Todd Stephenson’s End of Life Choice bill risks taking euthanasia ‘choice’ too far - Maryanne Spurdle

THE FACTS
- Act MP Todd Stephenson has prepared a members bill that would amend the country’s euthanasia laws.
- The End of Life Choice Act legalised euthanasia in certain circumstances and came into force in 2021 after the majority of voters supported it in a referendum.
- Between April and June this year, medical officials approved 164 euthanasia applications and facilitated 97 assisted deaths.
When two-thirds of Kiwis voted “yes” to euthanasia in 2020, we were promised some safeguards. They included:
- Only the terminally ill would qualify, lest we offer suicide to people who aren’t dying.
- The criteria would be strictly enforced to prevent involuntary deaths and coercion.
- No one would be encouraged to choose euthanasia without an explicit request.
- Choice would be protected: no pressure on patients, no compulsion for professionals.
Now, a member’s bill proposes to scrap each promise in the name of “choice”.
The current legislation requires a terminal prognosis of six months or less.
Todd Stephenson’s End of Life Choice Amendment Bill would extend eligibility to patients with any “advanced, progressive” condition that may lead to death.
This is already happening in Canada, where in 2023 nearly 5% of deaths were by euthanasia. There are reports that people with disabilities and chronic illnesses are opting to end their lives because they cannot access the care they need. This is not what many Canadians would have pictured when they legalised euthanasia for the terminally ill in 2016. But now that they offer suicide to end so many types of suffering, 28% of Canadians who took part in one survey would allow it for homelessness. Once euthanasia is available to those who aren’t near death, who’s to say what it may be a “solution” for?
Removing the six-month prognosis would invite New Zealanders with some of the most challenging diseases and chronic conditions to consider euthanasia. How many of them want to hear that instead of advocating for better care, we will offer them the cheapest exit? As disability advocates warned before the referendum, normalising euthanasia for segments of society tells people that their lives may not be worth living.
The Ministry of Health’s recent review claimed the current regime is “largely operating well”. To me, that’s a generous way to describe it, given the way they swiftly lost two of the original three Review Committee members because – as one former member said – if there was wrongdoing, they wouldn’t know it. They did know, however, that one patient who spoke no English, had no interpreter, and probably had dementia, was euthanised.
Rather than improve oversight, Stephenson’s bill leaves the Review Committee powerless to investigate, authorising it only to “make recommendations” and alert other authorities. Committee members already demonstrated the futility of that exercise. When they flagged information missing from death reports with the Ministry of Health, it told them to simply “assume nothing is wrong”.
We are following Canada’s playbook; Stephenson’s bill specifically references that country’s euthanasia regime. Leaked documents showed hundreds of “compliance issues” in Ontario that may violate criminal law, none of which have been referred to the police. Can someone die unlawfully if law enforcement never hears about it? Apparently not.
The 2020 Act requires patients to confirm their wishes both at application and on the day of death, but Stephenson’s bill would allow patients to waive consent on the day if their request for assisted dying is approved but they lose the capacity to make decisions in the intervening period. Perhaps our restriction on allowing people to make terminal decisions for their future selves is validated by the experience of one Dutch patient. She had dementia and a directive to die at a later date, but on the day, she resisted her lethal injection. The physician had family members hold her down to finish the job. Does this look like “free choice”?
The bill would also remove the prohibition on doctors offering euthanasia to patients who have not requested it. The rationale is that patients have a “consumer right” to know their options – as if anyone competent to consent doesn’t also know that euthanasia has been legal for years.
Numerous stories from Canada and the Netherlands demonstrate the psychological harm that results when vulnerable people have a trusted authority offer to end their lives.
And disturbingly, Stephenson’s bill would require every care facility to allow access to euthanasia. Today, patients who prefer euthanasia-free spaces have that choice, and staff who prefer to work in places where no patient is killed have that option too. If this bill passes, those choices vanish.
Euthanasia is universally available, with the fastest time from application to death just two days. Palliative care isn’t. If we truly value end-of-life choice, why aren’t we fully funding hospices? A MartinJenkins report found that they return $1.59 in services for every dollar of funding – in other words, the only thing more economical than fully funding hospices is to deny some people access to them.
Stephenson’s bill was inspired by Canada’s laws.
How is Canada doing? In 2027, they plan to add people with mental illness to their ever-growing list of citizens who, if they desire suicide, will have the Government’s help getting it.
These are not the “choices” New Zealanders voted for. As the slippery slope confronts us, we need to make a call: do we want our society to be more utilitarian, or more compassionate?
Sign up to Herald Premium Editor’s Picks, delivered straight to your inbox every Friday. Editor-in-Chief Murray Kirkness picks the week’s best features, interviews and investigations. Sign up for Herald Premium here.