Opinion

National can only hope for a second-term Government where it’s barely the main ingredient – David Cohen

David Cohen
Opinion by
David Cohen is a Wellington-based journalist and author.
Nicola Willis and Mark Mitchell at the National Party’s election night function at the Viaduct Events Centre in Auckland. Photo / Dean Purcell
Nicola Willis and Mark Mitchell at the National Party’s election night function at the Viaduct Events Centre in Auckland. Photo / Dean Purcell

It’s looking more like another National-led Government, Jim, but not as we know it.

Barring some extraordinary upheaval when the final few hundred thousand special votes are counted and the result is declared on November 27, the centre-right coalition seems to have the best chance of another three years in office.

In a nation where National Governments have always enjoyed consecutive terms ever since Sidney Holland first led them to victory in 1949, that shouldn’t be remarkable.

With 67 seats in the 130-member Parliament, Luxon’s National Party and its two coalition partners are doing about as well as New Zealand’s grand old party would lead us to expect.

The centre-left only holds a thin pathway to get it over the line, depending on special votes tilting the allocation of seats a little bit more in its favour and then obtaining the support of Opportunity. But I think it is more likely that Qiulae Wong comes to some kind of confidence-and-supply arrangement with Luxon.

And yet.

Probably another term, sure. But not more of the same, and not like any second-term National Government before it. It could even be more left-leaning in some respects than the last Labour Government.

The personalities, for one thing; no sitting government this side of Tehran has ever lost as many senior ministers in one hit.

So many of the last administration’s senior Cabinet ministers are gone. Any new centre-right government would have to do without them, on the lowest percentage of votes for a right bloc forming Government since the advent of MMP.

Luxon’s problem isn’t just finding replacements for the old hands who defined his last government. It is forging a cabinet in which Act’s libertarian values and New Zealand First’s nationalism somehow co-exist. Last time, National provided most of the main ingredients while the junior coalition partners supplied the spices. Now he would have to make the recipe work when National itself has lost some of its flavour.

Then there is Luxon himself. Whatever happens later in the month, there was already a question before this weekend’s wash about how long he wanted to stay on the slippery pole.

According to one school of thought in National circles for more than a year now, the leader would indeed shepherd the party to electoral victory but then step aside at some point going into this second term – not so much because of any internal pressure but because a part of him still yearns for a private sector life. Now there’s the added pressure of the past six weeks.

After a promising start, the campaign just gone was generally seen as less than dazzling – a “woeful” effort, one former senior National minister told your writer – especially after Luxon failed to capitalise on the potentially strong uptick enjoyed in the aftermath of the hoo-hah around gangs.

The Prime Minister’s well-known allergy to culture-war issues is also seen by some of the team as an own-goal effort, allowing the all-too culturally-conscious Act and New Zealand First to mop up votes that might otherwise have been earmarked for National.

For those already betting that Luxon might walk away of his own accord, that may give the theory a bit more bite. A campaign’s reception, of course, doesn’t tell us what’s going on in its leader’s head.

Even so, a departure is one possible reading of what Luxon may have been hinting at late Saturday night when he talked about how “negotiations and compromises are going to be required” in the coming weeks.

On the Labour side, the question is more straightforward. Chris Hipkins gave an excellent leader’s speech on the night and was quite right to wait for the final results.

But if those results confirm a second successive trouncing by Luxon, it might prove to be one of his last speeches as Labour leader. To lose one election, after all, may fairly be regarded as a tragedy; to lose two is surely great carelessness.

No Labour leader since Peter Fraser in the 1940s has become prime minister mid-term and gone on to lead the party to victory at a subsequent general election. Nor has any leader stayed on to contest a third election.

Other leaders may be weighing up their future options too.

Act, the Greens and New Zealand First all exceeded expectations. TPM’s strategy, though, seems to have prompted a similar play on the centre-right. National ended up with an even greater overhang, which now looks to be securing the government’s return.

Green co-leader Chloe Swarbrick’s tentative admission earlier in the evening that “it looks like the left has lost it” might just as well have been applied to the silly game of over-hangman.

Or maybe not. Kiwis won’t know for sure until November 27. Former Labour leader David Cunliffe put it well when he talked about voters now awaiting “a result that may turn on rules most of them have never heard of”. Heaven help the winner.

David Cohen is a Wellington-based journalist and author.

Catch up on the debates that dominated the week by signing up to our Opinion newsletter – a weekly round-up of our best commentary.