Opinion

Christchurch’s One New Zealand Stadium reaches 32.5C as six treated for heat-related issues – John MacDonald

John MacDonald
Opinion by
John MacDonald is the Canterbury Mornings host on Newstalk ZB Christchurch.
Fans sweltered as it hit 32.5C inside One New Zealand Stadium. Photo / Photosport
NZ Herald Morning Headlines | Monday, November 2, 2026. Politicians prepare for the NZ Election this week. Video / NZ Herald

The armchair experts are having a field day.

They’re saying the design of Christchurch’s One New Zealand Stadium is flawed, after the temperature inside reached 32.5C during the Labour Day NPC rugby final.

It was the second time in a fortnight that the heat level exceeded 30C and saw play stopped twice for hydration breaks and the halftime break extended.

I was at the match on Labour Day – so I know what it was like. Initially, my thinking was that we needed to get a grip and accept that a venue with a predominantly clear roof would get a bit hot sometimes.

That, at the time of the match, it was 25C outside. So of course it was going to be warm inside. I knew that even before I turned up.

Instead of pointing any fingers, I thought we would just have to learn from the experience and dress for the conditions. Like we do when we go to outdoor venues, such as Hagley Oval. Wear less. Get the sunscreen out. All of that.

But, after chewing it over with callers to my radio show and finding out that six people at the stadium on Labour Day were assessed and treated for heat-related issues, I’ve come around to the idea that something has to be done.

Because what if someone succumbed to the heat and fell down those steep stairs in the stands?

Which raises questions about what changes could, realistically, be made and who should pay.

The money part of it is clear, in my mind. Which I’ll get to.

Finding a solution is going to be the real challenge. Because, from what stadium boss Caroline Harvie-Teare has been telling me, all current options for cooling the place down have been exhausted.

During the NPC final, the stadium’s louvre windows were open and the fans were running at full power. Bearing in mind that the fans are designed to circulate air, not control the temperature inside the venue.

Harvie-Teare tells me the stadium does have pitch-side systems which can spray mist to bring the temperature down. But they can’t be used when the stadium is in use, because they’re too loud. And they can’t be used ahead of sporting matches, because the moisture would make the pitch too slippery for the players.

She also can’t rule out the heat issue making the stadium unusable at times, telling me this last week: “Now that we know and have operated the stadium for six months, maybe we do need to look at certain times of the day when we make the venue unavailable. If it’s going to be warmer, we can’t be playing sport in the daytime. We don’t control broadcast and we don’t control the draw but we can certainly have influence on how those decisions are made.”

So something, obviously, has to be done.

There are all sorts of suggestions being made. Everyone seems to have a solution. I’m going to leave that to the experts.

But one thing I do know is that Christchurch City Council needs to drop any ideas it might have about making the people who designed and built the stadium pay for any remedial work.

While councillor Sam MacDonald thinks the overheating issue is a teething problem and councillor Yani Johanson thinks it’s a design flaw that needs fixing, they both agree that ratepayers shouldn’t carry the can.

What they need to remember is that building the stadium cost less than what was budgeted for. The council was expecting it to cost $683 million. But the final cost was $656.5m, so a saving of $26.6m.

That’s where the money for any fix or alteration should come from.

Trying to chase the outfits that designed and built the stadium would be pointless and only mean ratepayer money going down the drain on legal bills.

Proving any shortcomings could be difficult and even then, knowing the construction sector, the companies would fight any claims tooth and nail.

Yes, in theory, they should carry some responsibility if any flaws in the design and construction of the stadium can be identified and proven.

But, if we want something done about it without a long, drawn-out bunfight and without compromising use of the stadium – which is already exceeding its expected economic impact – then the council needs to bite the bullet and get on with it.

Catch up on the debates that dominated the week by signing up to our Opinion newsletter – a weekly round-up of our best commentary.