Labour is hugging National on policy. It’s a smart, ruthlessly centrist strategy – Andrew Ketels

At a time when you might expect parties to be explaining to voters what makes them unique, Labour has been doing an awful lot of agreeing with National. What’s going on?
In short, National doesn’t want the election to be about its record — it’s trying to frame the choice for voters as between two starkly different futures under left and right governments.
Last week, Labour deprived National of two opportunities to paint that picture by “hugging” them.
National launched two populist initiatives and Labour determined that being on the other side of each debate was likely to be a vote loser.
It has agreed with National’s social media ban for under-16s. Given National was reliant on its votes to pass, Labour had the opportunity to demand changes, but it didn’t.
Presumably, it didn’t want to be accused by anxious parents of holding the bill hostage. The ban is popular. Although, when pollsters ask voters, “do you think it will work?”, even some of the ban’s supporters don’t believe it will.
On the coalition’s 4% rates cap, Labour gave its approval, deciding it would rather be offside with councils than ratepayers.
It has also pre-empted National’s attacks — scraping barnacles off the boat, as political consultant Lynton Crosby once put it — by committing to no fuel tax increases over three years. It’s ruled out a streaming tax, a ute tax, a land value tax and a wealth tax.
While there’s a big difference between spending the 30% of GDP that is forecast under the coalition, and the 33% of GDP Chris Hipkins wants to spend, Labour has committed to similar surplus and debt targets as National, depriving the Government parties of another attack line.
Tactically, all of this is smart.
National has recently ramped up its attacks against Labour, particularly on the issue of tax. While the immediate reason for this was presumably to distract from the failed coup, the broader driver is that National feels it doesn’t have a strong record to run on, particularly given the state of the economy and cost of living.
Instead, National wants to frame the election as a black and white choice between red and blue governments and drive Labour’s vote down. But to achieve this, National and Labour need to hold different positions. On a range of issues, Labour isn’t allowing that.
Leader Chris Hipkins has decided that this isn’t a time for principle. Given the proximity of the election, the tightness of the race, and the grumpiness of the electorate, why would it engage in such abstract debates?
Besides, on many of these issues, with the exception of the social media ban, Labour isn’t able to change the outcome.
The relative centrists are clearly running the show inside Labour and Hipkins is ruthlessly charting a course back to government.
You can argue that Hipkins has been underwhelming. His personal polling shows that. But he has kept his caucus unified and he appears to have kept policymaking away from the more progressive left of his party.
Some Labour voters will be drifting to the Opportunity Party and the Greens. But the voters Labour needs are the centrist voters who swing between the two major parties each election.
And some of them will still be wary about Labour’s last stint in Government. Hipkins can’t afford to scare them.
Perhaps that’s why we heard Labour MP Willie Jackson in an interview over the weekend refusing to commit to reintroducing the controversial Māori Health Authority. Jackson even went so far as to say he was personally not in favour of doing so.
If Labour continues with this strategy and wins, there are a couple of likely upshots.
We’re going to have more policy continuity between governments of different colours.
Labour has been at pains to point out, for example, that it won’t cancel major infrastructure projects already contracted or funded for delivery. Whether that is a good approach in other policy areas is an open question.
If Labour is painting a smaller target on its back, it’s painting a larger one on the backs of its future partners. Less talk about Labour’s plans will mean more talk about where the Greens, Opportunity and Te Pāti Māori differ from the right.
Although they know the craziest ideas won’t even make it to the starting line of post-election negotiations, Luxon and National will be poring over the statements of Chloe Swarbrick, Rawiri Waititi, and Qiulae Wong and taking full advantage.
Under MMP, major party leaders are asked by journalists whether the views of their minor party partners are likely to become government policy.
The contest of ideas is increasingly a sport played by the smaller parties.
And so as much as he tries to avoid it, over the next nine weeks, Hipkins will be dragged into the conversation to rule out various ideological outbursts from the Greens, Opportunity and Te Pāti Māori.
Andrew Ketels was the Act Party’s chief of staff from 2020 to 2025 and has worked as an adviser to the National Party. He is currently head of government relations for corporate affairs firm Sherson Willis.
Catch up on the debates that dominated the week by signing up to our Opinion newsletter – a weekly round-up of our best commentary.