Tom Phillips shooting: Documentary crew accessed scene before forensic examination finished

Police officers in charge of the Tom Phillips shooting scene and campsite where he had been evading capture formally challenged a Netflix documentary crew’s access but were told it was approved by top brass.
Police today released a review into their collaboration with the documentary, led by Dame Julie Christie with the working title The Marokopa Project.
The 90-minute to two-hour documentary is being produced for Netflix by Christie’s NHNZ Worldwide and UK-based Grain Media.
A camera operator followed the inquiry’s lead detective and several other officers as they worked to find the fugitive father.

The review reveals that the day after Phillips was killed in a shootout with police on Waitomo’s Te Anga Road, Christie and a cameraman were given ”privileged, controlled access” to the scene for 25-30 minutes.
Phillips’ body had been removed but not all forensic examinations were completed, the review said.
“Dame Julie Christie and a cameraman were permitted to attend and film from the northern side of Te Anga Road, an area that had been forensically processed. They were accompanied by the Officer in Charge of the Scene, who provided a recorded operational narrative. At the time of access, key elements to the scene remained in situ, including the ATV and Police vehicles. Forensic evidence was present and visible within the scene at this time,” the review said.
The pair were also given access – under a police escort – to a campsite where Phillips’ children had been located. Exclusive access to the scene was authorised by the Acting District Commander Andrea McBeth.
“At the time of access, the forensic examination had not been completed, and key elements of the scene remained in situ,” the review said.
The review also revealed that the officers in charge of both scenes challenged the documentary crew getting behind the cordons.
“Both Officers in Charge of their respective scenes were cognisant that granting such access to the documentary production was inconsistent with established best practice and had created additional scene-management risks that required careful control. Each officer formally challenged the decision to permit access; however, access was approved with communication [staff] emphasising that the agreement with the documentary crew was approved at a senior level,” the review said.
Police’s executive Director of Media and Communications Cass Carter said some of what police could do better - “such as giving documentary staff access to crimes scenes” was already clear going into the review.
“I can assure people, right from the start, there were strict settings in place to protect the children and sensitive Police operational information.
“While the documentary did not compromise investigative integrity, we know there was a perceived conflict, and it did create conditions where integrity required protection. Some staff had reservations which they raised at the time,” Carter said.
“Our relationship with media was also called into question. That relationship is vital to the work we do every day. The media supports our ability to reach communities and get important safety messages and reassurance out to them.
“We agree that some of our decisions around the documentary meant we did not serve media in the way we should have. Police has a long history of cooperating on documentaries or programmes involving ongoing investigations, and we don’t want to stop that. They offer unique and interesting insights into Police work and transparency around our work, which enables communities to have trust and confidence in their Police.
“We just need to do better in how we manage these agreements, so we ensure we are being fair to all and not putting our staff into positions where they feel uncomfortable or question the authority or integrity of what they are being asked to do. I believe the documentary crew also acted with the best intent in all their dealings with our staff. However, we should have had better processes in place for both our staff and the crew, so they could have better navigated those instances where there was uncertainty,” Carter said.
More soon.