Pacific to China: Warn us next time you fire a missile our way

After months of deliberating, leaders of Pacific countries have agreed to collectively rebuke China for firing a nuclear-capable missile into the Pacific in July.
The rebuke came after a day-long closed-door meeting between leaders, including Prime Minister Christopher Luxon, at the Pacific Islands Forum (PIF) in Koror, Palau. As is tradition at the forum, leaders are left alone, without officials, to thrash out pressing issues in the region, often talking late into the evening in a bid to find compromise.
Luxon was centre-stage when the rebuke was announced, as a member of the PIF’s important “troika”. The troika is the group of three countries that help provide political leadership of the forum.
It is comprised of the current, outgoing, and incoming chairs of the forum – as New Zealand will chair the PIF next year and host the annual leaders’ meeting, it has joined the troika as incoming chair.
Leaders compromised in their rebuke of China. The text, which was included in a long list of items in a communiqué following the meeting, did not mention China by name, and noted only that leaders “register their concern” about the test, which overflew several territories without “adequate notice”. The leaders called on anyone testing a missile in future to give “at least 24 hours” notice.
Luxon said he wanted a forthright statement.
“I don’t want to see this normalised across the region. When you fire an intercontinental ballistic missile into a nuclear-free Pacific, given all the history in our, in our part of the world, with nuclear testing … that’s just not something we want to see.”
Even this compromise text did not compromise enough for some of China’s most staunch supporters in the region.
Nauru registered a rare dissent from that particular part of the communiqué, and Kiribati, another of China’s staunch supporters, was not represented at the leaders’ retreat at all.
Typically, PIF decisions are made by consensus. Topics are debated fiercely within the room, but once consensus is reached, all leaders sign on. Nauru’s dissent from this compromise text is exceedingly rare.
Luxon told New Zealand media he did not know why Kiribati was not at the meeting.
“I genuinely don’t know,” he said when pressed on the matter.
The retreat, held at the residence of Palau’s President Surangel Whipps jnr, lasted the entire day, with leaders only arriving back for the much delayed closing ceremony at around 8.30pm.
Speaking to New Zealand media at about 10.30pm, as the forum wrapped up, Luxon described the day, saying leaders spent it sitting at tables with a microphone and speakers in a bid to thrash out compromise.
“We had our chairs and little tables in front of us and little speakers and passed the microphone around amongst each other,” he said, describing the atmosphere as “relaxed” and “informal”.
NZ gears up to host - Taiwanese politicians not invited
The forum also agreed to a fairly significant shake-up of how invitations will be extended to outside partners.
Currently, there are 21 dialogue partners of the forum. These are countries like the United States and China that have an interest in the Pacific and often donate aid and participate in development.
A series of controversies, including a blow-up at last year’s meeting in the Solomon Islands, which ended up being blocked off to all partners, has caused the forum to consider splitting these partners into two tiers, strategic partners and sectoral partners.
The split was agreed today and the forum is now going to engage with the affected countries to tell them which tier of membership they have been given. A list of which countries have been placed in what tier has not been published.
Luxon supported the move, arguing it streamlined the forum, which has become crowded by partners who now outnumber full members. Luxon suggested the placing of countries in one tier or another may have something to do with the level of economic development aid each country spends.
“We have to acknowledge that as we go forward, we can’t treat them all the same or give the same sort of effort … We actually are looking for partners that genuinely can lift the living standards of our people across the Pacific,” Luxon said.

Whipps confirmed that Taiwan’s status as a “development partner”, separate to a dialogue partner, was not changed by the new tiering system.
This decision is not universally popular. There has been thought that tiering the PIF could risk offending partners who end up in the second tier and encouraging them to ignore the forum.
Much of the controversy around partners related to Taiwan. Three PIF states, including this year’s hosts, Palau, are among the just 12 countries to have diplomatic relations with Taiwan, the self-governing island China claims as its own. Its Foreign Minister, Lin Chia-lung, took advantage of friendly hosts to make a rare visit to the forum .
His presence at this year’s forum has stirred controversy.
More controversial still, he expressed an interest in sending high-level representation to next year’s meeting in New Zealand.
When asked about this on Thursday morning, Luxon did not have a firm answer, saying attendance would be determined by longstanding “protocols”.
Luxon said people from the “official level” from Taiwan would be welcome to New Zealand, and that these officials could engage with countries, including those who diplomatically recognised Taiwan, at an event on the sidelines of the forum.
In a slight clarification of his earlier remarks, Luxon confirmed ministers would not be invited. Extending an invite to ministers could be seen as provoking China.
Police and climate change
Luxon said the group had agreed to strengthen JHoPS (Joint Heads of Pacific Security), a meeting that brings together leaders from Pacific police, military, customs, and immigration agencies.
Established in 2019, the group is intended to respond to growing transnational crime and drug trafficking, which has been destabilising some Pacific states.
The leaders debated bringing the group into a more formal arrangement with the forum.
This has been controversial because JHoPS is emerging as a powerful and interconnected group of defence and security agencies, which Australia has an outsize influence over, owing to the group being housed within Australia’s Department of Defence. Critics also fret over a lack of democratic accountability over the institution.
Forum Secretary General Baron Waqa when asked about the lack of civil society input into JHoPS did not answer the question directly, preferring to say leaders “do value” their input.
The forum continued to push for ambitious climate action, with leaders agreeing for “urgent and inclusive” action “to keep 1.5 [degrees of warming] within reach”.
