Opinion

I see first-hand what damage social media is doing to our kids - Dr Maneesh Deva

Opinion by
Dr Maneesh Deva
Dr Maneesh Deva is a paediatrician at Health NZ, Waitematā. He is a member of the Paediatric Society of New Zealand, the medical adviser for KidsHealth.org.nz and an expert adviser for B416.
Should Aotearoa follow Australia’s lead on youth social media access? Photo / Getty images
Should Aotearoa follow Australia’s lead on youth social media access? Photo / Getty images

THE FACTS

  • Paediatrician Maneesh Deva warns of social media’s harmful effects on children, including anxiety and depression.
  • A proposed Bill in New Zealand aims to prohibit under-16s from having social media accounts, mirroring Australian laws.
  • Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese banned children under the age of 16 from social media, saying the pervasive influence of platforms like Facebook and TikTok is “doing real harm to our kids”.

As a paediatrician working in Waitematā, I have seen first-hand the growing damage that early, unrestricted, round-the-clock social media use is inflicting on our tamariki and rangatahi. Over the last decade, I’ve seen more and more children suffering from anxiety, depression, disordered eating, self-harm – and these are not “just teenage problems”.

As doctors we have not been taught about navigating harm from the online world at medical school. We have to go from what we’ve professionally been trained to do and then just take a step to address what we are actually seeing.

These new harms are symptoms of a digital environment our brains weren’t built for. What I hear from my young patients, and what the growing body of research confirms, is that social media is a central driver of this harm.

I do not raise this claim lightly. What worries me most is not just psychological harm, though that is pervasive – but also physical health consequences. Sleep deprivation is common among adolescents I see: notifications ping deep into the night, feeds scroll endlessly, and the pressure to keep up with peers never stops. Many fall into unhealthy relationships with food and exercise, comparing their bodies to unrealistic, algorithmically-curated ideals. If something doesn’t grab their attention in a few seconds, they dismiss it or block it and how does that work in the real world.

Worse still: some of the hardest conversations I have are with teenagers who have experienced predatory behaviour online – young people exposed through disappearing messages, anonymous profiles, live-location sharing. I have heard from support children who believed they were “just chatting” with a friend, only to discover the risk was far greater.

These are harms no parent – no matter how vigilant – can completely protect their child from, in an ecosystem deliberately designed to keep kids engaged at all costs.

While we’ve seen the harms among young people really accelerate in the last 10 years, we’ve also seen that when they reduce social media use for a week or more, mental health consistently improves.

I believe we need more than just parental controls and rules at home. We need systemic change. I believe the responsibility for protecting children online should not rest solely on parents. Social media companies – and governments – must be part of the solution.

Here in Aotearoa, that conversation has already begun. Last year, a new legislative proposal was introduced by National Party MP Catherine Wedd (with the support of Christopher Luxon). The Bill would require social media platforms to carry out strict age verification and prohibit individuals under-16 from having accounts on designated social media platforms and in December New Zealand’s Government released its own select committee report examining the same issue.

Even a one-week break from social media can improve wellbeing. Photo / 123rf
Even a one-week break from social media can improve wellbeing. Photo / 123rf

Beyond polls, this is part of a broader shift – governments abroad are already moving. Our proposal mirrors recent laws in places like Australia, where platforms are now required to block access to anyone under-16.

I welcome this momentum, because I know from experience how urgent the need is. When something carries a risk of harm, we put safeguards around it. That’s why we age-restrict alcohol, tobacco and gambling.

If we are serious about protecting children, we must treat this as a public health issue, not simply a moral panic. We must develop robust, carefully designed safeguards for under-16s. That means better regulation of social media platforms, strong age verification, digital literacy education in schools, investment in offline support, and a public conversation about what a healthy childhood should look like in a digital age.

I write this not from fear or moralism. I write it from the clinical front line. If the proposed law proceeds, and if we build on it with real, evidence-informed protections – not surveillance or censorship, but a safer digital environment – then we have a chance to protect our children from the now well-known harms young people face online.

Our tamariki and rangatahi, for the impact on them today and in the future, deserve nothing less.

Dr Maneesh Deva is a paediatrician at Health NZ, Waitematā. He is a member of the Paediatric Society of New Zealand, the medical adviser for KidsHealth.org.nz and an expert adviser for B416.

Catch up on the debates that dominated the week by signing up to our Opinion newsletter – a weekly round-up of our best commentary.