
The Ministry for Primary Industries will be required to remediate environmental damage at an East Coast forestry site under an Environment Court enforcement order, raising questions about the accountability of a government agency overseeing the forestry sector.
This month, Gisborne District Council served an enforcement order against MPI and other parties requiring remediation of woody debris and soil at Tokararangi Forest.
MPI was responsible for the commercial harvest of the 1130-hectare forest near Te Araroa on land owned by theMāori Trustee.
The council first raised concerns about forestry debris and soil entering streams at the site in 2017.
It issued an abatement notice to MPI, which immediately requested that the notice be cancelled, claiming the land use consent allowed the discharge of contaminants.
A council manager responded with a letter outlining the discharge, its relationship to consent conditions and the importance of complying with those conditions in a high-risk environment such as Tokararangi Forest.
A site inspection after bad weather in 2024 revealed a log jam at a recent harvesting site for which MPI received another abatement notice.
After MPI requested the notice be cancelled or amended, the council agreed to extend the deadlines for the required work.
After more bad weather in January this year, an aerial inspection found significant damage across the forest, including major collapses on hillsides and roads, and large amounts of woody debris that posed a risk of entering waterways during future rain.
In February, the council asked MPI and its forestry contractor, Ngāti Porou Forests Ltd (NPFL), to provide a plan for removing and disposing of the woody debris.
MPI outlined issues caused by the storm but did not provide a plan, prompting another council letter requiring remedial work.
In June, the council applied to the Environment Court for an enforcement order, which was granted this month.
According to court documents, although the respondents did not accept all matters raised in the council’s applications and affidavits, all parties acknowledged the risks at the forest and the importance of managing them.
Under the order, MPI, NPFL and the Māori Trustee must prevent woody debris from being discharged beyond the forest boundary, entering waterways or reaching locations where it could enter water.
An independent expert must assess entry risk locations, recommend removal options and consider suitable locations for slash catchers.
The expert must also assess whether some parts of the forest are unsuitable for future planting, with a management plan outlining those decisions due by June 30.
A risk assessment report and map identifying at-risk locations were also required this month.
Any additional risks identified during remediation must be incorporated into the risk assessment.
The order required progress reports on remediation work, including work at very high, high and significant risk locations by December 31 and March 1.
All reports and remediation work were to be completed by next July.
Ongoing monitoring of all streams in the forest is required, with further debris removal where necessary.
Inspections to check for debris and ensure water controls remain effective are to take place every six months from December 1, 2026, until December 1, 2030.
Any future forestry harvesting must be notified in writing to the council and local environmental group Mana Taiao Tairāwhiti (MTT) at least four months beforehand.
A risk management plan covering lawful harvesting and discharge management was also required.
General manager Crown Forestry at Te Uru Rākau – New Zealand Forest Service, Paul Burridge, said Crown Forestry was separate from the organisation’s policy and regulatory functions.
Te Uru Rākau, a unit within MPI, was responsible for forestry policy and regulatory functions, while Crown Forestry managed the Government’s commercial forestry interests.
The Environment Court process had resulted in an agreed programme of work that would build on the “significant work” already completed to reduce environmental risks, Burridge said.
“Our focus, in partnership with the other respondents, is now on delivering that work programme safely under council oversight, supported by independent expertise, monitoring and public reporting.”
At Tokararangi, delivering improvements through remediation, enhanced environmental controls, collaboration with the other parties and following expert advice would demonstrate responsible stewardship, he said.
“Responsible stewardship means recognising that we are entrusted with the management of the forest for a point in time, and have a responsibility to reduce environmental risk, build resilience, protect natural resources, and pass on a forest that is well-positioned to provide long-term benefits for future generations.”
Crown Forestry also manages Mangaoporo Forest, Waipiro A4B Forest and Waipiro A5 Forest in Tairāwhiti.
“Management approaches are tailored to each forest’s environmental characteristics and risk profile. Mangaoporo, Waipiro A4B and Waipiro A5 are semi-mature so the focus is on tending, maintenance and protection,” Burridge said.
A council spokesperson said there was no further comment on the outcome of the order.
Asked how the case might affect wider forestry discussions, the spokesperson said the council would continue to maintain its relationship with MPI to progress future transition work and support landowners.
MTT spokesperson Manu Caddie said the order raised questions about the environmental standards and accountability expected of government agencies.
MPI was responsible for national forestry policy and had a role in setting environmental standards for the industry, he said.
“Yet the ministry itself holds the forestry rights and harvesting consents at Tokararangi Forest, where Gisborne District Council has been trying to secure compliance for nearly a decade.
“Environmental laws must apply equally to everyone, including the Crown.”
A ministry should be setting an example for responsible forestry management, he said.
“Taxpayers are entitled to expect much better.”
MTT welcomed the enforcement order, but Caddie said it left unanswered questions about “why the risks were allowed to persist, why earlier enforcement measures were resisted and how much taxpayer money has been spent on legal proceedings fighting the local regulator”.
After an independent review that found the council’s regulatory approach was sound for the high-risk environment, Caddie said the Government needed to “be examining its own conduct rather than continuing to blame the local regulator”.
LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
