Opinion

How a future right bloc coalition government might be thrashed out on the seabed – Kiri Allan

Kiri Allan
Opinion by
Kiri Allan is a former Labour Party Minister who held the portfolios of Justice, Regional Development, Conservation and Emergency Management. She was the lead minister for the Cyclone Gabrielle response in Tairāwhiti. She is the founder of renewable energy company Four Directions Fund and runs KLA consultancy firm.
Opportunity leader Qiulae Wong and NZ First's Shane Jones could be in for some difficult coalition talks.
Opportunity leader Qiulae Wong and NZ First's Shane Jones could be in for some difficult coalition talks.

Fisheries has been a hot topic this election year, but how many of us saw it coming as a make-or-break issue in forming a government?

Observations were made about how Opportunity and New Zealand First were polar opposites, one wanting bottom trawling phased out and the other firmly behind it. But few scenarios put both parties in the position of needing each other to form a government.

For a party that has never sat in Parliament, Opportunity has done something unusual. It walked into coalition talks with its bottom lines already published, and one of them sits squarely on the seabed. Phasing out bottom trawling is one of five conditions leader Qiulae Wong has put to both major parties. If the special votes tighten the count, Christopher Luxon may need them both.

The reality is, Opportunity sits closer to Labour, the Greens and Te Pāti Māori on this. All three back a staged move away from bottom trawling, starting with the Hauraki Gulf or seamounts.

But National’s position is closer than many people realise. It has promised to review trawling rules in the Gulf and ban commercial fishing in the Gulf’s protected areas, and Luxon has since said he is open to a ban. Act has stopped short of a trawling ban, but its plan to end scallop dredging in the closed North Island fisheries shows some appetite to move.

New Zealand First, however, is where the real block is. Winston Peters has never named bottom trawling as one of his bottom lines, but Shane Jones has done the talking for him. During the Kaupapa Māori debate, Jones said there would be no end to bottom trawling in any government New Zealand First is part of, for as long as he is around. He called Opportunity naive and said a ban would destroy the Māori fisheries settlement.

So while bottom trawling is a bottom line, the real question is where that line is actually drawn. And just this weekend, Opportunity showed more flexibility than its rhetoric suggested.

On TVNZ 1’s Q+A, its fisheries spokeswoman and incoming MP Kayla Kingdon-Bebb said a full phase-out would take longer than five years. She set out a sequence that starts with the Gulf, moves to seamounts and then to isolated critical habitats, with the wider fleet transitioning over time.

She called the bottom line “quite reasonable”. Frankly, it is. National could put its name to that, and Act may not be far behind.

Which brings us back to Jones. His record in the portfolio matches his rhetoric. He shelved the plan to confine trawling in the Gulf to set corridors, stopped work on the Kermadec sanctuary, and parked the Fisheries Amendment Bill without ever dropping it.

Kingdon-Bebb says governing with Jones as Fisheries Minister would be very challenging, though Opportunity hasn’t ruled it out. Relations are already strained. Opportunity has said it won’t support a government with Peters as Foreign Minister, and incoming New Zealand First MP Michael Laws’ despicable remarks about Kingdon-Bebb have done nothing to build trust.

So what can Luxon do? He has a few options, and all of them come with challenges.

The first and most obvious is to take the Oceans and Fisheries portfolio off NZ First and give it to a National minister, or even to Opportunity. Peters would want something of comparable weight in return, but given Jones’ record, it is hard to see Opportunity signing up any other way.

Moving the portfolio on its own won’t be enough, though. Luxon would also need NZ First to expressly agree, in its own coalition agreement, to a staged phase-out. Without that, NZ First will oppose anything it disagrees with that isn’t written into the deal Peters signs.

I know, because I watched this happen before.

In the 2017 coalition negotiations, when New Zealand First went with Labour, Peters declined to meet the Greens at all. When the deal was announced, he was precise about the pecking order. “They’ve got a confidence and supply agreement with the Labour Party, we’ve got a coalition agreement.”

The Greens’ agreement included a commitment to use best endeavours, working alongside Māori, to establish the Kermadec Ocean Sanctuary. Jones then went on Q+A and said that without a solution New Zealand First agreed to, there would be no sanctuary. And there never was one. In 2024, as Fisheries Minister in the current Government, Jones stopped all work on it and took the bill off Parliament’s agenda.

Peters is a stickler for the agreement he signs. Promises made to another party are, in his view, the senior partner’s problem. A bottom-trawling commitment that lives only in Opportunity’s agreement will be worth exactly what New Zealand First allows it to be worth. The good news for Luxon is that Peters has kept his own powder dry on this one, and that silence gives the Prime Minister room to work.

The second option is to take the settlement seriously, because on this point Jones deserves to be heard. Iwi hold a significant share of fishing quota, much of it in deepwater species caught by trawl. It is telling that one of the loudest objections to Opportunity’s policy before the election came from Moana New Zealand, the iwi-owned fishing company, whose chief executive called it irresponsible.

A transition imposed on iwi would hollow out a Treaty settlement and would very likely end up in court. Having worked alongside iwi on settlement assets for much of my career, I know how quickly goodwill disappears when the Crown changes the value of what it handed back.

There are ways through this, and Opportunity’s own policy commits to protecting the integrity of the settlement through any transition. Build the pathway with Te Ohu Kaimoana and iwi quota owners, protect the value of settlement assets, and give iwi first access to the aquaculture investment Opportunity has promised. Do that, and New Zealand First’s objection becomes a question iwi can answer for themselves.

And if the special votes move further left, the ground shifts again. Jones has ruled out working with the left, so New Zealand First would take itself off one side of the table entirely. Opportunity would become a genuine kingmaker with a real alternative, and on this issue the left is already closer to it.

Even in a deal with the right, Opportunity could then insist on a Gulf ban passing with votes from across the House, knowing Labour, the Greens and Te Pāti Māori would back it. That raises Opportunity’s price for Luxon considerably, and New Zealand First’s veto starts to look a lot less absolute.

Until the specials are counted on November 27, we’ll all have to sit in limbo, waiting to find out whether bottom trawling is the issue that decides who governs. But if it is, Luxon would do well to remember one thing.

Opportunity may have drawn its line on the seabed, but with Winston Peters, the only line that counts is the one he signs.

Kiri Allan is a former Labour Party Minister who held the portfolios of Justice, Regional Development, Conservation and Emergency Management. She was the lead minister for the Cyclone Gabrielle response in Tairāwhiti. She is the founder of the renewable energy company Four Directions Fund and runs the KLA consultancy firm.

Catch up on the debates that dominated the week by signing up to our Opinion newsletter – a weekly round-up of our best commentary.