Gisborne forestry facilitator hopeful talks will conclude ahead of schedule

Gisborne Forestry Facilitator Doug Leeder was hopeful discussions would conclude before his six-month appointment ended. Background photo / Liam Clayton.
Gisborne Forestry Facilitator Doug Leeder was hopeful discussions would conclude before his six-month appointment ended. Background photo / Liam Clayton.

Gisborne’s forestry facilitator hopes his work will be completed before his six-month appointment ends, after delivering his first report to the Government this week.

Forestry Minister Todd McClay appointed Doug Leeder to help reset the “fractured” relationship between foresters, iwi, Gisborne District Council and other stakeholders.

One month into the role, Leeder has held meetings and conducted site visits to discuss consenting and land use changes in Tairāwhiti.

As part of the role, he will meet with forestry industry representatives, iwi, whenua Māori, post-settlement groups, environmental groups and the district council to identify key issues and solutions.

The appointment followed industry concerns about the council’s approach to land use change.

The changes were aimed at protecting erosion-prone land in Tairāwhiti and reducing woody debris, but there were concerns about the economic impact.

Leeder will provide land use transition recommendations to the minister by the end of March 2027.

Following his first monthly report to the minister on Wednesday, Leeder said discussions had been positive, although initial meetings continued.

Addressing differences and restoring trust between parties was important so Gisborne could make changes that benefited the community’s safety, economy and environment, he said.

“This is an issue that is best resolved by the community of Gisborne. It is your environment, it is your business community, it is your GDP, it is the wealth. And forestry has a part to play in that and I haven’t found anybody that rejects that. It’s just that it should be in the right place.”

He was encouraged that people in the forestry sector had agreed that some sites, particularly those planted following Cyclone Bola, were in the wrong place.

“They need to be taken out and what they refer to as the purple zone, either whole or in part, needs to revert or be replanted in some other form of vegetation, not plantation forestry. [I] haven’t met anybody who disagrees with that. It’s merely the process of getting there.”

Part of that process was rehabilitating skid sites made before 2018 and harvesting inappropriate plantations, he said.

“To ignore that is an inherent risk for the Gisborne community in terms of future weather events whereby, as was exemplified last time [Cyclone Gabrielle], these inappropriate geography plantations end up falling down the hills ... they’ve got to be removed.”

As cyclone season approached, Leeder said managing historic woody debris in stream headwaters should be prioritised. Management should not be constrained by “strict adherence to conditions within legislation”.

“Christmas is coming up, government industry shuts down, but you can’t change the weather. If it’s urgent enough and the risk is high, then we’ve got to find a way to get in, clean that stuff up, so the communities of Gisborne and Tairāwhiti don’t suffer the consequences of Cyclone Gabrielle and the other ones that followed it.”

McClay said he was looking forward to hearing from Leeder in the coming months and wanted to see all parties working together in a constructive and structured way.

Gisborne Mayor Rehette Stoltz and council chief executive Nedine Thatcher Swann were looking forward to a second meeting with Leeder.

“Our ultimate goal ... is to be in a position where our region is healthy both financially and environmentally,” Stoltz said.

Eastland Wood Council chairman Julian Kohn said initial discussions with Leeder had been positive.

Land use decisions made by previous governments or generations were no longer fit for Tairāwhiti, but changing use would take time, he said.

“Council actions which close down harvesting and the wider industry won’t deliver a sensible and affordable land use transition, so we’re pleased to be having a conversation about how we can work together to achieve this.”

The council was committed to working with central and local government to find a solution “where forestry can continue to thrive in the Tairāwhiti region”, he said.

Mana Taiao Tairāwhiti spokesman Manu Caddie hoped to see clear discharge limits and a framework for managing those conditions.

Relying on industry best practice for improvement would not be a solution, he said.

Caddie hoped Leeder would advocate for the minister to progress a rejected land use change plan, which could allow up to 100,000ha to be converted to native forest or other land uses.

Leeder’s discussions are taking place alongside an independent review ordered by Gisborne District Council for its consenting practices and industry compliance.

Leeder said the review was independent of his role, but there could be overlap between the two pieces of work, so a future discussion would be needed.

LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.