Ōtorohanga Primary School Board dissolved after ministry intervention

A limited statutory manager at Ōtorohanga Primary School has become its commissioner, and the school board has been dissolved. Photo / Google Maps
A limited statutory manager at Ōtorohanga Primary School has become its commissioner, and the school board has been dissolved. Photo / Google Maps

A Waikato school is set to lose its principal of 22 years, who has resigned in the wake of the board’s dissolution and the appointment of a commissioner.

The Ministry of Education dissolved the Ōtorohanga Primary School board in September.

In August, the ministry appointed Shawn Gielen as a limited statutory manager (LSM) to the school to oversee the board’s operations and provide additional support “while the school addressed some challenges”.

In September, the ministry appointed Gielen as the school’s commissioner, and its board of five elected members was dissolved.

Catriona Chrystall, principal for more than 22 years, then announced her resignation.

Marcus Freke, the ministry’s director of education for Waikato, said it was aware of challenges at the school.

“The ministry worked with Ōtorohanga School’s board this year to provide additional support while the school addressed some challenges.”

He saidGielen was appointed as limited statutory manager,tasked with providing “specialist expertise” in employment matters, communications, policies, financial and curriculum management, and teaching and assessment.

Freke did not specify the challenges the board was working through.

In July, King Country News reported that a parent had removed her children from the school and raised concerns with Taranaki-King Country MP Barbara Kuriger.

The parent shared emails recounting alleged incidents, questioned the vetting of one teacher and the qualifications of another, and said several students had been excluded.

Ministry of Education's director of education for Waikato, Marcus Freke. Photo / Marcus Freke
Ministry of Education's director of education for Waikato, Marcus Freke. Photo / Marcus Freke

Freke told King Country News that “statutory interventions may be used when there are significant concerns or risks relating to the operation of a school, student welfare, or educational performance, and are intended to provide additional support to help a board address identified issues”.

Since being appointed commissioner, Gielen now carries out the board’s full responsibilities and works alongside the school’s leadership team.

Freke said ministry intervention was designed to help a school return to “full and effective self-management”.

Parental concerns

The Waikato Herald approached the ministry for comment on the parents’ concerns.

Freke said the ministry did not comment on concerns raised by individual members of the school community, or matters relating to identifiable staff or students.

“Some concerns about the school were brought to the ministry’s attention earlier this year.

“These concerns informed the support provided to the school.”

The Waikato Herald also approached Gielen and Chrystall, but received no response.

The Waikato Herald first contacted Ōtorohanga Primary School on November 11, but received an automated response from the principal advising that she was on leave until November 15.

Gielen responded that day with a letter he had sent to the community on October 14, outlining the update on school leadership and governance.

He confirmed his role had changed from limited statutory manager to commissioner, and said he was now carrying out the school’s “full governance responsibilities”, including appointing its next principal.

He said Chrystall would leave at the end of Term 4 and the school would work to support a smooth transition for tamariki, staff and whānau.

He would communicate with the community about what mattered most to them in the school’s next leader.

“I will also take a few different approaches to seeking your views on the wider direction for Ōtorohanga Primary School as the strategic plan for 2027 is developed.”

The Waikato Herald asked further questions the same day, including about the nature of the parents’ concerns, but received no response.

An additional email to the commissioner on November 12 also went unanswered.

On November 16, after Chrystall returned from leave, another email was sent to her and to Gielen.

The school was contacted by phone on November 18, when reception staff said a message would be passed on to the principal.

A further email was then sent to both Chrystall and Gielen.

No response was received by the Waikato Herald’s deadline earlier today.

Within Waikato, only one other school, Onewhero Area School, currently has a commissioner.

The ministry appointed a limited statutory manager at Mercury Bay Area School this month, after a highly critical review raised serious concerns about student safety and how the school was run.

In June, the ministry also appointed a limited statutory manager to Thames High School to oversee health and safety, employment, finance and policy responsibilities.

Malisha Kumar is a multimedia journalist based in Hamilton. She joined the Waikato Herald in 2023 after working for Radio 1XX in Whakatāne.