Napier flood risk: 56% of properties in elevated-risk categories, Cotality data suggests

A young man carrying possessions out of his Te Awa property after Cyclone Gabrielle hit Napier in February 2023. Photo / Paul Taylor
A young man carrying possessions out of his Te Awa property after Cyclone Gabrielle hit Napier in February 2023. Photo / Paul Taylor

New data claims more than half of Napier and Wairoa’s homes are built in elevated flood-risk areas, among the highest shares anywhere in New Zealand.

But an economist for a firm that commissioned the report says the numbers should be used for awareness, rather than being something to fear.

Property analysis firm Cotality released data on Wednesday showing Napier and Wairoa had the highest share of properties in elevated flood-risk categories nationally.

The data, which used an established national flood model used by major insurers and financial institutions, created a relative flood-risk score for properties across the country.

Wairoa recorded the highest share of properties in elevated flood-risk categories nationally, at 66%, while Napier was third at 56%.

Buller was second on 61%, Gore fourth with 50% and Westland fifth with 43%.

Napier as a city has the second-largest community of higher-risk properties nationally, with about 13,900 homes, behind Christchurch with about 24,000 and ahead of Auckland City with about 11,300.

Cotality chief property economist Kelvin Davidson. Photo / Peter Meecham
Cotality chief property economist Kelvin Davidson. Photo / Peter Meecham

Cotality chief property economist Kelvin Davidson said the numbers related to “relative risk”.

“We’re not saying in the next year there’s a 90% chance there’ll be a big flood and you’ll lose your home.”

The figures come from Cotality’s partnership with global consulting and engineering company Haskoning, which analysed flood risk across New Zealand relating to three types of threat (fluvial or river, pluvial or surface/flash and coastal) and multiple return periods, such as a one in 10 year event, one in 50 and so on.

Davidson said those figures showed relatively high risk in areas like Hawke’s Bay and the West Coast of the South Island compared to other parts of the country.

“But we’re also saying other parts of the country aren’t zero risk ... nowhere is safe.”

He said the numbers shouldn’t put property owners into panic stations, but should build awareness.

“If you live in those areas, you might just want to pay more attention to any flood information you can get your hands on.”

A motorcyclist rides through floodwaters in Taradale, Napier, during the height of the Cyclone Gabrielle floods in February 2023. Photo / Paul Taylor
A motorcyclist rides through floodwaters in Taradale, Napier, during the height of the Cyclone Gabrielle floods in February 2023. Photo / Paul Taylor

He encouraged property owners across Hawke’s Bay, and those looking to buy property, to source flood maps for their areas on Hawke’s Bay Regional Council’s website.

“If you’re a homeowner, there’s probably not a huge amount people can do, and lenders and insurers and everything are already looking into this ... people in riskier areas or with riskier properties may already be seeing, you know, insurance premiums, for example, go up.

“But for potential buyers, it’s about going to these flood maps, looking at what the risks are, thinking about what the insurance premiums are.”

He said he did not expect the figures to immediately affect house prices in affected areas, saying prices may not fall but he felt affected properties’ prices may grow slower.

Locals ride through floodwaters during Cyclone Gabrielle near Venables Ave, Napier. Photo / Paul Taylor
Locals ride through floodwaters during Cyclone Gabrielle near Venables Ave, Napier. Photo / Paul Taylor

Napier Mayor Richard McGrath said his city was vulnerable to flooding because much of it was flat with low-lying areas of reclaimed land.

McGrath said the city had an extensive stormwater network with pumped systems and many roads and waterways were designed to mitigate the effects of flooding.

He said completed and under-way projects to help protect the city included the Taradale Rd and Herrick St culvert upgrades, the Maraenui to Te Awa Stormwater Improvement project, the Lagoon Farm Stormwater Project, the Cowshed Drain Culvert Upgrade beneath Eriksen Rd, upgrades to Clive and Memorial Squares and replacing the Purimu Pump Station roof.

Jack Riddell is a multimedia journalist with Hawke’s Bay Today and has worked in radio and media in the UK, Germany and New Zealand.