. It leaves you more money for other things, or it means higher-value homes are now within your reach.
For example, a $1m mortgage over 30 years costs roughly the same each month as a $1.2m mortgage over 50 years. Some homeowners will take the lower payments; some will buy a bigger house, but either way, a longer-mortgage term can be a genuine lifeline.
But what about the extra interest you pay?
This comes down to three things: how much you borrow, the interest rate and your loan term.
If you borrowed $1m for 30 years, you’d pay almost $800,000 in interest. Over 50 years, that has grown to $1.5m. Sure, the payments are lower, but is it worth paying the bank another $700,000? It all depends.
Borrowing to buy a flash new car, a holiday, or anything that can’t be sold later to clear the mortgage would be a mistake.
But housing might grow in value faster than the interest bill does over 30 or more years. And you can also sell your house later in life, hopefully at a profit.
Having a mortgage for longer is only a trap when you’re buying things that depreciate with borrowed money. Everyday investors can still beat inflation by swapping tomorrow’s weaker dollars for today’s stronger ones (borrowing), to buy things that have historically risen in price (like housing).
Coming out of the Great Depression, President Roosevelt wanted to get America booming again. In the US at that time, a typical mortgage term was just three to five years, but by the late 1940s it was becoming more common to borrow over 30-year terms. And that was when the average life expectancy was in the mid-60s.
It meant the debt might last longer than you did, but the boom in credit growth helped fuel an economic recovery. Is the Trump administration simply following the same playbook?
Adjusted for life expectancy, it’s not as radical as it sounds, but it still doesn’t fix housing affordability.
A 50-year term wouldn’t make it easier to save a deposit or build more homes. It merely pours more credit into a market already constrained by supply. When more people qualify to borrow more money, they end up bidding against each other for the same limited stock of houses, pushing up prices again. Perhaps that’s the point?
Governments, households and businesses aren’t about to stop borrowing from banks, and central banks aren’t about to abandon positive inflation targets. Long story short, this means inflation is baked into the system.
For borrowers, this is a great thing. In real terms, the burden of our mortgage falls as the years go by, so the more years, in theory, the better. The strategy is to borrow over longer terms and use the cash-flow savings to buy more productive or scarce assets that rise in price. Inflation quietly erodes the real value of what you owe while your assets (hopefully) grow faster than the interest bill.
So, are 50-year mortgages coming to New Zealand? Not yet, but it doesn’t matter. Many borrowers are already living with something that smells a lot like a rolling 40- or 50-year mortgage, simply because they changed banks and reset their loan term back up to 30 years.
Whether it’s a lifeline or a trap, the real question is whether longer terms are the right tool for you to use.
Catch up on the debates that dominated the week by signing up to our Opinion newsletter – a weekly round-up of our best commentary.