HDC finds Mindfull Support failed to care for high needs teen who ran away four times

The teenager ran away from Mindfull Support's care four times in two weeks. Photo / 123RF
Brianna McIlraith from the Open Justice team explains the role of the Health and Disability Commissioner to Jane Yee on Case by Case.

A law-breaking high-needs teenager who was threatening and violent towards his family was placed in specialised care to be supervised at all times.

However, in the two weeks the teenager was in the care of community mental health service Mindfull Support, he ran away four times, and they missed a doctor’s appointment and a meeting with his mother and Oranga Tamariki.

The boy’s mother complained to the Health & Disability Commissioner (HDC) and, in a decision released today, the deputy commissioner found Mindfull Support failed to provide services with “reasonable care and skill”.

In response, Mindfull Support accepted the breach of code, expressed its “deep regret” for what happened and outlined changes made in the organisation since, HDC deputy commissioner Rose Wall said.

According to the decision, the teenager was diagnosed with multiple complex developmental disorders, including autism spectrum disorder, fetal alcohol syndrome and oppositional defiant disorder.

Oranga Tamariki received reports the teenager’s family was struggling with his behaviour as he was threatening and violent towards them, breaking the law and running away.

A family meeting was held with Oranga Tamariki where it was agreed the teenager would be put into specialised, one-to-one care.

Mindfull Support was contracted to supervise the teenager short-term while long-term care was being organised, starting when he moved into an Oranga Tamariki support home last year.

Mindfull Support was supposed to support and oversee the teenager and provide a staff member to supervise him “at all times”.

‘Incompetent’ staff put teenager at ‘serious risk’, mother says

Two weeks later, the teenager’s mother complained to the HDC, saying Mindfull Support’s staff were “incompetent”, the deputy commissioner said, and their lack of care put her son at “serious risk”.

Mindfull Support responded, acknowledging shortcomings in its standard of care for the teenager and that he had run away from the whare several times, causing injuries to his feet.

Mindfull Support also admitted it missed taking the teenager to a scheduled doctor’s appointment and failed to attend a meeting with Oranga Tamariki and his mother.

Wall said Mindfull Support gave her an “extensive list” of gaps it had found in its processes and said it would no longer accept placements needing “high-complexity disability support”, with exceptions.

‘Immediate danger of harm’

Disability sector expert John Taylor, ONZM, reviewed the company’s policies and found they “provided very little useful guidance” for working with someone like the teenager.

Their practices also focused more on general mental health issues than complex developmental disorders, Wall reported Taylor saying.

It was a “moderate to severe” departure from the expected standard of care that Mindfull Support accepted the teenager’s referral without ensuring he would be safely and effectively supported, Taylor stated.

And in terms of missed appointments, he opined it was below the standard of how an organisation should operate but didn’t put anyone at any “immediate risk”.

The teenager running away, however, was “much more serious” as it happened without any “obvious” change being made to prevent it happening again.

“They ... put [the teenager] in some immediate danger of harm,” Taylor was quoted as saying in the decision.

No vulnerable child should be able to escape on their own, with the “accepted practice” being that organisations should have experienced staff to support such children.

Wall criticised Mindfull Support for agreeing to care for the teenager when they didn’t have the expertise or trained staff to do so.

However, she commended the organisation for putting new systems in place so similar failures wouldn’t happen again.

HDC’s decision opportunity to learn

In a statement to NZME, Mindfull Support managing director Mark Jones said they acknowledged and accepted the HDC’s findings.

“[We] recognise the significance of this experience for those involved.”

Jones said they had taken the HDC’s decision seriously and used it as an opportunity to strengthen their practice, reflect and learn.

Since then, they have invested in further training for their kaimahi (staff) and implemented recommendations made by the HDC, he said.

They recognised quality care involved adaptation to the individual needs of those they support and remain committed to safe, “mana-enhancing” care.

“Care that places the wellbeing of those we support at the centre of our practice.”

Ella Scott-Fleming has been a journalist for three years and previously worked at the Otago Daily Times, Gore Ensign and Metro Magazine. She has an interest in court and general reporting. She’s currently based in Auckland covering justice-related stories.

Join the NZ Herald’s Open Justice team for Case by Case, a video and podcast series examining the disputes and decisions making headlines across New Zealand.