Former police officer sentenced for deceiving his way into becoming a frontline cop

When Dominic Sulu-Magele was applying for a job with the New Zealand Police and was asked if he’d ever been part of an employment investigation, he lied and wrote “no”.
But the lie didn’t stop there.
He didn’t mention his previous job at Corrections, where he was fired for “serious misconduct”, and listed another job on his CV to cover the period he had worked there.
He then falsely told police that while he had completed a Corrections course, he had never actually worked as an officer.
Sulu-Magele, who was later charged with deceiving police to gain employment, also worked for the Ministry of Justice.
He was employed by the ministry as a court registrar at the time he applied to work for the police.
In 2023, Sulu-Magele’s application to join the force was successful and he worked as an officer for almost three years.
However, the 34-year-old’s run came to an end when he was spotted at a prison while there on police business and recognised as a former Corrections worker.
This week, Sulu-Magele appeared in Manukau District Court where he applied for a discharge without conviction, arguing a conviction would make it difficult for him to secure future employment.
‘I didn’t know what to say’
The court heard that Sulu-Magele was employed as a Corrections officer by Serco and was based at Auckland South Correctional Facility from May 2019 to February 2021.
An employment investigation was launched against him in April 2020 due to undisclosed “aspects of his employment”. He was also found in possession of letters from prisoners without explanation.
He was fired on notice in February the following year.
More than two years later, Sulu-Magele applied for a job with the NZ Police.
He intentionally removed any mention of his employment with Serco from his CV, replacing it with a job he had previously held at end-to-end information management company The Information Management Group (TIMG).
The deception continued in August 2023, when Sulu-Magele underwent an interview with police. He admitted participating in a 12-week Corrections course but told the interviewer that, despite completing it, he had never worked as a Corrections officer.

The court heard that on the day of his police recruitment interview, Sulu-Magele texted his friend: “Uce, I frozen when she asked but I told her I only did the initial 12-week training and moved to the ministry.”
He also sent a text to his partner.
“Baby I’m so scared of Serco [Corrections employer]. I should have just said it, but I didn’t know what to say I just froze.”
Sulu-Magele also completed referee documents for two supervisors at TIMG and the Ministry of Justice, listing inaccurate dates of employment to conceal the period he was employed by Serco.
As a result of the deception, Sulu-Magele joined the police in October 2023.
However, red flags were raised in May last year when the then officer was working on a job collecting seized drugs at Auckland South Correctional Facility and was recognised as a previous employee.
Police were then notified about the circumstances of his termination.
‘A breach of trust’
In court, defence lawyer Benjamin Mugisho argued that despite Sulu-Magele’s otherwise unblemished record, his plans to secure a landscaping job in Australia would be jeopardised.
He had a job lined up in Brisbane, where his family lived, but it was conditional on him not being convicted.
However, Mugisho said Sulu-Magele, who was due to marry his fiancée, was open to any work that would provide for his family.
In opposition to the discharge without conviction, Crown lawyer Thomas Riley argued the matter shouldn’t hinge on a single job offer.
“One letter from one employer which he’s asking to place significant weight on is not reflective of the wider position he may be in,” he said.
Judge Sanjay Patel described Sulu-Magele’s offending as “unsophisticated but effective” and, while noting his previous good character, said it was a “breach of trust”.
“It might be different if it didn’t speak to culpability or character; however, in this case the offending reflects both of these things.”
While Sulu-Magele had argued his sister’s cancer diagnosis in May 2023 had “clouded his judgment”, the judge acknowledged Sulu-Magele actually had two close family members diagnosed with cancer but said his application with police was “well-advanced by then”.
Judge Patel described Sulu-Magele’s actions as a “continuation of dishonesty”.
He said Sulu-Magele had a nine-month application period in which to come clean.
“It was deliberate and calculated and not made on the spur of the moment.
“It was a breach of trust which he built with police on goodwill.”
In addressing the discharge application, Judge Patel found that while a conviction would have a “serious negative impact on future employment”, it was up to an employer to make decisions based on a person’s history.
He declined to grant the application and instead sentenced him to 100 hours of community work, factoring in Sulu-Magele’s remorse and good character and noting his Samoan heritage and connections to church communities.
At the hearing, discussions were held about Sulu-Magele’s ability to work for the Ministry of Justice, which was not a part of the prosecution.
Sulu-Magele had said in an affidavit he “could not recall” whether his job application included information on his Serco employment or whether he was asked about previous employment.
He claimed he was never asked for a CV, references, job history or a one-on-one interview.
Judge Patel questioned the credibility of his claims, saying, “It would be most unusual if that was correct. I know there’s no contrary evidence but on the face of it, is it credible?”
“Don’t even supermarkets require CV and work history? This is a MOJ role dealing with privacy and people’s private information.”