Ombudsman rules against PM Christopher Luxon in climate lobbying document blunder

Prime Minister Christopher Luxon says the report was very fair. Photo / Cameron Pitney
The Ombudsman recommended the Prime Minister remind ministerial staff of their obligations under the OIA. Video / Mark Mitchell

The Ombudsman has determined it was “unreasonable” for the Prime Minister’s Office not to provide a briefing note from private companies about climate legislation in response to an Official Information Act request.

The briefing note had been sent to one of Christopher Luxon’s staff on his private email.

Ombudsman John Allen is also expressing a range of concerns after his investigation, including his surprise at the now-former staff member’s assertion that it is not uncommon for government staff to use personal email addresses for work purposes due to “inadequate” IT systems.

Luxon, who has previously accepted that former staffer Matt Burgess erred in using his private email, said Allen’s report was “very fair” but pushed back against Burgess’ claim about private email use, saying he hadn’t seen “widespread evidence” of that.

The findings add another chapter to the saga, which is viewed by some critics as evidence of excessive access large companies have to the Government and how they can influence legislation.

Burgess has repeatedly declined to comment when approached by the Herald.

In mid-2024, a briefing note was prepared by Fonterra and Z Energy lobbying for a law change in relation to litigation against a range of firms over their contribution to climate pollution. In May this year, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith announced an amendment “to prevent findings of liability for tort for climate change damage or harm caused by greenhouse gas emissions in both current and future proceedings before the courts”.

The note was given as a hard copy to Burgess, described by Allen in his report as the “chief policy adviser”, in mid-2024. It was also emailed to Burgess’ personal email address.

Matt Burgess was a former policy adviser to Christopher Luxon.
Matt Burgess was a former policy adviser to Christopher Luxon.

However, the documents were not released in an Official Information Act (OIA) request made the following year. It wasn’t until May this year that the note’s existence was revealed as part of the High Court proceedings Smith v Fonterra.

The revelation led to claims from the Green Party of an “alleged cover-up.” The party also accused the Government of “pimping for corporates”. Luxon and ministers denied the claims, saying they made the legislative change for good reason.

The Ombudsman investigation, which began in late May, detailed how Burgess had been consulted during the 2024 OIA response, but did not disclose receipt of the note, nor the meetings held with Fonterra or Z Energy.

Allen said Burgess, who was interviewed for the investigation, claimed he did not recall what had happened to the hard-copy note, but said he didn’t “knowingly retain or destroy any document”. Burgess also claimed it was “not practice for notes to be taken of every meeting or interaction”.

Citing a “high-workload and high-pressure environment”, Burgess said he couldn’t recall the OIA request but claimed he “engaged with the request in good faith”.

Allen said he didn’t find evidence which contradicted Burgess’ claims but said: “I do find it surprising that that the former chief policy adviser had no recollection of what was done with the information in the briefings, given they related to a prominent issue, were provided by high-profile companies, and the wording for the suggested legislative change in the briefing note was ultimately reflected in the proposed changes to the Climate Change Response Act 2002.”

Burgess also told the investigation the Department of Internal Affairs’ information technology (IT) system challenges were “well-documented” and as such, personal emails were used at times across Government for government business to “manage these limitations”.

Luxon had previously acknowledged that using private emails for government business undermined transparency and trust. Allen said Burgess’ claim was “particularly concerning” and he would be raising it with the department.

“Receiving official information in this way significantly raises the risk of it not being identified in response to OIA requests, as was the case here.”

PM Christopher Luxon has welcomed the report's recommendations. Photo / Mark Mitchell
PM Christopher Luxon has welcomed the report's recommendations. Photo / Mark Mitchell

Allen’s report said the department was undertaking a review of Burgess’ IT account to see whether any other official information could be held in personal accounts.

Allen concluded the note should have been retained by Luxon’s office as part of its records and found its omission from the request “unreasonable”.

He recommended Luxon review whether the note be made public, remind ministerial staffers of their obligations and have his own staffers review their personal accounts to ensure official information was properly recorded.

Luxon today said he fully embraced the report and its recommendations.

“As I said at the time, [it] didn’t meet our high expectations and standards.

“That’s why we’ve made sure that every staffer is fully aware of their obligations.”

However, Luxon pushed back on several of the claims made by Burgess, saying he disagreed that note-taking was not a common practice and that private email accounts were used for government business.

“What I see ... actually is most of our staff have been compliant with their obligations.

“I expect them to be engaging with community leaders, with business leaders as they develop policy, that’s a good thing, but the responsibility and the obligation is that they need to record those meetings and maintain transparency and trust.”

Asked whether he trusted Burgess’ recollection, Luxon responded: “Well, he no longer works for us and hasn’t for some time, but the issue for me is making sure that all staffers understand their obligations.”

The Prime Minister said his office was reviewing whether the document could be released, noting it contained commercially sensitive information.

“We will work our way through that as quickly as we can.”