Opinion

Has modern design become too safe? Why we miss products with personality – Glenn Dwight

Glenn Dwight
Opinion by
Glenn Dwight is the studio creative director – regional at NZME and an occasional writer for The Country.
They don't make 'em like this anymore: Glenn Dwight's beloved GEC Weltron 2001. Photo / Glenn Dwight
They don't make 'em like this anymore: Glenn Dwight's beloved GEC Weltron 2001. Photo / Glenn Dwight

Every house has that one thing guests point at and ask, “What’s that?”

Mine is a GEC Weltron 2001.

If you’ve never seen one, it looks like someone in the early 1970s was asked to design a stereo for the year 2001 and decided the future would be made entirely from spheres.

There’s a large central globe flanked by two matching speakers, looking less like a piece of home audio equipment and more like something that had escaped from a science fiction movie.

Something between a moon landing, a Bond villain’s living room and Newton’s cradle.

It’s gloriously impractical, takes up far too much room and weighs an absolute ton, but I love it anyway.

In fact, I think I love it because of all those things.

It’s bold, unapologetic and completely unlike anything you’d find in a shop today, which got me thinking: Has design got boring?

Not bad design. Not ugly design. Just ... safe and boring.

Somewhere along the way, it feels as though we stopped trying to surprise people and started trying not to offend anyone.

Walk into an appliance store today, and you’ll find rows of black, white and grey.

If a company is feeling particularly adventurous, they might release something in charcoal, because apparently that’s completely different to black.

The future, it seems, is 50 shades of sensible.

Cars used to have fins, giant chrome bumpers and colours with names like Burnt Orange and Avocado Green.

The dashboards were a glorious collection of dials, gauges, switches and knobs, and if you were really lucky there was a cassette deck with enough buttons that made playing a tape feel like you were about to launch a space shuttle.

Every car felt different.

Today, eight out of 10 cars are white, silver or black, and the dashboard is little more than a giant flat screen.

Apparently, the future isn’t flying cars. It’s driving around with an iPad glued to the dashboard.

Even kitchen appliances seem to have lost their sense of humour.

Toasters, kettles and coffee machines all arrive in the same handful of colours and all seem to be chasing the same look.

Minimalist. Clean. Scandinavian.

I still don’t really know what Scandinavian design means, but apparently it’s the answer to every design brief.

There was a time when designers seemed to wake up each morning and ask themselves, “What if we made it look like the future?”

Today the question seems to be, “How invisible can we make it?” No one saw that coming!

Maybe that’s why old Kiwi designs have become so memorable.

Take the Crown Lynn swan vase.

At the end of the day, it does exactly the same job as every other vase on Earth. It holds flowers. That’s it.

But somewhere in a design meeting, someone looked at a lump of clay and thought, “You know what this needs? A swan.”

Fifty or 60 years later, people are still hunting them down in antique shops and on Trade Me, not because they were the most practical vase ever made, but because they had a bit of personality.

Or those brightly coloured Formica kitchen tables that somehow survived generations of kids colouring in, doing homework and banging Hot Wheels together.

They weren’t trying to blend into the kitchen. They were the kitchen.

And perhaps that’s what good design used to do. It didn’t just solve a problem. It sparked your imagination.

Remember those old playground rocket ships? Every primary school seemed to have one.

Health and safety would probably have a collective panic attack if someone suggested building one today, but as kids we weren’t climbing on a few bits of painted steel.

We were astronauts. We were blasting off to the moon every lunchtime, discovering new planets before the bell rang for maths.

Today’s playgrounds are undoubtedly safer, and that’s a good thing, but they all seem to come from the same catalogue.

Everything is carefully rounded, thoughtfully engineered and almost impossible to fall off. They work perfectly.

They just don’t seem to ask quite as much of a child’s imagination.

Even fast-food restaurants seem to have had the colour turned down.

McDonald’s used to have bright red roofs, giant characters and enough primary colours to make a rainbow jealous.

Now many of them look more like modern apartments than burger restaurants.

Maybe that’s just the way the world works.

When you’re designing something for millions of people, in hundreds of countries, you probably can’t afford to be too weird. You have to appeal to almost everyone.

The trouble is, when you try to appeal to everyone, you rarely become unforgettable.

Which brings me back to the Weltron.

It wasn’t sensible. It wasn’t practical. It certainly wasn’t trying to blend into the background.

It was a designer being brave enough to ask, “What if a stereo looked like this?”

Someone could have designed a perfectly square stereo that stacked neatly on a shelf, cost less to build, and probably sold just as well.

Instead, someone decided music should come out of what looks like three giant white space helmets.

Fifty years later, complete strangers are still stopping to admire it, and I think that’s the difference between something that simply works and something that’s genuinely well designed.

Not because it was the most practical stereo ever built, but because it was memorable.

I sometimes wonder whether we’ve confused good design with invisible design.

Everything now seems designed to disappear into the background.

Speakers are built into walls, televisions are giant black rectangles and coffee machines all look as though they graduated from the same engineering school.

Individually, they’re functional designs. Collectively, they’re becoming a little forgettable.

Nothing is allowed to have personality anymore, which is strange because people have personality, and we’re naturally drawn to things that do too.

Nobody talks about the perfectly adequate toaster they owned in 1998, but they’ll happily tell you about Nana’s avocado-green fridge, the bright orange Formica table that somehow survived three generations of family dinners, or the gloriously impractical component stereo system they fell in love with and convinced themselves it was a sensible use of their student loan.

Those things became part of the family story, and perhaps that’s the real job of good design.

Not simply to make something work, but to make someone smile every time they see it. To spark a memory, start a conversation.

So, if you’re a young industrial design student wondering what the world needs next, here’s my completely unqualified advice.

Forget safe. The world already has enough sensible products.

Design something with a bit of personality.

Design something that makes people stop and point.

Give us something that people fall in love with, even if it takes up too much room, weighs a ridiculous amount or makes an accountant nervous.

Because history suggests we’ll forget the products that quietly blended into the background.

The ones we’ll remember are the ones that had the courage to stand out.