Treasury advice casts doubt on Greens’ wealth tax modelling

Green Party co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick, pictured with fellow Green MPs Teanau Tuiono (left) and Ricardo Mendéndez, launched the Super-Rich Tax policy. Photo / Joe Allison
NZ Herald Morning Headlines | Thursday, July 23, 2026. Lower NCEA pass rates are reportedly no concern. Health sector in need of new strategies. Video / NZ Herald

The Green Party is standing by the modelling of its Super-Rich Tax after being shown old Treasury advice that cast doubt on some of the modelling assumptions behind the figures.

The party’s Super-Rich Tax, a form of wealth tax, was modelled with help from the Parliamentary Library. The Greens’ policy document says this was “informed by Treasury advice”.

Treasury and IRD’s policy work on the last Labour Government’s ultimately unsuccessful wealth tax has been published online. That advice informed some of the Greens’ judgements around their own tax.

One of the main papers tries to model how much wealth people would shift out of the country to avoid it being taxed. Wealth taxes typically have high avoidance because wealthy people are more mobile than those less well off, and wealth taxes create a large incentive for them to shift their wealth offshore.

The paper estimated for every 1 percentage point of wealth tax, there would be a “17.5% reduction in the in-scope wealth base”.

That means that if wealth is taxed at 1%, 17.5% of the taxable wealth will go elsewhere, if it is taxed at 2%, then 35% would go elsewhere, and so on. The higher the wealth tax, the greater incentive there would be for people to shift their wealth offshore. Treasury confirmed to the Heraldthat this reading of their modelling is correct.

Treasury later told the Herald that this response would phase in over a period of three years. In the first year, only half of the behavioural response would take effect. By the third year, the full behavioural would be in play. Treasury cautioned that these figures were subject to considerable uncertainty.

The Greens have set their wealth tax rate at 2.5%. Adopting that Treasury methodology, this would suggest 43.75% of the impost’s tax base would be moved somewhere out of reach, leaving the Greens with a smaller pool of taxable income.

However, the Greens adopted a differing methodology, which came to a smaller figure. Their modelling assumes people will minimise their taxable wealth to the point that it was reduced by 28.5% – a far smaller figure than the 43.75% that would be a conventional reading of Treasury’s model.

The Greens based their modelling on advice given to Grant Robertson and David Parker during the Ardern Government. Photo / Mark Mitchell
The Greens based their modelling on advice given to Grant Robertson and David Parker during the Ardern Government. Photo / Mark Mitchell

The Greens explained their decision to the Heraldthrough a spokesperson. They pointed to a different piece of modelling from Labour’s 2023 wealth tax proposal.

“Inland Revenue and the Treasury estimated that a 2% wealth tax on net wealth above $3 million would bring in $7.0 billion of revenue in 2025/26. The implied reduction due to a behavioural impact at the 2% rate is 26%.

“Looking at behavioural impact assumptions at a 1%, 1.5% and 2% wealth tax rates, I have assumed a behavioural impact equivalent to 28.5% at a wealth tax rate of 2.5%,” the spokesperson said.

On another page of the same document, Treasury cited evidence from the UK to caution that a 1% wealth tax would have compliance costs of “around 20% of revenue collected”.

That would mean that the cost of implementing the tax would be 20c for every dollar collected, borne by both the Government and the person paying the tax.

The Greens are going to give IRD $100m a year in additional funding to help with collecting the wealth tax, about 2.5% of the revenue the party expects to raise.

The Greens’ spokesperson pushed back on the 20% figure, saying it was “inconsistent with rates estimated by other experts and is not the rate estimated as the cost to Government”.

They said that in regard to the last Government’s wealth tax proposal, IRD advised that “administration costs for IRD to implement the wealth tax would peak at $5.9m in 2024/25 and reduce to $2.2m for 2026/27 and outyears“.

“While there is quite a wide range between $5.9m and $100m, we opted to increase IRD’s funding by $100m a year to cover the administration costs of the wealth tax and our other tax changes,” the spokesperson said.

“It’s opaque how Treasury came to the 20% compliance costs figure as it is far higher than any of the compliance costs estimated for taxpayers by the UK Wealth Tax Commission,” they said.