I’m Jewish, and a hate speech law would empower Brian Tamaki, not stop him – Dane Giraud

THE FACTS
- Hindu leaders are calling on police to take action against Destiny Church leader Brian Tamaki after he made inflammatory remarks, calling to “purge” communities of Muslim, Sikh and Hindu faiths from New Zealand and burn down their places of worship.
- Ethnic Communities Minister Mark Mitchell has labelled Destiny Church leader Brian Tamaki’s latest social media comments the “actions of a scared bully”.
- In December, a Sikh parade in South Auckland was disrupted by protesters linked to Tamaki and Destiny Church.
The statement issued this week by New Zealand’s Muslim, Hindu, Sikh and Buddhist leaders condemning Brian Tamaki deserves to be read with sympathy.
It comes from communities that have lived with bomb threats, intimidation and attacks on their places of worship, and whose children are now frightened to attend services.
Tamaki’s rhetoric about purging New Zealand and burning mosques and temples was grotesque, and he may yet have an incitement case to answer. But the letter ultimately calls for our hate speech laws to be strengthened, which will quickly lose the public’s sympathy.
There is a painful irony at the heart of the censorship debate: free speech is the greatest friend minorities have ever had, but it rarely feels that way when you are the minority under attack.
When someone is denouncing your community, your religion or your family, freedom of expression does not feel like a constitutional safeguard. It feels like the wider society has abandoned you to the wolves: the loudest, most offensive and most dangerous voices. Every instinct tells you that decent people should agree to prevent this. That the right amount of silence would bring harmony.
As a Jew, I recognise that impulse, because I gave in to it. In the days after October 7, I saw someone celebrate the Hamas-led massacre and I tagged their employer, wanting them to face a consequence for what they had said. Within a day I realised I was wrong, and publicly apologised.
Jewish communities across the Western world have seen an alarming rise in intimidation, vandalism and violence and Christchurch was only seven years ago. Every New Zealand minority understood that it meant more than an attack on Muslims alone. Fear and sorrow carry a persuasive logic: they tell us that if governments had a little more power to silence hatred, we might all be safer.
History, however, tells a different story.
We minorities have generally prospered where speech is protected, not because free expression is always pleasant, but because it denies majorities the power to decide which ideas may be expressed and which communities may speak.
Once governments acquire broad authority over opinion, the groups they eventually regulate are determined not by principle but by politics. Governments change, political orthodoxies evolve and words such as “hostility”, “hatred” and “harm” expand beyond the narrow circumstances for which they were first enacted.
Every minority believes it will remain inside the circle of legal protection, while only its enemies fall outside it. History suggests otherwise. This proposal begins with a coalition of minority faiths asking the state to prosecute another minority faith, one made up predominantly of tangata whenua, and some of the most marginalised Māori at that.
Whatever you think of Tamaki, that should give every religious community pause before handing the state more power over religious expression. The honest question for every signatory: under a future government, with the definitions stretched and the politics reversed, are you sure it is only your opponents who would be charged?
There is a distinction here that matters, too. New Zealand already criminalises genuine threats, intimidation and inciting others to break the law. If Tamaki’s remarks crossed those thresholds, the police should investigate and prosecute if the evidence warrants it.
Extending hate speech laws is something altogether different. It shifts the law away from preventing violence and towards policing hostility and contempt, concepts that inevitably broaden as attitudes change, or are applied selectively depending on which group a government treats as a voting bloc worth protecting.
Ironically, the statement itself demonstrates why free speech remains the stronger remedy. The faith leaders have organised, spoken publicly and he has now been condemned by a Government minister, the Race Relations Commissioner and the overwhelming weight of public opinion.

That is not free speech failing minorities. It is free speech enabling minorities to answer hatred with unity and to build solidarity. This is much more meaningful than legal censorship.
We are told a stronger law would bring us into line with Britain, Canada and Australia, as if falling behind the Anglosphere were the danger. Look at what being in line now means.
In a single year, British police made more than 12,000 arrests under the Communications Act 2003 and the Malicious Communications Act 1988. These acts are only designed to lead to prosecution for serious crimes, such as a credible threat of violence or breaches of a court order designed to protect someone.
But they have required the clarification of the UK Crown Prosecution Service that online posts that are merely grossly offensive, indecent, obscene or false must face a tougher test before individuals are charged. The need for clarification around these Acts themselves is concerning.
The question is not whether we are behind Britain. It is whether we want to become it. The question is not whether we are behind Britain. It is whether we want to become it.
I understand why frightened communities ask for stronger speech laws. Only someone who has never belonged to a vulnerable minority could fail to understand that temptation. Yet, precisely because I am Jewish, I cannot believe the safest future for any minority lies in giving future governments more authority to decide which opinions may lawfully be expressed.
History has taught my own community to be wary of this devil’s bargain, however well-intentioned it appears when first offered. Trust that free speech is your only true friend, even if it sometimes behaves like a noisy neighbour.
Dane Giraud is a New Zealand-based screenwriter and council member of the Free Speech Union.
Catch up on the debates that dominated the week by signing up to our Opinion newsletter – a weekly round-up of our best commentary.