Letters to the Editor

Letters to the Editor: Something to be learned from handwritten approach to exams

Letters
NZ Herald
Jared Novelly is the US Ambassador to New Zealand. Photo / Jamie Ensor
Jared Novelly is the US Ambassador to New Zealand. Photo / Jamie Ensor

Top marks for handwritten approach

I was appalled at the digital platform failure during NZQA exams and aware that many students would not have been able to adjust quickly to a change and would have been severely disadvantaged.

Our grandson has just sent a screenshot of his final exam results. Of course, we were really proud of his scores but better still was the comment beside each grade – handwritten under supervision.

No chances were taken with electronic malfunctions or AI interference. This is at the University of Oxford, UK. No wonder it is the top university in the world. Something to be learned here.

Linley Jones, Half Moon Bay.

Say what?

Excuse me, but did the Trump-selected American Ambassador Jared Novelly just have a crack at Auckland’s mayor on the values of democracy? An American Republican lecturing us?

That has to be the comedy quote of the year.

Geoff Leckie, Flatbush.

Problems with MMP

Thirty years on, the architects of MMP will be, or should be, dismayed at the way the voting system has morphed into a system vulnerable to exploitation and gaming.

Two red flags that stand out are the current MP overhang of 11 and the likelihood that the formation of the next coalition Government is at the mercy of seven Opportunity list MPs who have zero parliamentary political experience.

Alarm bells are ringing and election 2026 should be the watershed event that precipitates a thorough review of MMP.

Proportional representation is to be applauded but complacency when it comes to critiquing the current flawed system is unacceptable, as it is fundamental to our ongoing democracy.

Bruce Eliott, St Heliers.

Gaming the system

Academics have raised their concerns about the election result being gamed through use of tactical voting, possibly leaving the political party with the most party votes (Labour by 0.02%) out of government.

Where were their voices when in 2017 the political party with by far the most votes in both party and electoral results (National) was left out of government by the system?

Larry Tompkins, Waiuku.

It’s in the mix

Since the election, there has been a lot of whining by academics that the final result will not be proportional. However, the first two words of MMP are mixed member. This allows a voter to support an excellent local member with their electorate vote and a different party with their party vote. This flexibility of MMP should be maintained, particularly as proportionality only counts those with 5% of the actual vote or an electorate seat.

Graham Power, Mt Roskill.

What about 2017?

In 2017, where were all these hand-wringing experts and academics concerned for the state of democracy when NZ First went into coalition with the major party with the lesser share of the overall vote?

Mike Wagg, Freemans Bay.

Making it count

Why not stick to the elected MPs only for ministerial posts?

Ray Green, Birkenhead.

China’s rise

Wayne Brown’s article in the Herald (Nov 16) was interesting and important.

He lays out the reality that China’s development achievement is very impressive and vital for underpinning New Zealand’s economy.

The Harvard Business Review, the respected American business magazine in a message in 2021 to its readers, mostly Americans, said companies should “send your best people to China not to teach them but to learn from them”.

And yet the attitude of much of America has been “how can we hold them back”. This is a very negative and retrograde attitude in line with the “America First” slogan of the Trump administration.

Australia and New Zealand are two of the world’s countries that benefit the most from China’s rise, demonstrated by significant trade surpluses, whereas most other countries are looking at trade deficits.

It is imperative that the New Zealand Government recognises this and avoids negative US propaganda on China’s economy.

Anyone who has not seen that the US has become increasingly inward-focused and self-serving needs to wake up and think again. It is not in God’s plan that America dominate and police the rest of the world, running ill-conceived wars, one after another.

Well said and well done, Wayne Brown.

Frank Olsson, Freemans Bay.

Britain’s new ambassadors?

Reading all the news and watching TV it would appear that Britain has two new ambassadors and Harry and Megan are back in the fold.

How are Harry and Megan allowed to travel around the world and make political statements as if they were fully accredited British ambassadors?

They seem to be hell-bent on staying in the limelight and next they will be complaining that the media won’t leave them alone and will ask for some privacy.

Jock Mac Vicar, Hauraki.