Loafers Lodge fire trial: Crown says silenced alarm let second fire spread

Pictured (clockwise from top left) are Barry Collins, Marie Murphy, Gregory Mein and Glenn McAllister who are on trial in the High Court at Wellington after the fatal fire at Loafers Lodge. Photo / RNZ
Pictured (clockwise from top left) are Barry Collins, Marie Murphy, Gregory Mein and Glenn McAllister who are on trial in the High Court at Wellington after the fatal fire at Loafers Lodge. Photo / RNZ
  • In May 2023, a fatal fire at Loafers Lodge in the Wellington suburb of Newtown killed five people.
  • In December, Esarona Lologa was convicted and sentenced on five counts of murder and one of arson for lighting the deadly blaze.
  • Now company director Gregory Bruce Mein, property manager Marie Louise Murphy, and the building fire warden and residents Glenn Brendan McAllister, and Barry Charles Collins, who were responsible for the fire alarm, are on trial in the High Court at Wellington
  • Each faces five charges of manslaughter by omission to discharge their legal duty (being a dangerous thing), or five alternative charges of manslaughter by unlawful acts.

If the fire safety system was working as it should have been at Loafers Lodge, five residents killed in a deadly blaze could have escaped the boarding house and survived.

That’s the view of the Crown, which opened its case today against four people who were allegedly responsible for the operation, management and governance of the fire safety system inside Loafers Lodge.

In her opening address in the High Court at Wellington, acting Crown Solicitor Stephanie Bishop told the jury the fire that killed the five men was the second one that was lit at the boarding house that night.

The first fire was lit about 10.30pm on level 3 by Esarona Lologa.

Residents discovered it and put it out.

But Bishop told the jury the smoke from that fire was enough to activate the building alarm system, accompanied by a recorded message telling residents to evacuate.

The smoke doors closed and the smoke extraction system activated.

Bishop said the alarm was silenced and no attempt was made to ascertain if there was a fire.

That meant the smoke and heat detectors on the third floor were turned off and needed to be reset before they could be activated again.

Later that night, Lologa returned to Loafers Lodge and set a second fire.

Bishop told the jury that at 12 minutes past midnight on May 16, 2023, a fire was lit in a wardrobe in a hallway on the third floor of the building.

Because the alarm on the third floor was silenced and wasn’t reset, it didn’t sound. That meant the fire grew without warning to those closest to it.

She said it took 13 minutes for the building fire alarm system to activate. When it did, it only sounded on the lower floors.

In those 13 minutes, the fire gave off smoke that spread through the building to the mezzanine floor on the fourth floor.

The Crown says smoke-stop doors that should have been shut remained open. It was only when smoke was detected on the lower floors that the alarm system activated and the doors were activated.

But in those 13 minutes, the Crown says, the flames had taken hold. A 111 call was made just before the alarm activated and firefighters arrived five minutes later, 18 minutes after the fire was lit.

Bishop said firefighters were greeted by a chaotic and confronting scene, with black smoke billowing from the upper floors of the 1970s building. There were reports of people trapped inside.

Residents had climbed on to the roof; one even jumped on to a neighbouring roof.

Loafers Lodge on fire.
Loafers Lodge on fire.

Bishop said firefighters managed to evacuate some residents, but were unable to reach the mezzanine floor, pushed back by the intense heat and thick smoke.

Firefighters in two aerial fire engines had to put hoses into the upper floors before crews could re-enter the building.

Upon reaching the mezzanine floor, firefighters found the bodies of Kenneth Barnard, 67, Liam James Hockings, 50, Peter Glenn O’Sullivan, 64, Melvin Joseph Parun, 68, and Michael Wahrlich, 67, known by many as Mike the Juggler.

Bishop said it was later established they’d died from smoke inhalation.

Two-year investigation

After the fire, police and Fire and Emergency New Zealand began a two-year investigation that led to two trials related to Loafers Lodge.

The first trial focused on Esarona Lologa, who was found guilty of five charges of murder.

Bishop said this second trial concerned the systems at Loafers Lodge and those responsible for managing the fire safety system in the building.

In the High Court at Wellington, Gregory Bruce Mein, Marie Louise Murphy, Glenn Brendan McAllister and Barry Charles Collins each face five charges of gross negligence causing death.

They also face, in the alternative, five charges of breaching health and safety, thereby committing manslaughter.

All four defendants deny the charges.

The Crown says if the fire safety system was working as it should have been, the residents could have escaped and survived.

The Crown says it was a series of failings and unsafe practices over a decade that led to the men’s deaths.

The jury heard the fire safety system wasn’t connected or monitored, leaving residents to call emergency services.

The Crown says the failings and unsafe practices of those involved in the management, governance and operation of Loafers Lodge accumulated and undermined the building’s fire safety systems.

Had they been in place, the Crown said, the building could have been evacuated sooner, and firefighters called earlier, possibly preventing the tragedy that unfolded.

Loafers Lodge was built in 1971 and converted to accommodation in 2005 with 92 rooms, housing up to about 100 people.

Bishop told the court Collins was the resident who silenced the alarm after the first fire. He returned to his room, making no effort to investigate or reset the alarm.

To silence the alarm he used a key that was given to him by Murphy, the property manager, who paid residents to do odd jobs at Loafers.

The Crown said that included silencing and resetting the fire alarm, which should only have been done by Fire and Emergency New Zealand or trained professionals.

However, the cost of paying for the service, coupled with the frequency of false alarms, meant that over time it had fallen on residents to do it.

McAllister also had a key to silence the alarm; he was also the building’s fire warden and her second in charge.

Bishop said McAllister was also supposed to help residents in an emergency, but he didn’t evacuate the building that night and stayed in his room, only emerging after the second fire had taken hold and calling 111.

Mein was the sole director of the company that operated Loafers Lodge and had a duty to ensure the fire safety system was working as it should have.

Bishop said as the company’s director, he had legal responsibility to ensure the safe operation of Loafers Lodge, but he took an arm’s-length approach to his obligations, which allowed the tragedy to occur.

Tomorrow the Crown will finish its address, with defence counsel expected to make short submissions to the jury.

The jury trial before Justice Helen McQueen is set down for eight weeks.

Catherine Hutton is an Open Justice reporter, based in Wellington. She has worked as a journalist at the Waikato Times and RNZ. Most recently she was working as a media adviser at the Ministry of Justice.

Join the NZ Herald’s Open Justice team for Case by Case, a video and podcast series examining the disputes and decisions making headlines across New Zealand.