PISA bombshell: Education data points to post-Covid stabilisation and a narrowing equity gap

The 2025 Pisa results showed New Zealand students, despite being at a lower level than in the 2000s, remained above the OECD average in reading, maths and science, and were particularly impressive at computational problem solving. Photo / 123RF
The 2025 Pisa results showed New Zealand students, despite being at a lower level than in the 2000s, remained above the OECD average in reading, maths and science, and were particularly impressive at computational problem solving. Photo / 123RF

The post-Covid collapse in education has halted amid signs of a narrowing equity gap, as disadvantaged students improved at higher rates than their richer peers.

That’s according to New Zealand’s 2025 Pisa (Programme for International Student Assessment) results, released this evening, which is a benchmark for 15-year-olds in the OECD in science, maths and reading.

This is the first education data that points to a shrinking gap between rich and poor, which could indicate a return to pre-Covid levels. The pandemic years hit the most disadvantaged the hardest, so they might be bouncing back stronger than their peers because they’d fallen further.

It’s a startling finding for an education system, as Education Minister Erica Stanford has repeatedly said, where “your means determine your destiny”. She is trying to change the strong correlation between academic achievement and socioeconomic circumstances so that everyone has the same chance to thrive.

“It’s big news,” Stanford told the Herald.

“It is the first time we’ve seen a statistically significant closing of the equity gap in as far back as we can look. It’s been a stubbornly wide gap that has got worse and stayed wide.”

New Zealand students continued to perform above the OECD average in all three subjects, ranking ninth in reading, 10th in science, and 16th in maths.

But there’s no sign of a recovery to academic levels in 2009, when results started sliding in New Zealand as well as across the OECD.

The 2025 results also had a curious finding: New Zealand students are exceptionally good at computational problem solving, scoring much higher than their maths, reading and science scores indicated they would.

This potentially bodes well as this student cohort enters a workforce in the coming years that demands increasingly higher digital literacy, although challenges remain: youth unemployment is at a three-decade high, while the number of teenagers leaving high school with no NCEA qualifications continues to rise.

New Zealand students in 2025 remained above the OECD average for science, maths and reading, although since 2009 they have slipped from being higher in the OECD rankings.  The red box indicates countries with which New Zealand has more or less the same scores. Source: Ministry of Education
New Zealand students in 2025 remained above the OECD average for science, maths and reading, although since 2009 they have slipped from being higher in the OECD rankings. The red box indicates countries with which New Zealand has more or less the same scores. Source: Ministry of Education

Smaller gap between the haves and have-nots

Pisa tests were taken by 5000 students across 133 schools last year, although there was a tendency for higher-performing students to take them.

This means the results come with a caution that they might be slightly rosier than the reality, although there was a similar bias in 2022, meaning comparisons between 2022 and 2025 are more robust.

“There is a persistent achievement gap between socioeconomically advantaged and disadvantaged students, but in 2025 this gap is smaller than in 2022, mostly due to higher achievement from disadvantaged students,” the summary report said.

This is not a trend that has emerged yet with NCEA school leaver data, nor with the pre-high school foundational assessments.

The Pisa report did not have granular detail about each subject but the Ministry of Education provided the Herald with Pisa data according to socioeconomic quartile.

In each subject, the gap between the lowest and highest quartile narrowed by a similar margin: 16 points in reading and maths, and 17 points in science. Twenty points is equivalent to a year’s worth of learning.

The main reason was higher achievement for the lowest quartile, relative to the other quartiles. The biggest jump for this quartile was in science, followed by maths and reading.

Each jump followed a sharp fall in 2022 (especially in maths), suggesting that at least some of the recovery is a return to pre-Covid levels.

Stanford dampened this possibility, saying “all kids were hit hard by Covid, through all year groups”.

She preferred to attribute the smaller gap to improved attendance, a greater focus on reading, writing and maths, and the consistency of the curriculum, professional learning and development, and classroom resources.

“This means no matter where you walk into school, you get the same world-leading education. This is going to have a greater impact for lower decile or high Equity Index schools.”

The Pisa summary report said high variation in achievement was due to difference between students within schools rather than between schools.

This means that the school a student attends makes less of a difference in New Zealand than in the average OECD country.

The report said 11% of the variation for the 2025 science scores “is explained by their socio-economic background, which is very similar to the OECD average”. This had improved from 2015, when it was 14%, and from 2006 when it was 16%.

Stabilising rather than improving

The 2025 scores in science, reading and maths were so close to those in 2022 that they are not considered statistically different.

This stabilising is positive, however, as it bucks the OECD trend of an ongoing decline in all three subjects. New Zealand students appear to have halted the post-Covid slide better than the rest of the OECD.

This is particularly encouraging as the 15-year-olds who took part in Pisa were also at school during the pandemic, so the learning loss over those years doesn’t appear to have destined them to lower academic achievement than pre-pandemic cohorts.

Another positive was the trend for the proportion of students below what’s considered baseline proficiency.

This had been growing in all three subjects and continued to edge higher in reading (23% in 2025, up from 21% in 2022).

But it fell slightly in science (from 20% in 2022 to 19% in 2025) and held steady in maths (29% in 2022 and in 2025), halting what had been a steep rise from 22% in 2018.

The proportion of students achieving at a high level also inched higher in 2025, by one percentage point in all three subjects.

The low- and high-achieving proportions are still a long way from where they were in 2009, when the cohorts above baseline proficiency as well as achieving top results were both much higher.

There was no major change in the 2025 results for gender equity, and the longer-term trends remained: girls tended to do better in reading, boys tended to do better in maths, and there wasn’t much difference between them in science.

Near top of the class for computational problem solving

Fifteen-year-olds in New Zealand were among the top-performing OECD students in computational problem solving (CPS).

“Students in Singapore were the only group to score significantly higher than New Zealand students in CPS,” the CPS report said.

“New Zealand students scored significantly higher than those in Canada, the United Kingdom, the United States and Ireland.”

A large majority (86%) of New Zealand students achieved baseline proficiency, higher than the OECD average (77%), while 36% were high achieving, “demonstrating the ability to solve complex programming and modelling tasks”.

Students sitting CPS assessments were not necessarily tested on their knowledge of content, which the new “knowledge-rich” curriculum is focusing on.

They were instead given some modelling or programming to learn, which they then had to apply during the assessment.

The results were much higher than the national scores in maths, science and reading would have predicted, indicating a high level of problem-solving ability and on-the-spot learning.

One of the criticisms of the Government’s knowledge-rich approach is that important skills such as problem solving or creative thinking might be sidelined.

The Government has countered this by saying that schools still have the ability to teach as they see fit within the new curricula.

The CPS results indicate that schools are continuing to maintain a balanced teaching approach.

Pisa results also indicated that bullying was a bigger issue in New Zealand than other OECD countries.

  • More than half of OECD students (53%) reported that they are never or almost never bullied, but in New Zealand the proportion was only 39%.
  • A quarter of New Zealand students said they were bullied as least a few times a month, higher than the OECD average of 20%.

New Zealand 15-year-olds are slightly below the OECD average in terms of feeling like they belong in school, but they are placing greater value on school and are more likely to say they are learning useful skills.

They’re also more likely to skip class than their OECD counterparts, but the pattern is trending towards less truancy.

Derek Cheng is a senior journalist who started at the Herald in 2004. He has worked several stints in the press gallery and is a former deputy political editor.