Whakatāne water services: Council asks public to choose between CCO and in-house unit

Diane McCarthy
Whakatāne District Council advertising, seeking public opinion on forming a water services CCO. Photo / Whakatāne District Council
Whakatāne District Council advertising, seeking public opinion on forming a water services CCO. Photo / Whakatāne District Council

An organisation dedicated entirely to water services would save Whakatāne ratepayers $1.4 million over eight years, Mayor Nandor Tanczos says.

Members of the public have one week left to comment on what sort of organisation they want to provide drinking water, wastewater and stormwater services for Whakatāne district in the future.

Whakatāne District Council’s original preferred option was to form a council-controlled organisation (CCO) with Rotorua Lakes, Kawerau and Ōpōtiki district councils, as that had been modelled to create the greatest long-term savings for ratepayers.

However, none of the other councils have indicated they wish to join together at this stage.

While forming a specialist organisation on its own would still have financial advantages, these savings would be modest compared to a multi-CCO due to the smaller scale.

An investigation by consultants, MartinJenkins showed a Whakatāne-owned CCO could achieve about $1m in capital efficiencies and $400,000 in operating efficiencies by 2034, even after accounting for the estimated costs of about $2.5m for establishing the CCO.

“There are costs involved in establishing and running a separate organisation, and we’ve taken those into account,” Tanczos said.

“Our analysis shows the benefits of a Whakatāne District Council-owned CCO outweigh those additional costs by a small margin, even if it operates for Whakatāne district alone.”

 Whakatāne Mayor Nandor Tanczos says establishing a dedicated organisation for water services will have benefits for the community. Photo / LDR
Whakatāne Mayor Nandor Tanczos says establishing a dedicated organisation for water services will have benefits for the community. Photo / LDR

Those financial savings were not the only benefits forming a CCO would bring.

“[The CCO] would give us a dedicated organisation focused entirely on water services, with specialist governance and management, greater financial flexibility and borrowing capacity, while retaining 100% local ownership,” Tanczos said.

The other option for the council was to deliver water services through an internal business unit.

Because of new Government legislation, a dedicated, ring-fenced water services business unit is being established and will be in place by next July.

While this will ring-fence all finances for water services from other council activities, compared to a CCO, it will have financial constraints limiting investment in necessary infrastructure and limited flexibility if the council chooses to join with other councils in future.

“The previous government has made it more difficult and more expensive to keep delivering water services in-house, as we have done in the past. With new restrictions, I’m not even sure that we would be able to deliver what we need to over the next 30 or so years,” Tanczos said.

While a multi-CCO is off the table for now, the council also wants to know how the public feels about this option in the future.

Moving from a single council to a multicouncil organisation would not require a further round of public consultation.

It would facilitate working together with other councils in the future.

“That could be structural, through a shared CCO, or it might be with shared procurement and other services,” Tanczos said.

“I see it as a stepping stone. We can get the structure right for Whakatāne district now, while continuing to pursue opportunities for greater scale over the longer term.”

Several public engagement events have been held around the district since consultation opened this month, where concerns were raised that forming a CCO could lead to water services being privatised in future.

“This isn’t privatisation,” Tanczos said.

The Local Government (Water Services) Act 2025 required water assets to remain in public ownership, so establishing a Council Controlled Organisation did not mean those assets could be sold off to a private company.

 Whakatāne District Council Local Waters Done Well transition director Nic Johansson (centre) and other three waters managers speak with members of the public at a recent engagement event. Photo / Whakatāne District Council
Whakatāne District Council Local Waters Done Well transition director Nic Johansson (centre) and other three waters managers speak with members of the public at a recent engagement event. Photo / Whakatāne District Council

Under a single-council CCO, water assets and associated debt would be transferred to the CCO.

The CCO would manage water services on behalf of the council, and the council would be the sole shareholder.

The CCO would be governed and operated independently to council, with its own chief executive and board of directors, but the council would continue to provide oversight and set expectations for how water services were delivered.

“The organisation would remain publicly owned and accountable to the council and the communities it serves,” Tanczos said.

– LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.