Sadie-Leigh Gardner inquest: Acquitted Adrian Clancy says he got police timeline wrong

The man acquitted of murdering toddler Sadie-Leigh Gardner says he was on “Cloud 9”, $12,000 ahead on sports bets and glued to his phone on the day she suffered the injuries that would prove fatal.
Giving evidence for the first time, Adrian Clancy has told an inquest into her death that he got parts of his police statement wrong because he was under “a lot of pressure”.
“I was under a lot of pressure,” Clancy said today about his statement. “... I was just trying to help.”
Sadie-Leigh died in 2019 from what pathologist Dr Kilak Kesha described as blunt force head injuries.
Her death was the subject of two earlier jury trials after Clancy, the then-partner of Sadie-Leigh’s mother, was charged with murder.
He was found guilty at the first trial in 2021, but the Court of Appeal quashed that conviction and he underwent a retrial.
Clancy was acquitted at the second trial in 2024. He did not take the stand at either trial.
Today, at the inquest into how Sadie-Leigh sustained her fatal injuries, Clancy told his story for the first time.
Yesterday, the inquest in Tauranga heard from Sadie-Leigh’s mother, who has name suppression.
She told the inquest that on the afternoon of March 27, 2019, Sadie-Leigh was sick with a cold and grizzly, and Clancy put the child to bed.
Then, after hearing the child coughing, she gave her some medicine, left, then poked her head back in to check on her again before leaving for an appointment around 3.30pm.
Today, Clancy described that day as beginning with him going to the gym before heading back to their Tauranga unit to bet on sports.
Gambling on live sports was a constant, and at times lucrative, hobby of Clancy’s, who said he was “up” $12,000 on the day.
“I was on Cloud 9.”
He said when Sadie-Leigh and her mother got home, he put the toddler to bed and brought her wipes when she spat out her medicine, before going back to his bets.
When betting on live sports, he explained to the inquest, the odds are constantly changing, so he would be “glued” to his phone trying to figure out his next step.
“You’re just not even aware of anything else.”
He told police hours after Sadie-Leigh was taken to hospital that after the mother left he heard the toddler have another coughing fit.
However, at the inquest, he said that information was wrong and that, looking back at the evidence heard at both trials, he now believed the fit had happened earlier, before the mother left.
The inquest heard from their neighbour, Shantelle Flynn, earlier in the week that she was outside on her deck and would have heard Sadie-Leigh having the alleged coughing fit.
She said she didn’t hear Sadie-Leigh cough in the moments before Clancy brought the unresponsive toddler to her doorstep.
Clancy’s recollection now was that after placing his last bet of the day, at 3.46pm, he thought Sadie-Leigh had been quiet for a while and went to check on her.
He said he found her with her eyes rolled back and barely breathing. She was rushed to hospital.
The mother’s lawyer, Ben Smith, read Clancy’s statement from that day.
“About 10 minutes after [the mother] left Sadie had a coughing fit that lasted for about 10 seconds it was silent after that. After it had been silent for five minutes I went to check on Sadie. She looked as if she was having trouble breathing,” the statement said.
Clancy said he had got the timeline “wrong” because he was under “a lot of pressure”, trying to answer every question and was mostly worried about Sadie-Leigh in hospital.
Smith pointed out what Clancy said was inconsistent with what he was saying now.
“I’m gonna suggest to you that after [the mother] left, you went into Sadie’s room and assaulted her?” Smith said.
“No, I don’t think so. I would never assault a child, never,” Clancy replied.
Smith also questioned why Clancy had told police that day that Sadie-Leigh’s bedroom door had been shut when today he said it was only half shut.
“Hard to keep your story straight?” Smith asked Clancy.
“No,” he replied.

Smith asked Clancy if he had heard any “banging or crashing” while Sadie-Leigh and her mother were in the room together, and the man said no.
But he said he wouldn’t have seen or heard a bus crash through their living room while he was betting.
Richard Jenson, for New Zealand Police, referred to evidence given by one of Clancy’s ex-partners at the second murder trial.
He referred to the former partner’s evidence that Clancy used gambling as a way to deal with stress.
Clancy replied that he had always gambled, saying it was in his nature and not a form of stress relief.
“Not a problem?” Jenson asked.
“It’s not an issue,” Clancy replied.
Jenson suggested that Clancy claimed he was on “Cloud 9” that day to “distract” the inquest from the fact that he was grumpy and Sadie-Leigh and her mother had “derailed” his important day of gambling.
“Absolutely not,” Clancy replied. “... I was not grumpy ... I was happy ... I always looked after Sadie ... as long as they’re safe, everything’s okay.”
Jenson suggested Sadie-Leigh had interrupted Clancy at an important moment, his “calm facade” had “boiled over,” and he had seriously assaulted her.
“No,” Clancy again replied.
‘Big horrible words’
Yesterday, Clancy’s lawyer, Rob Stevens, asked Sadie-Leigh’s mother about three different neighbours who told police after Sadie-Leigh’s death that they had heard her verbally abusing the toddler.
The mother denied it.
Today, Clancy told the inquest the mother would lose her temper when putting Sadie-Leigh to bed, so it became his job because he was good at getting her to settle.
Before he detailed some of the “big horrible words” the mother would say to the child, he began to cry.
“[She] would say things like ... ‘I wish I could get rid of you’, ‘I wish you weren’t here’, ‘you little b****’, ‘I wish you’d go live with your dad, your father’,” Clancy claimed.
He also said that the mother would grab Sadie-Leigh by the arm and drag her back to bed when she wouldn’t go.
Yesterday, the mother said she had only dragged her daughter by the arm once, when pulling her away from oncoming traffic.
The oral evidence portion of the inquest into how Sadie-Leigh came to die concluded with Clancy’s evidence this afternoon.
Coroner Tracey Fitzgibbon took a moment to acknowledge Sadie-Leigh and noted that the purpose of her inquiry was very different from that of a criminal court.
She adjourned with a karakia.
Ella Scott-Fleming has been a journalist for three years and previously worked at the Otago Daily Times, Gore Ensign and Metro Magazine. She has an interest in court and general reporting. She’s currently based in Auckland covering justice-related stories.
Join the NZ Herald’s Open Justice team for Case by Case, a video and podcast series examining the disputes and decisions making headlines across New Zealand.
