Opinion

The truth Luxon let slip during the leaders’ debate – Heather du Plessis-Allan

Heather du Plessis-Allan is the drive host for Newstalk ZB and a columnist for the Herald on Sunday.
Christopher Luxon on the 1News Leaders Debate on TVNZ on Tuesday. Photo / Harley Peters
NZ Herald Morning Headlines | Sunday, October 11, 2026. Trump has called for Ukrainian President Zelenskyy to be replaced. Video / NZ Herald

Christopher Luxon gave away the truth in that TVNZ leaders’ debate on Tuesday.

If he wakes up on November 8 needing the Opportunity Party for the numbers to form a government, he will absolutely be calling Qiulae Wong.

When he was pressed on Tuesday about the possibility of that phone call, he wouldn’t rule it out. He would only repeat what he considered to be historical facts. National has ruled out Opportunity. He has been crystal clear. He’s laid it out from the very beginning of the year.

But not once did he say no, he would not be picking up the phone.

That was deliberate.

Because the truth is he might need to call Q. Things have changed since the beginning of the year. On the averages of current polling, Opportunity will be in Parliament.

Luxon’s voters would not hold that against him. They would accept Opportunity and their five milquetoast bottom lines as a small price to pay for preventing a Labour-led government.

And frankly, it might be what Opportunity actually wants.

That may seem a strange contention, given how clearly left-wing Opportunity’s personnel and policies are, but hear me out.

If there’s one thing we should already have clocked about Opportunity, it is that this isn’t a party of principle. It is a party of PR.

A party of principle would never have announced two radically left ideas like a land tax and basic welfare payments for every citizen, and then nuke those policies within 98 days.

A party of PR would, though. They would have no problem rolling out two wild policies to grab attention and drive the polls up by winning over largely disgruntled left-wing voters, only to then put those two policies on ice once they’d served their purpose and lifted the party to 8% in the polls.

A party of PR would then see no problem with replacing those two radical policies with five vanilla pledges that no one could really object to. Who doesn’t want to clean up politics? Who would argue against a long-term commitment to funding hospitals?

Labour leader Chris Hipkins and National leader Prime Minister Christopher Luxon face off at the 1News Leaders Debate. Photo / Harley Peters
Labour leader Chris Hipkins and National leader Prime Minister Christopher Luxon face off at the 1News Leaders Debate. Photo / Harley Peters

A party of principle would likely be started by a leader or a cluster of potential leaders rallying around a unifying idea.

A party of PR would hire a leader through a Seek job ad.

A party of principle would choose to form a government with parties that largely share the same values. Which would be the left bloc. Because they share the values of higher tax and greater welfare payments. Opportunity’s general manager is a former Labour MP. Its fourth-ranked candidate is one of the authors of the He Puapua co-governance blueprint.

But a party of PR would do the opposite. It would choose National if it had the choice. Because of the end goal.

Opportunity’s stated aim is to replace Winston Peters as the kingmaker. It will, though, never be the kingmaker if, at the first chance it gets, it does exactly what everyone expects it to do and goes left.

It can only become a genuine kingmaker if it demonstrates it really can go right as well.

Plus, there’s the added advantage of the right providing continuity of government over disruption, which brings its own electoral rewards.

Opportunity is practically gagging for Luxon to call on November 8 if it gets in.

For him, that phone call will have a price. His voters won’t punish the party if he breaks his pledge because it’s the only way back for National. But they will probably think less of him. It will be yet another public demonstration that he is not quite the smooth political operator he might have hoped to be.

And judging by his answers on Tuesday, he’s already preparing for that eventuality.

Catch up on the debates that dominated the week by signing up to our Opinion newsletter – a weekly round-up of our best commentary.